So Spotify, due to the end of Flash player moved to HTML5 player.
And then the only browser which need a flash player is Apple Safari ?
Oh, the irony :-)
Which ones? Desktop Safari still supports Flash and it has DRM available in the form of FairPlay. It's the latter which those other platforms are presumably using.
The iPhone was released in the summer of 2007, didn’t support Flash, and wasn’t intended to run third-party apps[0]. After Jobs caved on releasing an SDK, they finally opened the App Store the following autumn. There was never an opportunity for “Flash portals” to compete with the App Store, let alone to influence the decision to support Flash in the first place.
And if you really want to know, read this article from Wired on the topic: https://www.wired.com/2008/11/adobe-flash-on/
Sad that I get downvoted for this, but I already accepted that on hacker news, don't go against all the Apple and Google fanboys.
When I was reading “the only reason they did that was because …”, I mentally substituted the pronouns to read “the only reason Apple didn’t support Flash on the original iPhone was because …”. And then I was left with “The only reason Apple didn’t support Flash on the original iPhone was because Flash portals were competing with their app store”. So that’s the idea that I was confronting. If that’s not the sentiment you were advancing, then the first thing we should do is settle it.
But since I'm defending Flash, and saying something negative about Apple, let the downvotes begin.
But the blocking of Flash was a business decision, not a technical one, or even a "support the open web" one.
And so yes, if they allowed Flash, then portals were indeed a direct competitor to their app store. That is why they kept them out.
Second, I'm not suggesting that the threat posed by Flash wasn't ever a factor in any decision Apple ever made about supporting Flash on iOS (then iPhone OS). But you said "the only reason they did that ...", which suggests that there were no other reasons ever. But if the first iPhone was never intended to run 3rd party apps, then there was nothing to compete with at first. If there was nothing to compete with, then the initial decision not to support Flash could not have been motivated by the threat to the then-not-even-planned-to-exist App Store.
Before the App Store (and still today), iPhone had support for third party apps and an open (non-Apple App Store) app ecosystem, HTML5 apps installable to home screen with offline mode. At the time, you could install games like PacMac that worked fine.
Apple avoided support for Flash because it was absolute crap on mobile, from hardware issues affecting battery life to UX issues such as presumption of a cursor and hover states.
I wish developers and media streamers had let go of Flash sooner and moved to HTML5+JS, before the native App Store captured all the mindshare. Apple’s biggest mistake here was misunderstanding the lasting power of Adobe’s simpler tool ecosystem for “creators”.
iPhone didn’t need Flash. It did need better tools.
// Source: Owned a video CDN throughout the player wars, with ongoing first person conversations with folks from the companies in question, and their key media and publishing clients were our clients.
Well worldwide.....maybe? But if you're in the game for paying customers you're looking at 10-20% easily, with desktop users. Mobile users even more.
> On top of that, I'll bet most of their customers use the desktop app
That's true. Staring at that green icon in my dock right now!
Big site's will support all the CDMs because they have the resources but everyone else will standardize on the one with the largest installed base (Widevine).
It was absolutely awful maintaining them.
A couple months ago, Spotify switched their web player from using Flash to using HTML5 + DRM (the "standardized" web DRM).
At least, that was the case for Chrome and Firefox, which I noticed because I exclusively use the Spotify web player.
But I guess Safari doesn't support web DRM via the Widevine CDM. So they must have kept the Flash based web player around for Safari.
And, indeed, Flash would only be needed for Safari. Chrome and Firefox support web DRM on Windows, Linux, and AFAIK MacOS too.
Now, supporting both a Flash based web player and an HTML5 based web player is a lot of engineering. I'll bet at some point they decided they didn't want to do that. The only reason they still had the Flash player was to support Safari and Safari only has 2% market share. On top of that, I'll bet most of their customers use the desktop app. So of the 2% of Safari users, how many are using the Spotify web player?
So they dropped their Flash based player, and thus had to also drop support for Safari.
I think it's a fairly reasonable move. Flash is dying; they couldn't keep their player on it, so they _had_ to move to HTML5. Since they have to use DRM at the behest of the RIAA, web DRM thus becomes their only choice.
I doubt the story is much better for alternatives. Even if any of the other music subscription platforms are still using Flash, that's unlikely to continue for long.
I don't blame Safari for not implementing web DRM. That leaves only one party left to point the finger at; the RIAA. If you need someone to blame, blame them.