News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by thebigshane on Monday July 19, 2010 @09:21PM (#1530830)
That all sounds very nice, but secrets are important. Without getting into Personal and Financial information, military secrets are essential to military operations. Security by obfuscation is never the best way to go but security WITH obfuscation is a very successful and practical approach to keep an edge over others. This edge helps us remain free and open (open in as many areas as practically possible).
Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by david927 on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @01:23AM (#1531236)
There's a big difference between saying 'no secrets ever' and a situation where secrets are the norm. Those in power will always have the urge to increase secrecy, but it increases their power. We, the people, have to be always diligent to fight against secrecy, because to do so is to fight for democracy itself.
Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by thebigshane on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @10:20PM (#1534136)
I agree that we should also be vigilant/diligent to preserve democracy, but that's not contradictory to secrecy being A norm in sensitive political or military circles. Although it is natural to doubt the sincerity of the checks and balances and oversight over these secrets, the fact is, they do exist. And they are pretty damn successful. Sure we have an occasional overstepping of secrecy but nothing that bad either.