News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Dodeka Music – piano keyboard and easy-to-read s... by hashkb on Friday September 22, 2017 @10:25AM (#15312440)
These guitar hero style alternative notations are a major problem IMO. It's extra problematic to advertise it as "learn music" when really it's giving you a crutch to avoid learning music.
Re:Show HN: Dodeka Music – piano keyboard and easy-to-read s... by sclangdon on Friday September 22, 2017 @10:40AM (#15312575)
I think you're confusing the act of making music with musical notation. This app is clearly trying to teach you how to play music, not how to read notation.

I don't see the problem in an alternative notation if it's easier to read (I don't know if it is, I've never used the app).

Re:Show HN: Dodeka Music – piano keyboard and easy-to-read s... by analog31 on Friday September 22, 2017 @12:20PM (#15313516)
Disclosure: I'm a performing musician. I'm fluent at "sight reading," which means that I can perform music directly from a written sheet. I use this skill regularly on stage. Since I play jazz, the notations that I read include standard "dots," chord symbols, and mixtures thereof.

But... learning to read music is an effectively insurmountable obstacle for many people who might otherwise enjoy playing music in a limited capacity, or in musical styles that don't make much use of reading. For this reason, I appreciate development of alternative notations. There is already an extensive literature of written music for guitar and electric bass, that uses "tabulature," a notation based on numerically identifying finger positions on the instrument. Percussion notation is a kind of tabulature.

The problem with alternative notation is that standard notation represents a symbiosis between composers and performers. Composers know that if they use a particular notation system, then there will be plenty of people who are capable of reading it. Performers know that if they learn standard notation, then they can tap into extensive literature and performing opportunities. Nothing like that exists for any alternative notation. Even with guitar tabulature, very few composers know how to write it unless they're guitarists, and nobody can "sight read" it, so it's use is limited to learning material that will be performed from memory.

Granted, I've just made a lot of generalizations, but they hold pretty well, most of the time.

Re:Show HN: Dodeka Music – piano keyboard and easy-to-read s... by armagon on Friday September 22, 2017 @03:54PM (#15315233)
As someone trying to learn to read sheet music as an adult, it is clear to me that the system is in dire need of a refactor. I'm always excited to see alternative notations, but you are right about the problem where there is a vast amount written using the notation we have right now.

I look forward to the day when I can don a pair of high-tech glasses, look at something written in standard musical notation, and have it "transnotated" on the fly to something easier to read!

Re:Show HN: Dodeka Music – piano keyboard and easy-to-read s... by analog31 on Friday September 22, 2017 @06:12PM (#15316353)
One huge problem is that very little of the literature is in computer readable format, otherwise we'd probably already have translators and more open exploration of alternative notation systems.

But I don't know how much of the problem is our notation, versus the fact that learning to read is hard. It's almost like becoming fluent in a foreign language, which we know gets harder as we get older. I started learning to read music when I was 6. I don't know what it's like to learn reading as an adult.

Re:Show HN: Dodeka Music – piano keyboard and easy-to-read s... by armagon on Friday September 22, 2017 @11:55PM (#15318009)
I have no doubt that learning to learn to read English would be a real pain. (There's a poem called "The Chaos" that makes fun of how we spell; see http://ncf.idallen.com/english.html ) Since I know it, I have no interest in learning a different system that maps graphemes onto phonemes (ex. Shavian, or the International Phonetic Alphabet).

I suspect that that is part of how it is with our standard musical notation. The people who already know it have no interest in learning another system, even if it were demonstrably "better" (for some definition of better).

It is my opinion that our current system expresses a lot of irreducible complexity, but also has a lot of incidental complexity due to quirks of history. Accidental marks, in particular, strike me as making a backwards-compatible change that is easier for the people already locked-in to the system, but has made it more difficult for learners in the centuries since.

There's a really simple change that would roughly halve (!) the effort to learn to play music written with a grand staff. Right now, it is, from the bottom up, composed of a bass staff, one ledger line, followed by a treble staff. Simply changing it for a treble staff, two ledger lines, and another treble staff, would make it so much easier for people learning to read the music.

Going one step further, if every octave looked the same -- why should half the Cs be on lines, and half on spaces? -- that would make it far easier to learn the notation.

(And don't get me started on the timing system!)

I heard of a fluent sheet reading kid who was introduced to Klavarskribo. Apparently after 45 minutes of learning, he (she?) was able play pieces he'd never played before, just because the incidental complexity was reduced.

Re:Show HN: Dodeka Music – piano keyboard and easy-to-read s... by analog31 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @11:36AM (#15320187)
Indeed, I've had the experience of trying to explain music notation to non musicians, typically engineers. You spend more time apologizing than explaining.

Perhaps another thing that saves standard notation from itself is that most of the time, we're not actually reading all of the notes. In my case, working within a particular musical genre (jazz), my brain knows what the next notes will be, even if I'm not looking at the page. And when working up a classical piece, you've memorized it after a couple weeks, and the chart is just a place to annotate special things like fingerings and problem areas.

There was an article about a famous piano concerto, where someone discovered a mistake in the accepted transcription, and nobody even knew about it because everybody just instinctively played the right note.

Re:Show HN: Dodeka Music – piano keyboard and easy-to-read s... by cranjice on Friday September 22, 2017 @10:35AM (#15312536)
Yeah, sorry, I took one look at this keyboard layout and thought to myself "ok this is a toy"

I'd love to see an application that could capture audio from an instrument and act as a real-time theory aid/teacher. For example:

  * the note you are playing is this
  * the notes you've just played in sequence belong to these scales. here are possibilities for next notes
  * try these chords
  * the chord you've just played is comprised of these notes
  * the next chord in the scale could be this
  * popular songs with these chords or in this scale are
Re:Show HN: Dodeka Music – piano keyboard and easy-to-read s... by ThomPete on Friday September 22, 2017 @10:41AM (#15312589)
You need context for that. Clearly something like this isn't for getting your head around avantgarde music.

I say the more tools the better. People will outgrow their instrument fairly quickly if it's too limiting and then just move on to something new.

Re:Show HN: Dodeka Music – piano keyboard and easy-to-read s... by markvdb on Friday September 22, 2017 @12:30PM (#15313594)
Supposedly something like chordify does this relatively well...
Re:Show HN: Dodeka Music – piano keyboard and easy-to-read s... by ThomPete on Friday September 22, 2017 @10:40AM (#15312578)
Isn't music first and foremost about rhythm, melodies, harmonies? How is this not giving them som basic introduction?
Re:Show HN: Dodeka Music – piano keyboard and easy-to-read s... by treehau5 on Friday September 22, 2017 @10:52AM (#15312688)
Those are the parts that roll up into this thing we call "music" but that is not what music is nor what it is about. Your air conditioner, for example, has a rhythm and a pitch to it's sound, but no one would ever call it music. Your cooking timer, another example. Jonathan Peters defines music as "the universal language of emotions communicated through intelligently ordered sounds consisting of rhythm and pitch" so to answer what music is about: It's about conveying emotion.
Re:Show HN: Dodeka Music – piano keyboard and easy-to-read s... by brooklyn_ashey on Friday September 22, 2017 @11:44AM (#15313185)
Wait,what? So who is Jonathan Peters (a dj, re-mixer, and producer) to tell us what music is? Excuse me, but I happen to think my air conditioner is making a kind of music. The dude works with Mac Quale (American Horror Story) , and Quale seems to think sounds and textures are music. Also- can we please move beyond this "universal language" thing? What is universal about sounds and contexts? For example, the 12 tone scale is western, while other cultures enjoy microtones but these sounds sound "out of tune" to the average westerner. Steve Reich thought the utterances of a victimof race riots was music as evidenced by his piece "Come Out". John Cage showed that chance ambient sound is music with the famous 4'33"... and well, there are hundres ofexamples. Why can't we reach for a more culturally and intellectually and conceptually expansive defenition of an artform here on Hacker News? What "emotion" was John Cage going for in his prepared piano pieces? What about Richard Serra, the sculptor? I read stuff like this time and again by truly intellectual people on HN and I am always surprised at how behind the developments in artistic thinking are here.And really, it is 2017-- how can anyone think "music" is a universal language. As a composer myself, this defenition of music shoves me into a time machine and thrusts me back to old Vienna where I'm having tea with Brahms and Clara Schuman! Please! I need my modern brain, modern concept of the history of music and art, and my ability to redefine the parameters of my artform! How would you like program in COBOL all day for the rest of your life, denying the existence of modern coding languages? By the way, do yourself a favor and listen to "come out"---- drop in at some middle or later point innthat composition or even anywhere in Reich's "clapping Music" and tell me what emotion one is meant to feel... get back to us on that please.
Re:Show HN: Dodeka Music – piano keyboard and easy-to-read s... by whiddershins on Friday September 22, 2017 @01:59PM (#15314316)
I'm just going to weigh in here and say ... your comment could be taken the wrong way.

I am a noise musician, among other things. It's an entire career. And whether music is about conveying emotion ... I don't know if that covers all the edge cases.

My favorite definition of music is "sound arranged over time."

However, I totally agree with what you are getting at. Learning music is really about learning conventions and common language, which allow you to communicate emotions and mental states, especially at the beginning.

Re:Show HN: Dodeka Music – piano keyboard and easy-to-read s... by jcelerier on Friday September 22, 2017 @12:55PM (#15313826)
> Your air conditioner, for example, has a rhythm and a pitch to it's sound, but no one would ever call it music

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tJwoQlYUVTk

Re:Show HN: Dodeka Music – piano keyboard and easy-to-read s... by ThomPete on Friday September 22, 2017 @12:09PM (#15313394)
And the way you convey emotion is to learn how to play music so you can use the features of music, rhythm, harmonies, melodies. Thats at least how I have been doing it the +30 years I have been playing, composing and performing.