The exception for US-owned databases in European datacenters was a bizarre, short-lived loophole created by case law which maps poorly onto the realities of the situations.
I'd say it's the companies which have twisted themselves into knots to take advantage of this loophole, and expected that to be an enduring investment, which are having a problem.
How do you think search warrants and national espionage programs are carried out? ... That's where the law comes in: data is just "property". The law gives many craps about property :)
> I'd say it's the companies which have twisted themselves into knots to take advantage of this loophole, and expected that to be an enduring investment, which are having a problem.
The business conundrum is whether to cede massive, growing, markets to regional players or to try and straddle multiple legal regimes. That straddling means trying to reconcile different legal requirements, and that's what we're seeing: saying no to party A to respect the demands of party B.
Far from a problem, this is a consequence of expansion and profitability. Far from a "pretzel" this is par for the course for multinationals, and a key area of legal precedence for the current IT behemoths (read: impacts billions in revenue).
There are other corporate solutions to this issue, they're just much less profitable than todays approach from MS, Google, and others.
Based on the citizenship of the targets.
>Far from a "pretzel" this is par for the course for multinationals, and a key area of legal precedence for the current IT behemoths
Well, not anymore if this ruling stands.
Executing a legal search warrant involves using legally binding power on a legal entity within a specific jurisdiction. If property or entity is outside that jurisdiction then the laws do not apply. US and EU law give very, very, much a crap about their jurisdictions, and where property is (ie where data is located).
Certainly the citizenship of the entity holding the data matters, and from the GDPR's perspective, the citizenship of the data subject matters, but the "location" of the data itself has (maybe) mattered for about 2 years, and may not anymore after this works its way through the system.
See, for example: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/09/feds-google-stop...
1. An AWS Ireland instance bought by a EU member: here the storage box analogy should apply fully. The data is indeed geographically located and being operated within that geography. US courts need to accept that they need to go through the local authorities to get a warrant for that data just like they would for any physical good.
2. A worldwide distributed database like the Facebook graph: here the analogy breaks down completely and the US courts are taking advantage of that to access anything they like. I'm sure their tune would change if suddenly the Chinese authorities forced the local Facebook subsidiary to hand over all the data of US citizens. For this the solution will need to be an international arbitration for data access. If the database is not geographically bound then the mechanism to ensure its privacy will have to be international as well.
I think the Microsoft case was of type 1 and so new laws should not be needed. Cases of type 2 will be much harder and it may very well mean that Facebook becomes de facto illegal in Europe.