News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What if Hacker News Has Badges? Who'd Get What? by epochwolf on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @11:15AM (#1532275)
No thanks. Hacker news does not need badges.

Edit as requested:

Hacker news does not need badges because hacker news is about content. (Discussion and articles) Badges will do nothing to add to this and would risk ruining the experience.

Re:What if Hacker News Has Badges? Who'd Get What? by beccax on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @02:14PM (#1532920)
Thanks for the additional info. What about StackOverflow then? That's also about content. (Questions and answers) Badges there seem to encourage contribution. What's special about HN, in your opinion?
Re:What if Hacker News Has Badges? Who'd Get What? by lionhearted on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @02:23PM (#1532947)
> What about StackOverflow then? That's also about content. (Questions and answers) Badges there seem to encourage contribution.

StackOverflow is for programmers, and its scope pretty much limits participation to programmers and people directly tangential to programming. Thus, you don't get the internet hoi polloi problem.

> What's special about HN, in your opinion?

The editors and culture have largely managed to turn back the horde of lolcats, not funny puns, flamewars, and vacuous content. This is nigh impossible on a broad scope site. Hacker News is an incredibly rare feat, and has a fragile equilibrium that needs constant attention to preserve.

If hard-editing killing and re-titling submissions stopped, how long until this site denigrated to chaos? I'd say the over/under is two weeks.

Re:What if Hacker News Has Badges? Who'd Get What? by yef on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @11:22AM (#1532301)
Well, it already has a leaderboard and some other sorts of rankings, http://news.ycombinator.com/lists which I find very useful. Not sure why the link to it is buried at the bottom of the page.
Re:What if Hacker News Has Badges? Who'd Get What? by cynicalkane on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @11:30AM (#1532328)
The reason they're buried is because they exist to satisfy peoples' curiosity, not to serve as a leaderboard. PG doesn't want HN to turn into a karma race (and I agree).
Re:What if Hacker News Has Badges? Who'd Get What? by jgrahamc on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @01:07PM (#1532648)
I would be happy if HN didn't have karma at all. I don't think it adds anything to my use of the site.
Re:What if Hacker News Has Badges? Who'd Get What? by sorbus on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @04:16PM (#1533313)
There are some things it makes sense for; flagging submissions, downvotes, and perhaps a few other things being karma-restricted removes some issues associated with people trolling. It's also useful for identifying comments which lots of people find useful - or ones which are useless. It's basically a community-powered spamfilter and measure of relevance. That said, I would be entirely in favor of hiding or obscuring karma, outside of comment sorting (and even that could be obscured while still being useful).

Of course, hiding/obscuring karma could remove some of the motivation to upvote comments. It would be interesting to see how usage patterns changed if it was hidden/obscured ...

An option to hide karma would be useful as well, for people who aren't interested (like you). I wonder if there's an extension for some browser which does that; if not, it probably wouldn't be too hard to write one [stripping out everything in the form of "# points" and the (#) next to the username in the bar at the top of a page ... adding display:none to all the score_# classes and applying a bit of filtering to pagetop would do that.]

I'm also in favor of getting rid of downvotes, mostly because I see them abused too much (people being downvoted for expressing unpopular opinions, especially anti-apple), but that's neither here nor there.

Re:What if Hacker News Has Badges? Who'd Get What? by cynicalkane on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @04:20PM (#1533322)
One thing I like a lot about it is that you don't get the "first post" effect, where the first few people to say something get page top and all the attention. That's how it is on Slashdot.
Re:What if Hacker News Has Badges? Who'd Get What? by jokermatt999 on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @01:33PM (#1532762)
I agree that the lists page is useful, but I don't use it for finding out about posters. It's a good filter for content, as it can help me find the most upvoted posts, the ones with the most discussion, and insightful comments on stories I may not have seen.
Re:What if Hacker News Has Badges? Who'd Get What? by beccax on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @11:18AM (#1532288)
Why not? Would be very helpful if you could elaborate, so we can all learn something.
Re:What if Hacker News Has Badges? Who'd Get What? by jbail on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @11:30AM (#1532333)
I don't think hackers see value in fake awards. I for one don't see the point, except for the desire to compete to see who's got more badges on their sash. Until these badges can buy me a sandwich, pay my rent, etc, I'll leave them for the kiddies to collect.
Re:What if Hacker News Has Badges? Who'd Get What? by patrickk on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @11:37AM (#1532355)
Hear, hear. The real award for me from reading HN, would be if it ultimately made me smarter and more informed, and therefore successful in starting (and hopefully selling) a startup. Not to mention having a cool place to hang out digitally with like-minded people ;-)
Re:What if Hacker News Has Badges? Who'd Get What? by beccax on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @11:39AM (#1532362)
Makes good sense. What if instead there're badges for hackers based on their coding ability? What would you think of that? (Not that it's easy to compute of course.)
Re:What if Hacker News Has Badges? Who'd Get What? by davidw on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @11:43AM (#1532374)
There could be a badge for people who create successful startups. It might look something like this:

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/94/New100fro...

You would collect a lot of them from your customers or via an acquisition.

Re:What if Hacker News Has Badges? Who'd Get What? by bhc3 on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @12:44PM (#1532574)
Doesn't TopCoder somewhat address that?

http://www.topcoder.com/stat?c=top_developers

Re:What if Hacker News Has Badges? Who'd Get What? by icey on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @12:05PM (#1532445)
I would rather judge and be judged on the merit of a comment, not by who is making it.
Re:What if Hacker News Has Badges? Who'd Get What? by Sirocco on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @11:31AM (#1532336)
Hack News is a place I frequent to come across interesting subject matter. It is not a place to accrue accolades based on posted material. There are plenty of other communities to visit if you want to make a name for yourself.
Re:What if Hacker News Has Badges? Who'd Get What? by bmj on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @02:02PM (#1532872)
I agree. While I note upvotes while I'm looking at the discussion threads, I rarely look at the leaderboards or a user's profile for upvote counts.

And if it wasn't for my own count next to my username, I likely wouldn't know how many upvotes I had.

Re:What if Hacker News Has Badges? Who'd Get What? by thedjpetersen on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @11:26AM (#1532315)
Rather than putting extra layers of complexity on to the site, I feel that if a plugin/add-on to the browser was offered that would provide this functionality gained enough momentum then the discussion of implementing it on to the site would be worth further discussion.

I think the biggest draw for a lot of us is the pure simplicity in the site as it is.

Re:What if Hacker News Has Badges? Who'd Get What? by bonquesha99 on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @12:57PM (#1532612)
It really depends on what kind of badges/achievements are created.

We definitely wouldn't want anything like "submitted 10 posts to HN", but something like "submitted the most popular comment in an article" might be cool.