News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Dodeka Music – piano keyboard and easy-to-read s... by cranjice on Friday September 22, 2017 @10:35AM (#15312536)
Yeah, sorry, I took one look at this keyboard layout and thought to myself "ok this is a toy"

I'd love to see an application that could capture audio from an instrument and act as a real-time theory aid/teacher. For example:

  * the note you are playing is this
  * the notes you've just played in sequence belong to these scales. here are possibilities for next notes
  * try these chords
  * the chord you've just played is comprised of these notes
  * the next chord in the scale could be this
  * popular songs with these chords or in this scale are
Re:Show HN: Dodeka Music – piano keyboard and easy-to-read s... by ThomPete on Friday September 22, 2017 @10:41AM (#15312589)
You need context for that. Clearly something like this isn't for getting your head around avantgarde music.

I say the more tools the better. People will outgrow their instrument fairly quickly if it's too limiting and then just move on to something new.

Re:Show HN: Dodeka Music – piano keyboard and easy-to-read s... by markvdb on Friday September 22, 2017 @12:30PM (#15313594)
Supposedly something like chordify does this relatively well...