Any notion of data having a geographic home, unless specifically created to address a regulatory requirement, is a performance optimization. In any realistic architecture, there are are a million exceptions to "this Irish user's data is stored in Ireland": offsite backups, cross-datacenter requests within backend systems, offline analytical stores, queries, derived tables, etc. The same engineers who build and operate code for the US would build and operate code for Ireland, and in fact the developer platforms would be designed to hide differences between datacenters as much as possible.
If an Irish citizen logs into GMail in the US, they're not going to hit a frontend proxy in Ireland. Their data is going to be processed, and at least cached, by Google servers in the US.
Data having a geographical location is an incoherent concept in the context of the architectures of modern multinational tech companies. That much is obvious from simply reading their engineering blogs and whitepapers.
It would be a coherent legal standard (and one I favor) to say that an EU citizen's data is subject to EU protections regardless of where it's stored. It would also be coherent (and the one we unfortunately seem headed for) to say that anything an American employee can get over any remote access tool, he's required to hand over in response to a valid court order.
But pretending that data has a location is a weird hack, nowhere near as clear cut as your analogy suggests. Can you imagine, arguing in the courtroom over which member of a trans-continental Paxos group was master at the time a warrant was processed?
The exception for US-owned databases in European datacenters was a bizarre, short-lived loophole created by case law which maps poorly onto the realities of the situations.
I'd say it's the companies which have twisted themselves into knots to take advantage of this loophole, and expected that to be an enduring investment, which are having a problem.
How do you think search warrants and national espionage programs are carried out? ... That's where the law comes in: data is just "property". The law gives many craps about property :)
> I'd say it's the companies which have twisted themselves into knots to take advantage of this loophole, and expected that to be an enduring investment, which are having a problem.
The business conundrum is whether to cede massive, growing, markets to regional players or to try and straddle multiple legal regimes. That straddling means trying to reconcile different legal requirements, and that's what we're seeing: saying no to party A to respect the demands of party B.
Far from a problem, this is a consequence of expansion and profitability. Far from a "pretzel" this is par for the course for multinationals, and a key area of legal precedence for the current IT behemoths (read: impacts billions in revenue).
There are other corporate solutions to this issue, they're just much less profitable than todays approach from MS, Google, and others.
Based on the citizenship of the targets.
>Far from a "pretzel" this is par for the course for multinationals, and a key area of legal precedence for the current IT behemoths
Well, not anymore if this ruling stands.
Executing a legal search warrant involves using legally binding power on a legal entity within a specific jurisdiction. If property or entity is outside that jurisdiction then the laws do not apply. US and EU law give very, very, much a crap about their jurisdictions, and where property is (ie where data is located).
Certainly the citizenship of the entity holding the data matters, and from the GDPR's perspective, the citizenship of the data subject matters, but the "location" of the data itself has (maybe) mattered for about 2 years, and may not anymore after this works its way through the system.
See, for example: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/09/feds-google-stop...
1. An AWS Ireland instance bought by a EU member: here the storage box analogy should apply fully. The data is indeed geographically located and being operated within that geography. US courts need to accept that they need to go through the local authorities to get a warrant for that data just like they would for any physical good.
2. A worldwide distributed database like the Facebook graph: here the analogy breaks down completely and the US courts are taking advantage of that to access anything they like. I'm sure their tune would change if suddenly the Chinese authorities forced the local Facebook subsidiary to hand over all the data of US citizens. For this the solution will need to be an international arbitration for data access. If the database is not geographically bound then the mechanism to ensure its privacy will have to be international as well.
I think the Microsoft case was of type 1 and so new laws should not be needed. Cases of type 2 will be much harder and it may very well mean that Facebook becomes de facto illegal in Europe.
Italicized for emphasis, because that's the part where one discussion attempts to diverge into two.
It's true what you're saying, in exactly that one context: from the point of view of a multinational cloud provider there's a lot of different ingredients coming together to make "a" stew.
For what the OP was discussing though: what you're saying is completely wrong.
From the context of the Irish Government who is protecting sensitive personal data on Irish citizens and deciding how it, the Irish Government, and their related services should handle data, there is only one legally defensible position as of today: full control of the legal entities handling the data. The EU has very little legal sway outside the EU, there is no baked in legal reciprocity, and your suggestion for data handling laws fall woefully short of the real world issues (like... hate speech legislation, abortion politics, etc).
You're thinking about GMail. The legislation is looking at something like the entirety Irish health services and handling sensitive individual research data. From that context the idea of having no data governance and relying on inadequate legal agreements directly contradicts expert opinion and legal requirements.
Personal Identification Numbers do a lot to streamline public services, they also change the relative sensitivity of data at rest. Therefore the EU has decided that putting such data in an environment where something like Paxos would be relevant is a complete no-go. Data has a location until it is copied multiple places. The EU has decided they don't want any of those places to be outside their jurisdiction for the good of their citizens.
TFA is about GMail.
>there is only one legally defensible position as of today: full control of the legal entities handling the data
Absolutely! The GDPR does this, and it's perfectly coherent, in that it applies to all EU citizens' data, regardless of where the data is stored or processed.
What's incoherent is the (former) US policy that data held by American companies is immune to search if and only if it's located outside the US.
>Data has a location until it is copied multiple places
Data are copied hundreds to thousands of times as they transit any network. Further, if data at rest are only stored in one place, the company storing it is dangerously irresponsible. HIPAA actually mandates backup and disaster recovery capabilities. The illegal thing would be having too few copies, or an architecture with a single point of failure.
>The legislation is looking at something like the entirety Irish health services and handling sensitive individual research data
Surely something this sensitive should not rely on the "one weird trick" that US companies are (sometimes? maybe?) not required to comply with court orders for data that they claim lives on EU soil.
That is clearly not an optimal situation and will clearly have to be resolved, either by one side changing their rules or by a common agreement that voids GDPR for American courts.
On the off chance an agreement is reached with the EU I fully expect that they will allow law enforcement access from both jurisdictions; None of the EU laws restrain law enforcement in this regard.
You can try and denigrate the judge all you want, but they have the authority to make these demands, and your only recourse is the supreme court or congress. Laws are a cost of doing business in the US.
Assume I build a storage box business with headquarters in the US. After a few years of good business I decide to expand and open a subsidiary in Ireland with a local CEO in charge. I now get an order from a US court saying I need to hand over the contents of box #371 that's sitting in Ireland. I consult my lawyers in Ireland who tell me handing over those contents will be a breach of Irish law and very likely to be prosecuted. As the US based CEO do you think I should go to jail or I should send my Irish CEO to jail?