Second. How do you reconcile it with AnandTech's tests that show that the iPhone 4 is better at keeping calls even with a poor signal?
I made some research on this and found http://arxiv.org/pdf/physics/0210022 which says basically that drop rates among 720 different carriers have a lognormal distribution with mean of about 2.4%.
iPhone 4 might have better RF and baseband chain to compensate, but it's clearly not enough when the phone seems to lose the signal altogether.
Edit: Jobs said clearly that the 4 drops ~1 calls more per 100 than the 3GS. 1 per 100 -> 2 per 100.
1 more is still a ton, an average user probably does more than 100 calls per month so... that's a drop call per month and for people in shitty area that could be multiple a week on the high end (some people never drop calls on the iPhone)
Jobs said: "One or less additional dropped call per hundred calls". I don't know how I should parse this to be "one percent more dropped calls than 3GS".
"It means that if the 3GS drops 1% of calls, the iPhone 4 drops 1.01% of calls."
"If the 3GS drops 1% of calls", it drops one call per hundred.
That means the iPhone 4 drops two calls per hundred, or 2% of one hundred calls. Not 1.01%.
Just to show I'm somewhat unbiased on the issue -- if we want to question Apple's data why did they show AT&T store returns and not Apple Store returns?
That's not the issue at hand. The issue with the iPhone 4 is that it's very easy to drop calls and get signal attenuation. The reports are too numerous to be just a sporadic problem. Whether this is a problem in the manufacturing process (which would explain why not all telephones have the problem) or the design, only Apple knows.
At first they say there is no antenna problem. Then they say it's a bug in the software. Now they say "well all phones have this problem".
I think inspector Columbo would say "Aahh! Of course, all phones have the problem... Now Mr. Jobs, just one more thing..."