i would hope the "not being owned by a datamining advertising giant" of wire or telegram would be a good reason to use them instead of whatsapp.
You should be extremely suspicious of any messaging company that advertises client-server encryption as a privacy feature. It obviously is not.
> This is the overwhelming consensus of the cryptography and security community
Yeah, having your client (automatically and without a warning to the user first) let a "trusted" 3rd party make it re-send and re-encrypt a message with another unverified public key is the "overwhelming consensus of the cryptography and security community".
This article did not try to debunk what the original article said at all. Instead its main argument seems to be "Sure, whatsapp resends a message encrypted with a different key when the server demands it without even informing the user but this is not bad (because of "usability concerns") and damn you for even daring to inform the users about it!". Its secondary argument seems to be "b-but users will switch away to less safe applications if you inform them about how much whatsapp sucks - even if you suggest signal afterwards!".
> Here’s a difficult attack that could allow a sophisticated, resourceful adversary willing to invest a good deal of effort, some components of which have never been demonstrated in practice, to read a few messages that had been sent but have not yet been read after events like the intended recipient changing phones or SIM cards
It's not a "difficult attack" if the trusted third party (or anyone who can compromise their servers or force them) can perform it at will.
In any case, even if this backdoor did not exist it would not make whatsapp any better as it still is a proprietary software that might perform shady things in the background (or might be updated at any time to do so).
For anyone else seeing this and wants to read more about the story see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13389935 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13394900
if I will find only one my contact on Wire, it can be amazing as much they want, but it's useless, reason why I switched today from Hangouts to Facebook Whatsapp as my secondary messenger (primary is Signal), which I really don't like (especially bloated UI with 2 unnecessary tabs out of 4), but there is not really any other option, since nobody use Allo, Skype has horrible UI, and very few people use Telegram or Viber
telegram, wire or signal are fine for people working in IT, but if you have contacts outside your work circle they are pretty much useless