News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by techsupporter on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @01:50AM (#15282100)
From the words in your comment, you don't live in the United States. The reason payment cards the world over still have a mag stripe is because, until a few years ago, chip cards were simply not a thing in the U.S. so the facilities for reading them simply didn't (widely) exist. Therefore, cards from other countries had to have magnetic stripes in order to work in the U.S.[0]

Even today, two years after the supposedly "drop dead date" for switching to chip cards, 40% of my transactions are by swiping.

0 - There are other reasons, like some ATMs reading the magstripe to ascertain whether a card has a chip and then prompting the user to leave the card in place. I've only encountered older ATMs that do this but it is another reason. But the most common one is that outside-the-U.S. issuers want their cards to work inside the U.S. if a customer of theirs travels there.

Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by usaphp on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @02:23AM (#15282221)
> so the facilities for reading them simply didn't (widely) exist

I live in San Diego, 8/10 places where I shop still have chip slot taped closed with a handwritten message "Does not work".

Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by dx034 on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @06:01AM (#15283164)
Which is problematic when you visit with a European card where only the chip works (swiping always gets declined). Luckily, some have contactless (mostly without the staff knowing about it) and for others it usually turns out that the chip reader does actually work.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by sjwright on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @02:32AM (#15282265)
I wonder how many of them actually work.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by pohl on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @10:37AM (#15285000)
It wouldn't surprise me to learn that most of them work but that businesses want to avoid them because they slow down the checkout process.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by Jaruzel on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @02:41AM (#15282296)
Out of curiosity... Do these same places accept contactless payment, either by card, or e-wallet (Google/Apple Pay etc.) ?
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by deforciant on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @04:17AM (#15282681)
when visiting Austin, US I went for a burger in Fridays near a highway and cashier was like "Oh my god, I have never seen this thing working!!!" after my contactless worked on their terminal :D Apparently it's too much magic and people just stopped trying to use chip, contactless or anything else. Just cash and swipe :)
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by dx034 on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @06:03AM (#15283167)
Had the same at a McDonald's in Boston. They even called the manager to show him what happened. Turned out that no one working there was aware that they had contactless functions, despite the advertisement at the machine.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by Ambroos on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @09:37AM (#15284442)
I even get that in Belgium. And the occasional cashier that double-checks the terminal's ticket/output because they suspect the transaction is invalid because "as far as they know contactless doesn't work".
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by mark-r on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @01:08PM (#15286507)
I think McDonald's was the first time I ever encountered a contactless terminal. It goes much faster than inserting the chip for some reason.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by dx034 on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @09:55AM (#15293728)
I love the system and like that it's being used extensively in some countries (e.g. UK) and becoming more prevalent in others (e.g. Germany). What's annoying are the differences in rules. In the UK it only works up to £30 (but terminals show the logo for any amount), in Spain it will work but I'll have to enter a PIN for higher amounts, other countries have completely different rules around that.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @12:51PM (#15286337)
Contactless was narrowly deployed in the US 10ish years ago. It never took off as too few vendors had the terminals to support it. I only ever used mine at the local grocery store. I don't think you can get an RFID card from a US bank any more.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by techsupporter on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @12:58PM (#15286410)
Capital One has started issuing contactless credit cards. They began in late June, I think. I have one.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by corpMaverick on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @10:34AM (#15284958)
For those of us stuck in 2007. Can you briefly describe how the contactless payment works ?
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by FTA on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @11:00AM (#15285226)
You just hold the card over the screen and it reads (I believe) an RFID chip in the card. No swiping or card insertion required.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by gokhan on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @12:12PM (#15285913)
And it's much faster most of the time.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by ryandrake on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @01:59PM (#15287078)
How do you know if your card supports it? Try it and see if it works?
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by FTA on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @02:54PM (#15287710)
I had no clue until a cashier did it for me in a European country. There may be a little logo like this either on your card or on the materials when you get your card: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contactless_smart_card#/media/....

Once it was demonstrated to me, I went back and found out the cards I've had since 2013 (pre-chip).

Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by mi100hael on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @11:00AM (#15285227)
RFID Cards or NFC from your phone. Hold your payment method near the reader and it pulls the card info wirelessly.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by usaphp on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @03:34AM (#15282507)
The only place so far where I can safely use Apple Pay without causing any frustration from cashiers is Whole Foods, cashiers in the rest of the stores either have no idea if the Apple Pay is supported or the terminal itself is not "enabled" to support Apple Pay.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by jowiar on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @04:48AM (#15282822)
Interestingly, I have been traveling in Ireland recently, and well over 90% of my transactions are Apple Pay.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by jandrese on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @10:18AM (#15284803)
Some of the retailers in the States are protesting Apple Pay and disabling it on the terminals even though it would otherwise be fully supported. Home Depot did this awhile back, they were one of the first places where Apple Pay worked and then it stopped working due to some corporate hissy fit.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by dx034 on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @09:58AM (#15293752)
That's a political decision. Stores like you to use store cards wherever possible (where they get a profile of what you've bought). Banks have to share profits with Apple for Apple Pay which is why they try to avoid it.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by kbart on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @01:56AM (#15282119)
"The reason payment cards the world over still have a mag stripe is because, until a few years ago, chip cards were simply not a thing in the U.S. "

So let them have it, why should I care and endure security risk? I've never been to USA nor I'm planning to (at least not unless they fix that gestapo-like border control), but still my every card has a magstripe waiting to get skimmed. If I ever need to go to USA, I'll get a suitable card.

Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by techsupporter on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @02:14AM (#15282185)
> So let them have it, why should I care and endure security risk?

Because banks the world over are notoriously slow about doing anything that might nudge even a fraction of a percentage of customers over to a competitor. If they removed magnetic stripes (which, in the short run, would cost a bank money because that's a specialty card) and said "just contact us if you're going to the States and we'll overnight you a States-compatible card, no questions asked," nothing would stop a competitor from running adverts that say "why wait 24 hours and worry about not getting your card? We issue cards that work in the United States from day one!" Now the person who made the decision to delete the magstripe from cards issued by the first bank is out of a job and so now you see why his or her interests didn't line up with yours.

It's the same reason why chip-and-PIN isn't primary in the United States; chip-and-sign is. Over here, customers have been trained that entering a PIN means the money comes out of a checking (draft/demand/deposit) account while signing means it goes "on the card." Trying to get that mindset changed is more costly than just eating the potential stolen-card-being-used-before-being-shut-down fraud for most issuers.

(Some credit unions, primarily catering to people who travel overseas, and smaller banks that want to differentiate themselves are issuing PIN-primary cards but they are definitely in the minority. I happen to have cards from three of them--First Tech, Spokane Teacher's, and Target--for reasons of security and international use but I am also in the minority. Amusingly, it's large merchants who want PIN-based cards because it puts the onus on the cardholder, not the merchant.)

Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by kalleboo on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @06:49AM (#15283387)
Because they could instead sell it as "an unskimmable card!". Many people I know have had their cards preemptively replaced by their bank because it was used at a store/ATM where other cards were skimmed. Avoiding worries/hassles like that could be a selling point.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by rtkwe on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @11:55AM (#15285741)
Except some chip transactions are just the same data as mag swipe so even a chip only card isn't going to prevent skimming and subsequent fraud.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by amenghra on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @02:06AM (#15282152)
Get rid of the magstripe and bad actors will steal your card info using cameras (pretty much all the info in the magstripe is also printed on the card, that's how online shopping works).

It would be good to raise the bar, but it won't be an end-all solution.

At the end f the day, it's going to take quite some effort to move the entire payment industry to something more secure.

The current state of affaires is good enough in terms of cost for the banks vs loss from fraud.

Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by kalleboo on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @06:50AM (#15283397)
3DSecure is also pretty widely deployed in my neck of Europe (Sweden).

EMV chip transactions and 3DSecure really ought to eliminate the vast majority of "card number stolen" fraud. Too bad it's all so poorly implemented.

Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by kbart on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @02:07AM (#15282156)
"Get rid of the magstripe and bad actors will steal your card info using cameras"

Even if they see my PIN, they can't clone a chip, so what they are going to do with it?

Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by pitaj on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @02:11AM (#15282168)
Use it for online payments.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by ddnb on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @06:24AM (#15283261)
Wait, you guys don't use card readers for online payments? Edit: My bad, just realized you use credit cards instead of debit cards we use in europe. CC here also don't use ccard readers for online payment.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by colejohnson66 on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @07:01AM (#15292382)
Wait. What? You have to have a card reader for online debit purchases?
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by kbart on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @02:12AM (#15282178)
You need a valid address for that too and it's not on a card.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by tzs on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @04:45AM (#15282811)
To elaborate a bit on what amenghra said, the information you are asked for when you use your card for a "card not present" transaction (card number, card security code, name, billing address, expiration date) falls into three categories.

• information required by the bank,

• information that the bank will check if you supply it,

• information that is not checked by the bank.

The first category, required information, is just the card number for most banks (and the amount to charge, of course).

The second category, checked by the bank if supplied, is everything except for the card number and the expiration date and the amount. This information is used for fraud control. If a merchant supplies it, the bank tells the merchant if it was correct. With many banks the credit card fees are slightly lower if this information is supplied. Even if the merchant supplies this and the bank says it does not match the merchant can go ahead with the transaction, although such transactions have a higher risk of fraud (and therefore chargebacks).

The third category, information not checked by the bank, is the expiration date. The expiration date check is at the payment processor, and that check is simply:

  if expiration_date < current_date()
    reject_transaction()
The expiration date on a card is just when that physical card is no longer supposed to be used. It is not an expiration date on the underlying account.

This is one reason why many people have gotten a surprise when they have had some kind of subscription they no longer wanted, and instead of actually cancelling it they just let their card expire and think the re-billing will then fail. There are three problems with that approach.

1. If the merchant marks a transaction as a recurring transaction some payment processors skip the expiration date check.

2. Some merchants include something like this in their re-billing code:

  if expiration_date < current_date()
    expiration_date = date_add(expiration_date, interval(3, 'years'))
3. Visa, Mastercard, and Discover (not sure about Amex) have updater services. Merchants can send a credit card number and expiration date to the updater service, and the service will tell them the current expiration date and the current card number for the underlying account. This one can be especially surprising to people because it can update both the expiration date and the card number.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by dx034 on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @06:06AM (#15283184)
Are you sure that the expiration date is not checked for any vendor? I recently paid online (Mastercard I think) and the transaction got declined because I entered the wrong expiration date. The date was in the future, I just entered a wrong month. So there must've been a check. But could be that they used 3D secure (or equivalent) and it got declined there, the check often happens too fast to notice.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by leesalminen on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @10:44AM (#15285065)
I believe this comes down to the cardholder bank. My local credit union doesn't check expiration date of cards (I've tried as far out as 2029). CapitalOne does.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by tzs on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @07:04AM (#15283462)
It's possible that some of the enhanced security systems, like 3D secure, do check more.

It's also possible that there is more checking for transactions that are not flagged as recurring payments.

Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by amenghra on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @02:22AM (#15282220)
Sadely not all banks validate the billing address. Some just check the zip code, others don't even do that.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by daurnimator on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @03:21AM (#15282452)
Thankfully.

Trying to use a non-US card in the USA is a pain: most online shops or machines (e.g. NYC Metrocard) require a 5 digit ZIP. Cards from elsewhere don't have a 5 digit ZIP to enter. So usually I can't use those websites, at least if it's a machine I can pay cash.

Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by jjeaff on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @03:01AM (#15282370)
By choice, to make it easier for our customers to pay (we are saas) we only require the number and CVV.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by WhiteSource1 on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @07:45AM (#15283714)
Do you have a payment provider that verifies that card?
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by Grue3 on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @06:58AM (#15283434)
If you know the name of a person, finding their address is pretty easy.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by mcv on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @03:53AM (#15282572)
The core of the problem is that visible info on the card is enough to authorise payment. Visible info is not secret. Info that you share with every seller is not secret. Public information should not be good enough to authorise payment.

Payment should require some kind of private information, either from the chip, or from the head of the owner (like a PIN), but preferably both.

Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by peteretep on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @04:49AM (#15282829)

    > Get rid of the magstripe and bad
    > actors will steal your card info
    > using cameras 
They probably won't though, they'll probably just skim people who don't do that.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by peteretep on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @04:47AM (#15282820)
I use a company called Revolut to manage a card of mine. One of the options in the app is to explicitly disabled Magstripe payments, so one wonders if you could ask your bank to disable it?
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by kbart on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @05:53AM (#15283130)
"one wonders if you could ask your bank to disable it?"

I've written in my other comment that I did ask. The answer was "it is not possible".

Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by vertex-four on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @05:09AM (#15282933)
In the UK, I've recently had to swipe a card and sign the receipt as the card reader was misbehaving and that's what it wanted me to do. It's a reasonable backup. (I've also had to use a carbon-copy machine to print my card details onto a piece of paper to make a deposit a couple of years ago - now that was ancient tech!)