You're right that 401k funds tend to suck, but most funds everywhere tend to suck (compared to market). The ones that don't, you probably don't have access to.
So just avoid the managed funds. Buy index, outperform most, and save the fees.
However, if you actually need to withdraw any of these savings ahead of time, you're looking at a 10% penalty. And who's to say that taxes won't have risen on 'fat-cat' retirees in 10 or 20 years. Why not take the (known) risk now, pay your taxes and have risk-free savings now.
What about another market crash?
Can you invest in property, or in metals, in a 401K?
Can you avoid 2% mutual fund fees.
I posted elsewhere in the thread, but think very carefully before pumping a lot of money into a 401K. 20 years is a long time for the government to keep the value of money stable, or for Wall Street to not sucker you in a crash, or for fees to T Rowe Price to eat away your nest-egg.
If I had another opportunity, I'd sock 5% away in a 401K into Treasuries, and put the rest in cash and metals. There's a reason banks have vaults with gold, silver, platinum etc.
Answer this question: Do you trust Wall St and the government with your money for 30 years for the small benefit of maybe a 10% tax saving, or do you actually want to maintain the control of, and the value of that money, by paying regular taxes on it now.
Second some advice that's based on my semi-educated opinion: 401(k) is a scam for anyone under 50.
This is why conventional advice is to only contribute as much to your 401(k) as to receive the employer's matching contribution, which is essentially free money. The rest of your retirement savings which you want to invest should go into an IRA, which allows you to control what exactly it is invested in.
I don't worry about retirement because when I was 19 years old and working in the valley I happened to catch his radio show when he said to pull out of the market. It saved me $20,000 that's still working for me today.
(The 10 year numbers might look low right now but keep in mind the Dow was DOWN 14% in that same time frame)
Second some advice that's based on my semi-educated opinion: 401(k) is a scam for anyone under 50. Yes your employer might match it but even the risky portfolio of a 401(k) is usually very conservative and the guy running it usually isn't the firm's star (no one ever got rich managing a 401(k) accounts). If you're over 50 and can't afford to lose the money than go with that but if you have some time I personally think it's better to take a little risk and hopefully get a bigger reward.