"However, the Court found the prohibition of images that appear to be, but are not actually, minors improper"
They found the prohibition to be improper. It's oddly phrased.
"Pretending to be a minor" would have 1st amendment protections as per previous cases.
But, from the OP:
>> The case itself involved a 17-year-old sending “an unsolicited picture of his erect penis” to an apparently unwilling recipient, but the logic of the court’s reasoning applies even when the recipient is pleased to receive the photo. The court does say that, “because [Gray] was not a minor sending sexually explicit images to another consenting minor, we decline to analyze such a situation,” but I think that — given the logic of the majority opinion — the analysis would have to end up the same way; nothing in the majority’s reasoning turns on the presence of an unwilling recipient.
And that being said, one must imagine how differently the case might have been handled had the genders of the involved persons been switched.
Same reason that minors usually get a break from the law when committing vandalism, assault, etc.
So they should not get the same exact punishment, which is why I suggested counseling because unnecessary institutionalization of children is a predatory method of creating repeat offenders.
It's like that episode of Seinfeld where they learn a sex offender moved into the neighborhood and went to confront the person, then found out it was a woman and immediately (and somehow understandably) lost their vitriol.
Thank you for clarifying.
Is it me or was this densely worded?
https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/09/teen-sends-dick-... is more readable, probably.
Mods might want to update the link?
>In Free Speech Coalition, the Supreme Court struck down a law that banned sexually explicit depictions of minors, as well as depictions that appeared to be minors. These included computer generated images and depictions of legal adults pretending to be minors. The Court recognized that the First Amendment “does not embrace certain categories of speech, including … pornography produced with real children.” However, the Court found the prohibition of images that appear to be, but are not actually, minors improper; any harm stemming from those false images “does not necessarily follow from the speech, but depends upon some unquantified potential for subsequent criminal acts."
Unless I'm reading it wrong.
However there are such laws which remain, and in fact have been recently introduced, in Canada, England & Wales, Northern Ireland, Rep. of Ireland, New Zealand, Australia, and various European countries.
What's perhaps even more concerning is that even stories are illegal in Canada. The mere possession of the material, i.e a drawing that you made yourself is illegal in England. Publishing a story or even sexual roleplaying with another adult over the Internet might find you sentenced under the Obscene Publications Act.
It's hideous in my view and such laws deserve to be stricken down with ferocity.
I'm sure I've replied to you about this before, actually, not long ago. (Edit: found it https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14904716)
I'm not sure why my comment here is downvoted, though.
Your bbc example is telling: he's an admitted paedophile, who was offending against children. The OPA isn't new law, it's very old law.
> He admitted at Preston Crown Court to storing hundreds of child abuse images and posting on a paedophile website.
Wrong about what, exactly? Images of children in sexual situations, or rather, as is described in the act, is illegal even to possess. Unless you know something about the act that I don't, or I've completely misread it - in which case I'm very open to corrections - I'm an optimist that the law isn't as hideous as I am reading it out to be.
>The OPA isn't new law, it's very old law.
I was talking about that section of CAJA, I know that OPA is old, but the "lolicon law" is only from 2009.
>he's an admitted paedophile
So what? That's completely irrelevant to any point that's being made. The fact is that he was imprisoned for spreading stories, fiction, and it was through UK law enacted by parliament that this happened.
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2008-12-08/fake-simpsons-cartoon-...
>Justice Adams said the legislation's main purpose was to combat the direct sexual exploitation and abuse of children that occurs where offensive images of real children are made.
If he believes this, then why is he legislating that virtual pornography, in fact even hand drawn, of the Simpsons which bear such little resemblance to real people, never mind actually existing people, is against the law?
>But, he said, it was also calculated to deter production of other material, including cartoons, which "can fuel demand for material that does involve the abuse of children".
Was it really? And if so, does he, or the authors of the legislation, have evidence to back up this claim? This seems to be totally unsubstantiated nonsense this judge is saying. And what of fueled demand? The fact that a drawing or story might make someone else do an action is, in my view (and I hope others can agree) not reasonable grounds for illegalising possession or production of that drawing.
Unfortunately bone-headed cases and legislation like this have graced the rest of the Commonwealth and various European countries.
Just utterly amazing. Hentai is now child porn. How many hentai pictures are stored on Tarsnap??!
Those images might be stored on US servers. Time for you to grant a "backdoor" to the government.
If I was in your position, I would be genuinely confused when trying to juggle all of these regulatory threat matrices :( :(
It reminds me of the situation right now with the guy in Philadelphia who is in prison for contempt for not offering decryption password to the judge.
What is strange is how today's puritanism is coming from the left rather than the right.
Growing up as kid, I remember christians and conservatives attacking "Married with Children", "Simpsons", "Beavis and Butthead", "Southpark", etc. Even as an elementary kid, I remember associating christians/conservatives with censorship and for most of my life identified myself as a liberal.
The past few years, I've given up on liberals too as they are now pushing their form of censorship under the aegis of "social justice".
> Congrats, two 17 year olds sending pictures of themselves consentually = child porn.
It's even worse that isn't it? If a 17 year old takes a picture of herself on a smartphone and sends it to herself on her other accounts, then she's guilty of distributing child porn. Technically, isn't she guilty of distributing child porn of herself to herself?
At this point, if they spend time going after people for that type of technicality, then it's only a matter of time before they get all of us in prison for something.
70m people in the USA have a criminal record of some kind.
The more victimless crimes we have, the more power we will lose.
From both actually, take the UK for example, the anime=CP law was made under a right-wing government.
Congrats, two 17 year olds sending pictures of themselves consentually = child porn.
What I also couldn't understand from the article:
A picture of someone who is an adult, but is /pretending/ to be a minor is also child pornography?
What?!
Pornhub.com will need to take a hard look at some of its content providers then.
Or does it not apply to Montreal based companies?
What if the servers are in the US? What if the client is in the US?
Lunacy.