News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by david927 on Monday July 19, 2010 @09:22AM (#1528536)
The very word "secrecy" is repugnant in a free and open society; and we are as a people inherently and historically opposed to secret societies, to secret oaths and to secret proceedings. We decided long ago that the dangers of excessive and unwarranted concealment of pertinent facts far outweighed the dangers which are cited to justify it. Even today, there is little value in opposing the threat of a closed society by imitating its arbitrary restrictions. Even today, there is little value in insuring the survival of our nation if our traditions do not survive with it. And there is very grave danger that an announced need for increased security will be seized upon by those anxious to expand its meaning to the very limits of official censorship and concealment. --JFK
Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by thebigshane on Monday July 19, 2010 @09:21PM (#1530830)
That all sounds very nice, but secrets are important. Without getting into Personal and Financial information, military secrets are essential to military operations. Security by obfuscation is never the best way to go but security WITH obfuscation is a very successful and practical approach to keep an edge over others. This edge helps us remain free and open (open in as many areas as practically possible).
Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by david927 on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @01:23AM (#1531236)
There's a big difference between saying 'no secrets ever' and a situation where secrets are the norm. Those in power will always have the urge to increase secrecy, but it increases their power. We, the people, have to be always diligent to fight against secrecy, because to do so is to fight for democracy itself.
Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by thebigshane on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @10:20PM (#1534136)
I agree that we should also be vigilant/diligent to preserve democracy, but that's not contradictory to secrecy being A norm in sensitive political or military circles. Although it is natural to doubt the sincerity of the checks and balances and oversight over these secrets, the fact is, they do exist. And they are pretty damn successful. Sure we have an occasional overstepping of secrecy but nothing that bad either.
Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by balding_n_tired on Monday July 19, 2010 @09:27AM (#1528551)
See: Bay of Pigs, the unfortunate matter of the Diem family; etc.
Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by rbanffy on Monday July 19, 2010 @12:31PM (#1529194)
You are confusing the fallible person who delivered the speech with the principles a country was founded upon.

And, BTW, Ngô Ðình Diêm's family name was Ngô, not Diêm.

Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by balding_n_tired on Tuesday July 20, 2010 @06:05PM (#1533615)
I stand corrected on the family name.

One can appeal, with Abraham Lincoln, to the better angels of our nature, but it is as well to be realistic about the worse ones.

Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by david927 on Monday July 19, 2010 @10:25AM (#1528743)
Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by Charuru on Monday July 19, 2010 @11:59AM (#1529068)
I don't think this is the same thing. You're conflating a bureaucracy and expenditure problem with the CIA. I mean it's hard to say which one is the bigger problem, but they're very clearly 2 different issues.

The problem with pointed out by the article is that there's a closed community within the security apparatus that has grown so big and extensive that it's difficult for the government to control, and could give us a situation where the tail wags the dog. Greater transparency there could be helpful.

On the other hand I don't see how the CIA could work without secrecy. It's nuts.

Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by mcantelon on Monday July 19, 2010 @04:00PM (#1529927)
>On the other hand I don't see how the CIA could work without secrecy. It's nuts.

Whether the CIA is a net benefit to society is debatable.

Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by kiujhygtfhyj on Monday July 19, 2010 @10:37PM (#1530979)
>On the other hand I don't see how the CIA could work without secrecy. It's nuts

Names of agents in foreign countries secret = yes.

Existence of the CIA, the number of agents, the cost of operations, illegal operations, agents that have committed criminal offenses = no

Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by Ardit20 on Monday July 19, 2010 @12:41PM (#1529232)
I am not sure. I think I would like the red button to be kept very secret.
Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by bmm6o on Monday July 19, 2010 @01:42PM (#1529462)
What does this even mean? The existence of the button? If you're talking about "secret codes" for using it, that's just an implementation of an authentication/authorization scheme.
Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by thebigshane on Monday July 19, 2010 @09:26PM (#1530842)
Secrecy is more about keeping details hidden than protecting something completely. If China found out we were developing some new awesome missile defense system (ignore the fact that they never work...) that wouldn't be nearly as bad China getting access to the developers of the system, blueprints, source code, etc.
Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by Ardit20 on Monday July 19, 2010 @03:33PM (#1529845)
The quote and the circumstances in which the quote was made, seems to be advocating a complete ban in regards to secrets from our government. I was pointing out that there are very good reasons at times for keeping certain things secret, such as the "red button" which rather than being a code, is the so called button which send off all the nukes.

I know that we as a society, civilisation even, are very adverse to secrets, especially from our government, and rightly so, but secrets in practice are necessary at times. It is their motive which is highly objected to and frankly we do not know what the motive of the secret activities in the United states are.

As I posted in another comment, apparently only 0.30% of the people of the United States are involved in such highly secret activities. That seems rather fare to me.

Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by bmm6o on Monday July 19, 2010 @04:01PM (#1529934)
> I was pointing out that there are very good reasons at times for keeping certain things secret, such as the "red button" [...].

I'm sorry, I still don't understand what you're suggesting. What would it mean for the "red button" to be secret? Do you consider it to be secret today? Why or why not?

Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by hugh3 on Monday July 19, 2010 @04:55PM (#1530135)
I assume that the OP was using "red button" as a synecdoche (wow, I finally found a use for that word) for the entire procedure by which the US nuclear arsenal is launched. Which may or may not involve an actual red button at some point. (If I were designing the system, it damn well would.)

Now, I assume that launching a nuclear missile is more difficult than ringing up NORAD and saying "Hi, this is the Preisdent, the launch code is XD8-3342-9982", but let's not take that chance, shall we?

(Man, I hope I didn't just guess a real launch code. That would be difficult to explain to the nice men in suits.)

Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by mkramlich on Monday July 19, 2010 @03:35PM (#1529847)
i'd prefer no nuke weapons
Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by randallsquared on Monday July 19, 2010 @04:55PM (#1530130)
I'd like a pony.
Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by mkramlich on Monday July 19, 2010 @05:40PM (#1530259)
that's fine. you work towards getting yourself a pony and I'll work towards a world without nuclear weapons.
Re:"Top Secret America": The Washington Post's contracting i... by randallsquared on Monday July 19, 2010 @06:51PM (#1530492)
You might well get it, but keep in mind that the only world without nuclear explosives would be a world in which we are technologically incapable of building them. Not saying that's an impossible dream, but it's sure not my idea of fun.