News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YC wants to let people invest in its startups through the... by pfraze on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @10:42PM (#15300215)
I guess I'd ask this question:

Is it ethical to want to bring in unaccredited investors to a market that's known for being scammy and overhyped?

Re:YC wants to let people invest in its startups through the... by relyio on Thursday September 21, 2017 @12:54AM (#15300699)
It doesn't bother the government when the middle class spend its hard earned money in gambling, sport events or entertainment. Somehow, there's suddenly a moral imperative to protect those poor sheep from doing as they please with their property. But, wait, only if their capital inflow will dilute the returns of established investors.

It's to protect the middle class of course, though one can only wonder why the blatant double standard. I have no idea!

The "accredited investor" regulations are a sham, an unfair and artificial barrier to entry that ought to be removed. Yes, some people will get abused. This might even create local instability. But, that is clearly the long-term optima. Those who lose money to scams can leave it to law enforcement to do their job. Others who invest more they can afford to lose into bad apples will learn that you should always hedge risk. As a whole, society gets smarter when it is allowed to make mistakes, even costly ones. Smarter and less fragile.

Re:YC wants to let people invest in its startups through the... by lazyasciiart on Thursday September 21, 2017 @01:50AM (#15300875)
> It doesn't bother the government when the middle class spend its hard earned money in gambling

Isn't gambling heavily regulated in the US to the point of being barely legal in many states? Isn't that basically how many Indian tribes make money - by being outside this regulation?

Re:YC wants to let people invest in its startups through the... by brandnewlow on Thursday September 21, 2017 @02:28AM (#15301006)
Running a casino is heavily regulated. Gambling at a casino is open to anyone over 21 where its legal. That was the OP's point.
Re:YC wants to let people invest in its startups through the... by dragandj on Thursday September 21, 2017 @10:10AM (#15303551)
Yes, and everyone entering casino is aware that it is gambling.

ICOs, on the other hand, is like entering a street shell game. Something non-regulated, where you are sure to get skinned.

Re:YC wants to let people invest in its startups through the... by relyio on Thursday September 21, 2017 @02:04AM (#15300929)
I'm by no means an expert on the matter, but I believe you're thinking of running Casinos specifically. For example, scratching games or lotteries are legal in almost every state in the US. And for those states where casinos are allowed, no one will ask you questions as long as you are +21.
Re:YC wants to let people invest in its startups through the... by stale2002 on Thursday September 21, 2017 @02:21AM (#15300989)
There is a significant difference.

Gambling is up front about the odds and the fact that they are stacked against you.

ICOs and scam investments are not.

The issue is not about allowing people to lose their money.

The issue is about Fraud, and people lying about what they are selling, as well as promising false returns.

Casinos don't promise you anything false, and transparently offer you provable odds.

Re:YC wants to let people invest in its startups through the... by icebraining on Thursday September 21, 2017 @04:13AM (#15301440)
Would casinos be that honest if they didn't fear being prosecuted? Why can't ICOs be similarly managed?

After all, if someone is willing to violate the law, chances are they won't respect limitations regarding the eligibility of investors - which is, in fact, what we're seeing with ICOs.

Seems like just another example of the known results of Prohibition - prevent legal markets and you'll just have dark markets in which people get poisoned.

Re:YC wants to let people invest in its startups through the... by notahacker on Thursday September 21, 2017 @08:23AM (#15302595)
Regulating a casino is relatively straightforward. You demand their games actually pay out on the odds they're required to publish and periodically check they actually do so, and prohibit them from claiming that they are an investment at all.

Regulating a company that may or may not believe their pitch about making their investors rich and whose probable failure may or may not be the result of them failing to even attempt to execute on it and/or their pitch deck being a pack of lies is incredibly complicated.

So it's left to investors that have the resources to do what would otherwise be the extremely laborious regulator's job of doing due diligence, sitting on boards to see what's going on and litigating malfeasance. Who also happen to have sufficient funds not to suffer if they don't.

Prohibition isn't really an appropriate comparison since there's an abundance of alternative places for the general public to speculate, and no reason to assume that the investment opportunities investment professionals won't touch would start offering consumers better returns than a casino if everyone could advertise an SEC stamp on their ICO after filling in a few forms.

Re:YC wants to let people invest in its startups through the... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday September 21, 2017 @01:06AM (#15300736)
> Those who lose money to scams can leave it to law enforcement to do their job

Law enforcement rarely resolves securities disputes. It requires lawyers teeing up the evidence for courts and regulators.

Disclaimer: I am not a lawyer. Don’t do mean things with securities.

Re:YC wants to let people invest in its startups through the... by relyio on Thursday September 21, 2017 @02:09AM (#15300948)
I guess it would depend how sophisticated the scam is. When I wrote that, I had outright thievery in mind.
Re:YC wants to let people invest in its startups through the... by exelius on Thursday September 21, 2017 @09:51AM (#15303348)
Any *coin fiasco would take the government years to figure out. Nobody is even sure if the laws on the books would cover some of the scenarios that are popping up. A lot of it would be solved if people really understood what they're buying with these ICOs, but many just see it as "magical Internet money that's making cash obsolete".
Re:YC wants to let people invest in its startups through the... by twalla on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @11:03PM (#15300296)
Fundamentally, I see it as democratizing investment and removing arbitrary hurdles for those without millions in the bank to seek higher risk/reward investments.

In practice, I'm seeing teams doing ICOs do shady things like change the terms halfway through raising capital, leaving early contributors with a diluted stake or teams that straight up don't deliver with no way for share(token?)holders to hold the team accountable - basically this kind of behavior seems a whole lot easier when you took small sums from thousands of nobodies instead of millions from a handful of deep-pocketed somebodies.

Re:YC wants to let people invest in its startups through the... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday September 21, 2017 @01:08AM (#15300738)
> for those without millions in the bank to seek higher risk/reward investments

I question whether those risk-reward blends are appropriate for those without substantial excess capital. The current limits are somewhat arbitrarily placed, I agree, but someone with $50,000 in savings probably shouldn't be investing in start-ups.

Re:YC wants to let people invest in its startups through the... by redial on Thursday September 21, 2017 @04:04AM (#15301387)
Isn't that up to them?
Re:YC wants to let people invest in its startups through the... by Fomite on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @11:05PM (#15300306)
The worried part of me thinks this is the build up for just another example of "In which cryptocurrencies discover that banking and securities regulations were created for a reason".
Re:YC wants to let people invest in its startups through the... by fgjjgutjvnu on Thursday September 21, 2017 @02:27AM (#15301001)
I understand the reasoning behind such regulation. On the other hand, for example doing a startup is also highly risky. Should it therefore also be regulated, only people with enough savings (and perhaps education) should be allowed to do startups?

I don't think it is easy to answer, clearly not allowing people to take risks is also taking away there freedom and chances for making a better living. Not allowing people to take risks (and consequently, start businesses) ultimately leads towards a communist worlds were people can only pick from a selection of government ordained jobs.