News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Hardening of Consciousness by goatlover on Wednesday September 13, 2017 @08:37PM (#15244032)
> There is no way of showing that the subjective “red experience” is not simply a label applied to a particular set of conditions in the “physical world of things”.

This can be turned around to say that there's no way of showing that a particular set of conditions in the "physical world of things (or processes)" isn't an abstraction from subjective experience.

Either way, you have an explanatory gap. I know I have red experiences. I know there are abstract explanations for how my visual system works, how objects reflect light, and so on, making it possible to see objects as colored. I don't see how the abstract explanation (the scientific one) explains my having a red experience, because an abstract explanation isn't the same thing as having an experience.

Re:The Hardening of Consciousness by dragonwriter on Thursday September 14, 2017 @08:13AM (#15247140)
> This can be turned around to say that there's no way of showing that a particular set of conditions in the "physical world of things (or processes)" isn't an abstraction from subjective experience.

Sure, it can, and if someone said it was easy to show that o jective reality exists independent of subjective experience, that would even be relevant.

Of course, the difference is that the concept of an objective reality is a useful abstraction from subjective experience (it's what let's science, which has utility in predicting future experiences, exist). Qualia offers... what?

Re:The Hardening of Consciousness by goatlover on Thursday September 14, 2017 @01:19PM (#15250169)
> Qualia offers... what?

A way to clearly demarcate subjective experience. We don't have to use the term "qualia", but then people tend to use words like consciousness differently, and the debate ends up being a semantic one.

> the difference is that the concept of an objective reality is a useful abstraction from subjective experience

Agreed, and I think there is a real, objective world independent of our experiences. But to get at it, we do have to abstract from our consciousness. That works really well for most things, until we turn it around and try to explain the nature of our subjectivity. Qualia is philosophically specific term meant to highlight that difficulty.

Re:The Hardening of Consciousness by carapace on Thursday September 14, 2017 @02:46PM (#15251165)
What do you mean when you use the term "qualia"?

What do you mean when you use the term "exist"?

I cannot fathom the semantic meaning of "qualia don't exist".

Either you are the legendary "P-Zombie" or you're using the words fundamentally differently than I am, I think.

I hope this doesn't sound offensive, and apologize in advance if so. I am genuinely and sincerely curious about this.