How does this work with things like DRM? What if you have media on your phone from something like Spotify or Netflix that's presumably encrypted or protected in some way, that you cannot decrypt if your subscription expires...
Suddenly the Minister[0] possessed a file which he couldn't decrypt on demand. Would he consider amending the Bill to remove penalties for such eventualities? Of course not, nothing was changed.
If you possess the bytes you'll do the time. Delete everything that is unnecessary as soon as its usefulness has expired - big corps learned that lesson, for other reasons, in the early 2000s.
[0] well one of his staff
While I entirely sympathise with this idea abstractly, so much of law depends on the context of actions where it's easy to dismiss this stunt. Merely having encrypted data in your possession is technically not within the scope of the law if the context is "as part of a counterterrorism investigation" and if the person could reasonably be expected to decrypt it (which would imply they were both the person to encrypt in the first place AND with the means to decrypt it - as this politician clearly wasn't).
Wrongful convictions and dragnet searches are the serious consequence of these laws, yes, but the real test comes when it's hateable/despicable people at risk. The problem with these laws isn't that it's fundamentally or potentially arbitrary, it's that it's wrong even when it's not arbitrary. And the mere fact of a police investigation or allegation is not sufficient to cross that line.
People should have the right to encrypt anything they want without being coerced into decrypting it. There are more than enough means for police in our modern technological era to convict terrorists/criminals and prevent conspiracies without having total access to all data. And the costs of removing that right is much higher than the rewards of a few extra convictions.
Not quite; the bar is not as high as an existing 'terrorism' investigation. To quote RIPA (2000)[0], if anyone authorized has the belief (upon reasonable grounds), that
(3) A disclosure requirement in respect of any protected information is necessary on grounds falling within this subsection if it is necessary—
(a) in the interests of national security;
(b) for the purpose of preventing or detecting crime; or
(c) in the interests of the economic well-being of the United Kingdom.
It is very very easy to imagine how this could be abused. Saying that you'd like to slap POTUS or May on Twitter could conceivably meet grounds for (2), and (3) is so broad that it's possible to imagine it could be triggered by something like being Alexandra Elbakyan of SciHub, or Sundae of The Pirate Bay. Depending on the mood of the press and the 'authorized persons', why not any old person caught using BitTorrent, or cracking DRM?[0]: http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2000/23/pdfs/ukpga_20000...
It then becomes a grey area between having been sent encrypted data, and having used the previously mentioned scheme to avoid decryption.
I also wonder how this interacts with the new 5-tap SOS function on iPhones.
Interesting point, but I think in this situation they'd be putting pressure on the media provider to decrypt it for them (since the media provider is the one in control of the encryption, not the consumer). That's assuming said media provider is in a jurisdiction that the relevant govt has some control over, and/or media provider is compliant.
Here's a thought experiment: suppose ISIS (or your preferred terrorist organisation of the day) set up a media service for users to share videos (or other media) that are protected by DRM. The media service can disable the viewing of said content on a whim. A person using this service has their phone/computer confiscated, but the authorities are powerless to gain access to the content due to the DRM. Is this person liable under these laws, even though the encryption is outside their control?
I could have a file filled with /dev/random and the law would still apply.
How can you even defend yourself?
Is... a crime? Woah.
You really shouldn't be able to access /dev/urandum until you have been cleared by a reputable Alphabet company. This is for our security and that "obviously" trumps individual rights (whatever that means).
Root cause of all this is, of course, "bad thoughts" and "bad information", which IMHO should also be made illegal and only permitted in designated "free and error prone thought" areas and participants monitored by physicians from the Ministry of Error Free Thought.
You have no idea if a file contains something needed as part of a decryption process, or if the file itself contains encrypted informations.
So basically, having a "pad" file incriminate you.
Plausible deniability by allowing you to decrypt with one of two different passwords. One gives you access to the volume with your data, the other opens a shadow volume that contains random non-senstive data.
jeeeeesus
(Not disbelief or concern trolling, I'd like to find out more about this case.)
Almost everyone with an internet connected device possess encrypted data.
Not to mention that with digitization, every file is "just a number" anyway. Top secret document leaked? Naked photos of an ex posted for all to see? "Hey, I just shared a binary number on the internet" doesn't really hold water.
It might be politically abhorrent to persecute people for such things, but absurd it is not.
Absurd nonetheless.
Well, it depends. Though some information there might be protected by "attorney-client privilege" today's verdict doesn't seem to support it
> IIRC five if the magic word "terrorism" is conjured.
Well, there is another way, but when people are more preoccupied with the rights of outspoken jihadists (not saying it's the case here) and not appearing racist in reporting crimes pressure shifts to those who have less connections to wrongdoings
This was very clearly politically motivated to hamper the efforts of CAGE; a UK based group which lobbies of behalf of young Muslim men who have been detained without charge it gitmo, harassed by the security services etc.
Regardless of whether readers like CAGE's politics (which are considered inflammatory by the government), this raises a worrying precedent.
It's also worth noting that given the UK's recent authoritarian laws, he got off lightly --- this could easily have been spun to possessing encrypted data (while being unwilling or unable to decrypt upon command), which carries a two year sentence, IIRC five if the magic word "terrorism" is conjured.