News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by thewhitetulip on Monday September 25, 2017 @11:08PM (#15335840)
It's highly ironic that the ruling party is now receding to the level of the previous govt that they destroyed in the 2014 elections. The UPA also used to offer free things to poor and used to do minority appeasement two years before the elections.

The thing is, this govt came to power in all but 4 Indian states and it has just destroyed the economy. The GDP rate has skid down to 4% just as the previous PM, Dr Manmohan Singh said it would and at that time, everyone mocked him.

Guess who is laughing now?

The current govt has failed absolutely at every way, the Demonetization exercise was a total and epic disaster and it shocked the economy without fulfilling it's motive of "war on black money" as 99% of the invalid notes were returned to the RBI.

But that's not the only problem, the problem is, this govt takes decisions just to win elections. DeMo happened just before UP elections after the "surgical strike" lost it's glitter in the media.

Even the most ardent supporters of the current govt are asking the question, if the earlier govt was able to keep the GDP growth rate above 7 in horrible world economic condition, why is the current govt unable to do so even when the crude oil prices are half of what it was earlier?

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by _jgdh on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @02:03AM (#15336539)
I've been predicting this govt would do poorly long before they were elected to power. Having said that, you're completely mistaken about this issue. It's the govt's job to provide infrastructure. If all households are electrified by 2019 that makes a massive difference to people's lives - lights and fans at night improve the quality of life, children can study, phones can be charged etc. Further, this actually increases the rate of growth because these people will likely earn and consume more. Honestly, I'm thrilled about this.

Just to play Modi's advocate for a second, I think replacing all indirect taxes with one indirect tax will benefit Indian businesses in the long run. Although it will be painful for now, especially for corner cases the govt hasn't thought about (exporters having to pay tax and getting a refund months later) it will get better with time. I predict that the software will improve to the point that filing the tax will become more or less automated. India is taking the hit to growth today to reap the benefit of tax simplification 2+ years from now.

As for demonetization, I doubt even Modi's mother could spin that positively. It was a disaster, no doubt. Perhaps the tiny silver lining that was completely unintended is that most urban merchants accept digital payments now.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by thewhitetulip on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @06:37AM (#15337529)
tdlr: the scheme is good, but through the scheme he is hiding the fact that he has reinstated the economic advisory committee and it is too convinent to do this just as the nation has begun to realize that they were mistaken about his leadership.

long:

I am not saying that electrification scheme is wrong. I am merely pointing out that there have been too many coincidences.

1. surgical strike happened just a few months before UP elections 2. when surgical strike's glory failed, DeMo happened just a few months before UP election 3. in the first 2 months of DeMo 80% notes were returned, RBI counted 80% notes within 2months but they took 8months to calculate the rest of the notes? 4. RBI report came at the backdrop of the worst floods Mumbai faced since 2006.

I am not mistaken about anything, my good sir. I am saying that this govt doesn't do work and it hides it's failures strategically so that people have something else to talk about.

Remember the jibe "hard work is more important than harvard"? Our great PM dissolved the economic advisory committee which UPA had in place.

now he has reinstated the committee and he announced that during his 2.5Billion $ scheme (which was already present with a deadline of 2018) so that people will talk about electrification but not his utter failure to save the economy.

He has failed the country and the GDP is ruined despite good economic conditions and all they are doing is hiding their laundry under the guises of promotions and even more promises.

and I had said way back during the general elections (to my clg friends) that it would take 3hrs for bhakts to realize how wrong they were and now almost everyone have opened their eyes!

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by addicted on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @09:07AM (#15338256)
I’d rather a leader who responds to having made a mistake by fixing it than someone who digs in deeper.

In fact, I’d rather have a leader who acknowledges and fixes their mistakes than one who never makes any.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by thewhitetulip on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @11:12AM (#15339343)
Me too! I'd rather have MMS as PM again!
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by yinyang_in on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @02:03PM (#15341107)
MMS aren't we tired of corruption. Aren't we tired of scared image in India. MMS has always been puppet( his tenure during PM) and good guy in hands of SG and RG ; what are we upto.

Man who can't stand for himself, is he going to lead us !

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by vthallam on Monday September 25, 2017 @11:58PM (#15336016)
>The GDP rate has skid down to 4% just as the previous PM, Dr Manmohan Singh said it would and at that time, everyone mocked him.

The GDP growth rate has been low from 2012 to 2014[1]. And anything a former prime minister tells about the opposition party, I would take with a pinch of salt.

Also, the power ministry has done a great job over the last few years. They distributed LED bulbs across the country which reduced power consumption http://www.ujala.gov.in/

They might have made mistakes, but I would choose this govt over the corrupt congress any day.

1:http://statisticstimes.com/economy/gdp-growth-of-india.php

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by kamaal on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @07:31AM (#15337732)
>>And anything a former prime minister tells about the opposition party, I would take with a pinch of salt.

A former prime minister who was a distinguished professor of economics at top universities. Has served at the seats of world's top financial institutions and councils. And led the leadership in multiple tenures of Indias central bank. Plus being the finance minister and responsible for drafting and implementing Indias most succesful open market policy ever. This is all mildly putting his career highlights.

How quickly we forget the whole concept of expertise.

These days you go and see experts even in case of a throat itch. Here, we are talking of redoing the entire country's monetary system.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by pkhagah on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @10:06AM (#15338737)
Issue bigger then demonetization is NPA. Banks need appx. $50 billion USD to comply with the new norms. These huge NPA's are given in UPA2 term. Your beloved Manmohan Singh didn't utter a word against this. When the banks are looted systematically.
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by kamaal on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @11:36PM (#15344731)
Finance minister and the PM himself said that they did DeMo to demonstrate their heroics in killing black money.

Should I believe them or you.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by vthallam on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @09:04AM (#15338229)
For every expert who contradicts, I can point to equal number of similar distinguished people who can support the whole idea of demonetization.
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by thewhitetulip on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @06:40AM (#15337541)
So you want the PM to destroy our economy even in favourable economic conditions where there hasn't been a drought.

I shudder to think what his brand of Jumla economics will do if they face problems in the next two years. It is clear that they have next to 0 understanding of anything other than giving speeches and 'inaugurating' things which were actually built by congress.

I'll settle for RaGa as PM but not a party which takes decisions just for winning elections. and FYI all the LED/Solar schemes were started by Congress, he has just changed names, like 19/28 schemes or something like that.

and not to mention the utter hypocrisy and the contempt they use to address the middle class.

during UPA time the crude oil prices were 150$ per barrel and petrol was 70Rs per liter, not the crude oil prices are 50$ barrel and still prices of petrol are going up.

and at the same time they are wanting that India becomes a manufacturing hub.

I wonder which school they went to, or if they even went to a school for clearly they don't realize that manufacturing industry works on petrol, everything runs on petrol and petrol isn't used by "people are aren't starving like the car and bike owners"

The MLA aren't starving either, why don't they give up their subsidies?

BJP is doing exactly all the things that they opposed when they were in opposition, rise in LPG price, petrol etal.

petrol diesel ki pad rahi hai maar, nahi chaiye BJP sarkar

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by virtuabhi on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @08:31AM (#15338021)
> petrol diesel ki pad rahi hai maar, nahi chaiye BJP sarkar

Please keep idiotic comments like this outside HN

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by thewhitetulip on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @11:17AM (#15339386)
Swami Vivekanand said "talk to people in a language that they understand".

With all due respect, If you or others can't understand the obvious sarcasm then that's on you, not me.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by virtuabhi on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @05:59PM (#15342885)
What you referred to ("petrol diesel ki pad rahi hai maar, nahi chaiye BJP sarkar") is not sarcasm. Unfortunately, you do not seem to be capable of accepting mistakes and learning from them, so I will stop the thread here.
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by thewhitetulip on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @10:58PM (#15344577)
Oh, I do and that was satire not sarcasm.

I accept my mistakes when people aren't a condescending and especially not those who are too stupid to understand satire and if I am talking to stupid people then I ought to write stupid comments, for they don't even understand satire then what else can I hope to write which they understand?

And yes, this "stupid" discussion is over.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by harigov on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @12:48AM (#15336267)
Minor correction. They are NOT offering free electricity. Just free electric connections. Consumers have to pay the monthly bill on their own. Also, GDP growth under previous govt was accompanied by a significant increase in inflation and govt debt so it is not exactly apples-to-apples comparison.
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by kumarvvr on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @04:54AM (#15337178)
Providing power to homes is the job of the govt. I don't think it can be considered as 'freebies'. It's the responsibility of the state to use tax money to ensure improvement in the living conditions of all it's citizens.
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @05:31AM (#15337301)
> Providing power to homes is the job of the govt

This is far from universally accepted. If anything, as countries modernise and their institutions develop, the trend appears to lean towards the state not doing this.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by opencl on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @10:27AM (#15338914)
What countries have developed electric infrastructure (or really, infrastructure in general) without the state being heavily involved? Not trying to be dismissive, I haven't seen anything about this and my quick attempts at googling don't seem to turn up anything.
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by thewhitetulip on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @11:00PM (#15344585)
You know, Florida has an electricity generation company called FPL and it is private and because of the lobbying, the people of Florida coudn't use their solar panels when they faced the hurricane a few weeks back.

I am happy that our govt controls electricity, roads, railway because if they don't then such things will be run for profit and there will be lobbying which is never good for a democracy.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by Reason077 on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @09:33AM (#15338452)
"Demonetization exercise was a total and epic disaster and it shocked the economy without fulfilling it's motive of "war on black money" as 99% of the invalid notes were returned to the RBI."

That was exactly the point. The fact that 99% of notes were returned indicates that demonetization was a success.

The whole idea was to stop large cash transactions from occurring in secrecy where they cannot be taxed.

Any economic problems resulting from demonetization are short-term. In the long run, moving to electronic transactions will be of great benefit to India.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by thewhitetulip on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @11:15AM (#15339371)
Ghanta. The goal was to "eradicate black money" but they utterly failed in eradicating black money as all black money was converted into white in a BIG blow to the exercise & all black money has entered the banking system.

1% is the "destroyed black money"

If this was the case then BJP is a big damn liar as they kept claiming that congress did scams well, if there is only 1% black money Congress is full of saints.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by kapilkaisare on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @01:51PM (#15341000)
For the uninitiated, 'ghanta' translates idiomatically to 'bullshit'.

Been a while since I last heard that word. :)

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by vaseem on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @02:59PM (#15341573)
actually it translates to 'balls'
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by thewhitetulip on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @11:00PM (#15344590)
How so?
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by Reason077 on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @11:47AM (#15339680)
Money that is brought into the banking system isn't "black" any longer. It can be seen, counted, taxed.
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by 31reasons on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @10:07AM (#15338743)
I think they should just make any cash transactions more than 1000 rupees illegal.
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by awongh on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @12:19AM (#15336124)
Can you elaborate on the "disaster" of demonitization? The only things I've read have been breathless tech press coverage about online transactions and such.
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by balladeer on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @01:19AM (#15336395)
Oh, it was a disaster both technically and economically and it turned out to be a humanitarian disaster in many rural areas. Made life hell and since it was not even half baked (it wasn't put in the oven at all) it affected people worse than anyone would have anticipated, if at all. It was a whimsical decision followed by distorted data floated around as facts, and then rumours, FUD being released, leaked and misrepresented from the Govt or related sources.

I have not really done any elaboration here. I would just link you to https://www.google.com/search?q=how+india%27s+demonetization.... I can answer follow up questions if any (or hopefully others might pitch in whether disagree or agree). I am assuming you are not from the place. I am not into finance and economics so I will try my best. I have one foot in an Indian metro and another in a village near a small town and I travel extensively during that time (in fact I happened to backpack across a fair portion of the country for 2 months during that period).

And yeah, a lot of initial tech coverage just limited themselves to the failed online transactions (and similar issues in the cities) and completely ignored what was happening to the rural people and people in the small towns where most of India lives and does business. It was far far far worse.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by sarang23592 on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @01:50AM (#15336496)
I am from a small town in India(Jammu). It was not as bad for the people you are making it out to be. And what you are googling is a confirmation bias. You can search how demonetization was actually impactful and you will see the corresponding results.
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by geraltofrivia on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @02:10AM (#15336562)
Okay, so, apart from the entire thing being dragged around by the international press, and Indian netizens, apart from countless stories of discomfort, there are afew things that stand out, which would paint the entire demonetization move in a bad light nonetheless. I'm no expert, and I'm recalling most of what I've read. Here goes:

1. Promises Promises: The PM unveiled the scheme abruptly (no woes here), promising people discomfort for a week... Then two weeks... Then a month... And then literally six months. You can see how things slipped out of controls as the initial "discomfort deadline" was a mere week.

2. Impeccable Planning: The new Rs 2000 note was not made to-size with the current ATM standards. As a result, the entire nation's ATM machines had to be modified. That is so big a blunder, it felt like I was reading The Onion when I read that one.

3. The Verdict: This one was the real eye opener. I was sympathetic to the entire humdrum, the months of inconvenience caused to everyone. (Full disclosure, I was not in India during the time. IMO, I can still have an opinion on the matter). But if it really did solve some parts of the black money problem, some good would have come out of it. In the annual RBI report, it was mentioned that ~99% of the currency flowing in the form of Rs 500, Rs 1000 notes was returned back to the banks. This implies that 99% of the currency is now legal, white money. That less than 1% of the currency was unaccounted for, and that's the money gained by the RBI since those notes are now rendered invalid. Source: http://www.thehindu.com/business/Economy/only-12-of-demoneti...

In this light then, I can't help but think of the entire process to be shaky.

Edit: The link was an AMP link. Sorry about that.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by sifar on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @03:31AM (#15336856)
I think the government/RBI were fully aware of the period of discomfort. Without incurring additional debt, the RBI could print only so much new currency as equal to the amount of old currency returned. This was the main reason for the crash crunch for the new currency, the ATMs being dry. Somehow nobody communicated this to the people.

Now they may have underestimated the logistical issues to verify how much currency was returned.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by vijaybritto on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @02:00AM (#15336527)
A small town in Jammu doesn't represent the entire country you know. The impact of demonetization is incredibly bad on the poor. The GDP has come down. The govt acknowledges it in indirect ways like increasing the fiscal spending by 500 Billion rupees. It's insane that even educated people don't accept the truth and get carried away by emotional rhetoric. What are you all expecting exactly as economic slowdown? This is it!
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by sarang23592 on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @02:19AM (#15336612)
>A small town in Jammu doesn't represent the entire country you know

I never said it does and I never said that demonetization was successful. I was just replying with first hand experience that impact of demonetization was not too bad for the people from what I saw and that the google will show what you want it to show.

>It's insane that even educated people don't accept the truth and get carried away by emotional rhetoric

What made you think that I got carried away by emotional rhetoric?

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by vijaybritto on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @03:31AM (#15336861)
> What made you think that I got carried away by emotional rhetoric?

Refusing to accept or understand failure means that there is something else that makes you argue for it even when there are explicit results for everyone to see. Also it was not directed at you personally, rather at anyone who supports this decision still.

Again, the amount of impact it has caused is there for everyone to see. The numbers are out. Arguing anymore about this is like arguing with flat earth society. Let's not downplay the Poor's suffering.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by foo101 on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @06:31AM (#15337512)
> Again, the amount of impact it has caused is there for everyone to see.

That's your opinion. Two people have already mentioned that what they saw is inconsistent with what you claim everyone can see.

Do you have a personal anecdote to share that describes your experience? If yes, do so.

Do you have substantive evidence that your experience has been the experience of the majority? If yes, cite such statistics from trusted sources.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by vijaybritto on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @12:41PM (#15340319)
I think they can intentionally dismiss it. I'm not making up anything. So many verified sources have already published multiple articles. Just Google 'impact of demonetisation' which is obviously an unbiased query.
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by knowThySelfx on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @02:56AM (#15336723)
He is talking about his own experience. What is your own experience? Leave out what you read from MSM. From what I have seen and experienced, It isn't as bad as whats reported in the media. There were some initial hiccups but otherwise things are fine. A decrease in bootlegging and other evasive/illegal activities must've been included in this "slowdown".

The thing which is currently confusing and causing slowdown is GST implementation. Most businesses don't know what to do. This is to be expected. Feels like the govt wasn't fully ready with a streamlined implementation.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by vijaybritto on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @03:21AM (#15336820)
This is incredibly annoying. What do you mean it's all okay? For whom? You think the economy slowed down immediately after GST? No. GST's effect is yet to come in full flow. Dude the GDP has come to 6% in such a huge economy? You think that's a hiccup? Why aren't you all accepting numbers? If there is a small hiccup, then why is there a prolonged negative emotion in the country? If you ask how, see the recent attacks by the govt on a weak leader like Rahul Gandhi, this plan to electrify all villages. There was a plan to clean Ganga, clean the entire country as well. We all know how that went. If you don't accept failure you'll never grow.
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by richardknop on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @08:37AM (#15338060)
6% is a huge GDP growth tbh. Here in Europe everybody celebrates when Germany grows by 1.5% as it means EU economy is booming.

I understand that India is a developing country so growth should be faster but 6% is not that bad.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by knowThySelfx on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @04:33AM (#15337108)
Read what I wrote twice. Where did I say or mean its "all ok"?
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by foo101 on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @06:26AM (#15337488)
Nobody implied it is okay. Read carefully before responding. This is Hacker News, not your Facebook timeline.

Describe your experience anecdotally or provide citations when you make broad claims about the country's experience, and speak substantially in both cases.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by intended on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @06:41AM (#15337548)
I have lost or cancelled a truly significant number of orders for capital goods as a concequence of GST alone.

This is on the backs of a ridiculous plan to demonitize cash, in a cash based economy.

We saw an immediately slow down when GST hit. Certain sectors were entirely dead - real estate - for a while.

It’s been nearly 6 months, and the pain in the informal sector is now whip lashing its way into the formal economy.

Indians are born children - you are not taking toys away to make them behave.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by neeleshs on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @10:16AM (#15338815)
Real estate transactions in india are one of the largest areas where tax cheating and black money goes in to. It's not surprising the sector was hit. I'm not sure if it's a bad thing.
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by knowThySelfx on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @07:10AM (#15337651)
I understand the real estate part. Perhaps it (real estate) needed some regulation (though this is probably not the right way). It was getting out of hand and out of reach of most Indians. Tax evasion is a real problem we face.

Sorry for your loss pal. Lets hope things look up soon.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by sifar on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @03:11AM (#15336781)
What you concluded by what you saw around you is a sort of confirmation bias too.It speaks about the wide socio-economic divide in India which to me is more acute than the US income inequality. People around you may not be affected because the grocer would provide them things on free credit or use digital payment means. Not so for the daily wage laborers, who would have to incur debt just to buy food. This was the biggest tragedy and irony of demonetization - the very people for whose sake this was done, suffered the most.It also provided the same people as armies via whom one can launder the cash hoardings.

Communities/businesses who had good credit networks survived/weren't affected, those who didn't suffered.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by thewhitetulip on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @06:48AM (#15337577)
>This was the biggest tragedy and irony of demonetization - the very people for whose sake this was done, suffered the most.It also provided the same people as armies via whom one can launder the cash hoardings

it wasn't done to help poor people. it was a ploy to win elections in UP and a successful one at that.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by sarang23592 on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @04:52AM (#15337173)
> What you concluded by what you saw around you is a sort of confirmation bias too

Fair Point.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by balladeer on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @04:05AM (#15336987)
I am not googling it. I shared the search link for the commenter who asked about it. I am from a village in Bihar and family lives in nearby small towns. When the announcement for demonetisation was done I was asleep in a train to Hubli (from Bangalore) and I woke up to it with approx Rs 150 in my wallet (~3 dollars) and I backpacked across north and north east India for the next two months. I had left for the trip the previous day. I lived it as close as it could be in my capacity and mind it I was in a very privileged position. Really privileged and it was still very difficult. I could finally get some cash from a bank manager in Hubli who was a friend's relative and I went on.

But I agree on the bias part I should have just suggested to search "India + demonetisation" and only suggested to play with the search terms as in adding words like "effects", advantages, disadvantages etc.

> Jammu

And the villages and towns I am talking about (esp. in the hinterland and the North East) are something entirely else if I consider Jammu a small town (I say this relatively)

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by puranjay on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @03:51AM (#15336925)
You are delusional if you think Jammu is a small town. It has a population of half a million, nearly twice as much as Shimla.

Small towns are towns like Barmer, Dausa, etc.

Remember: nearly 70% of India lives in rural areas. Your "small town" of half a million doesn't reflect the reality of these 900M people at all.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by sarang23592 on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @04:43AM (#15337143)
I am from Barnara area near Mansar lake in Jamuu which ahs very low population. I didn't mention because I thought nobody would know it. Anyways my experience obviously differs from yours.
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by thewhitetulip on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @06:46AM (#15337567)
I am from Pune and I still face a cash crunch in the ATMs and I had to stand for 4hrs in a line on a saturday to get cash, which arrived one hour later from the RBI from Mumbai.

You were lucky!

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by awongh on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @02:04AM (#15336543)
I found this interesting article: https://www.forbes.com/sites/wadeshepard/2017/01/03/after-da...

They mention a parable about a crocodile, where things will eventually re-adjust to favor the black market just as much as before, and these policies are just an inconvenience.... I'm not sure I understand how that would work, if transactions really do start to shift online.

It seems to me that at the very least these policies will shift things in the right direction? Or is that an incorrect interpretation of the situation?

Is it more a case of botched roll out of policies that are essentially positive for india, or is it just a political maneuver that won't change anything?

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by horsecaptin on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @01:36AM (#15336455)
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by _jgdh on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @02:21AM (#15336620)
Demonetization 101

- India is a cash based economy. Most people, apart from the few doctors, lawyers, engineers etcz, are paid in cash and in turn pay for everything in cash.

- Since many businesses operate entirely in cash, revenue figures and tax payments are entirely self reported. The govt sees less tax receipts than it thinks it should.

- in November 2016 the govt decided that all high value notes were no longer legal tender and had to be returned to banks. The idea at the time being that businessmen who had hoarded mountains of cash would be forced to let their wealth disappear or deposit it and explain their sources of income. Also, people indulging in illegal activities such as politicians accepting bribes would be forced to throw the money away

- That's not what happened.

- As I said, the economy is cash based. With everyone's cash invalidated and the ATMs requiring retooling before they could work with the new notes, the economy ground to a halt. People stopped making purchases they otherwise would have, both large and small. They bought fewer TVs and washing machines, and also fewer cigarettes, fewer meals at restaurants, fewer clothes, fewer vacations. Every single sector saw their revenues fall, and a lot of people, mostly rural, lost their jobs. Farmers at the time were selling their produce for less than a tenth of what they did previously because they were desperate for money. So yes, GDP took a hit. But it's cool because the govt fudged the figures and made it appear better than it actually was.

- The real kicker however, is that the people with mountains of cash figured out ways to move that money into their accounts without raising any eyebrows. Brokers that did this merely took a 10-15% cut, rather than the 30-45% cut the govt hoped to take. 99% of notes were returned, hardly the success the govt hoped for.

- Later they changed the goalposts, claiming that the goal of this exercise was to promote digital payments, not catch the tax dodgers. Hogwash.

So to recap

1. Govt comes up with stupid scheme.

2. Implements it poorly when replacement notes are not available.

3. Scheme fails, innocent people are hurt, jobs are lost, growth grinds to a halt.

4. Govt shifts goalposts and claims victory.

Sources

1. The high economic costs of India's demonetization - https://www.economist.com/news/finance-and-economics/2171384...

2. Growth remains sluggish a year later - http://m.economictimes.com/news/economy/indicators/most-accu...

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by puranjay on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @03:48AM (#15336918)
I must have lost a good 20 hours over 3-4 months just standing in queues. Often in the Delhi cold.

The productivity loss was immense and somehow no one seems to care about it.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by _jgdh on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @04:12AM (#15337012)
I'd have mentioned it in my 101 post but it just seemed insignificant in comparison to the impact on poor people and the nation as a whole. For the record, I stood in those lines too.
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by yahna on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @08:11PM (#15343799)
> The real kicker however, is that the people with mountains of cash figured out ways to move that money into their accounts without raising any eyebrows

Isn't this a victory? The money is in the system now, can't it be tracked better?

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by vijaybritto on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @05:21AM (#15337270)
You missed the 100+ deaths!!
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by thewhitetulip on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @06:44AM (#15337562)
because our media is basically the mouthpiece of the govt!
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by hesarenu on Monday September 25, 2017 @11:28PM (#15335913)
Voting back Congress in is not an option i would choose.
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by ahamedirshad123 on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @08:43AM (#15338092)
No one asks You to.
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by thewhitetulip on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @06:51AM (#15337586)
Sure, vote BJP in power in 2019.

petrol will be 150Rs per liter and the finance min will say "people who use cars aren't starving" GDP growth will be down to 2% but "we don't want to vote congress in power!"

/s

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by yinyang_in on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @02:11PM (#15341174)
> Sure, vote BJP in power in 2019.

> petrol will be 150Rs per liter and the finance min will say "people who use cars aren't starving" GDP growth will be down to 2% but "we don't want to vote congress in power!"

> /s dude your all comments were like politicians. What good congress did other than bringing shame to country. Rahul Gandhi, Sonia gandhi are these your bets for nation ??

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by kamaal on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @11:46PM (#15344773)
Going by the current government's performance, the previous government was actually quite awesome.
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by ahamedirshad123 on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @09:00AM (#15338200)
"Technical Reasons!"
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by yinyang_in on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @01:59PM (#15341072)
I wasn't a BJP lover, but the criticism is just absurd. I think they're getting caught by the beast they unleashed (social networking).

GST everybody wanted it, but because everyone wants credit for it, no-one was letting it pass.

This whole tax system is changing, few problems are going to come.

What's wrong with using it as political agenda, rulers(so-called democracy) do this everytime. Atleast so far better than congress nation wide corruption.

He has marketed India well around the world, people talk about India. He is talking tough stands, don't know who you think is better one to rule. Congress, third-front( maya, lalu, nitish). I think he the best option we have.

If you think we've some better option, do enlighten me. Will be happy to hear your opinion.

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by QAPereo on Monday September 25, 2017 @11:16PM (#15335857)
It was toilets for all last time, right?

Edit: Oh right, thanks for the reminder. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swachh_Bharat_Abhiyan#Histor...

Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by unmole on Monday September 25, 2017 @11:32PM (#15335925)
You mean UPA's Nirmal Bharat campaign which Modiji rebranded as Swach Bharat?
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by virtuabhi on Monday September 25, 2017 @11:35PM (#15335934)
Yes, and all the new poverty alleviation schemes are just rebranding of Garibi Hatao of 1970s, right?
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by ahamedirshad123 on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @03:43AM (#15336896)
Re:India unveils $2.5B plan to electrify all households by e... by unmole on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @12:09AM (#15336077)
In the government's own words, Nirmal Bharat Abhiyan was Restructured into Swach Bharat Mission.[0]

[0]: http://pib.nic.in/newsite/PrintRelease.aspx?relid=109988