Re:Court OKs child porn prosecution of minors distributing p...
by ikeboy on Friday September 15, 2017 @08:44PM
(#15262055)
What they did was wrong, but it shouldn't be prosecuted under child porn laws. They should get whatever punishment they'd get if they did the same at 18, under whatever harassment laws apply.
Re:Court OKs child porn prosecution of minors distributing p...
by kakarot on Friday September 15, 2017 @09:12PM
(#15262181)
I think on one hand you are correct, but if the court wants to claim that a child is not old enough to consensually produce pornographic imagery of themselves, they must also admit that a child who takes and sends the images to another has not fully developed their reasoning skills.
Same reason that minors usually get a break from the law when committing vandalism, assault, etc.
So they should not get the same exact punishment, which is why I suggested counseling because unnecessary institutionalization of children is a predatory method of creating repeat offenders.
Re:Court OKs child porn prosecution of minors distributing p...
by thaumasiotes on Friday September 15, 2017 @09:04PM
(#15262146)
Girls get prosecuted for producing "child" pornography of themselves too.
Re:Court OKs child porn prosecution of minors distributing p...
by kakarot on Friday September 15, 2017 @09:12PM
(#15262182)
Well what I mean is, I just wonder at the likelihood of the situation being reported in the first place, as well as whether the sentencing would be the same. This isn't any attempt at making a point but just general curiosity.
It's like that episode of Seinfeld where they learn a sex offender moved into the neighborhood and went to confront the person, then found out it was a woman and immediately (and somehow understandably) lost their vitriol.
And that being said, one must imagine how differently the case might have been handled had the genders of the involved persons been switched.