Re:RIM on Apple's claims of Blackberry Bold signal loss
by fuzzybassoon on Saturday July 17, 2010 @10:29AM
(#1523822)
Unfortunately, you're misunderstanding what Jobs said. They said it drops ~1 call per hundred than the 3GS, not 1 percentage point more. That's a huge difference. It means that if the 3GS drops 1% of calls, the iPhone 4 drops 1.01% of calls.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:RIM on Apple's claims of Blackberry Bold signal loss
by Geee on Saturday July 17, 2010 @10:59AM
(#1523877)
What? I don't really get my head around your math or I just misunderstand what you are trying to say. 1 call per 100 calls means one percentage point.
Jobs said: "One or less additional dropped call per hundred calls". I don't know how I should parse this to be "one percent more dropped calls than 3GS".
Re:RIM on Apple's claims of Blackberry Bold signal loss
by nlogn on Saturday July 17, 2010 @11:06AM
(#1523884)
Actually I believe Geee is correct and YOU are misunderstanding Jobs. Here's the actual quote: "...iPhone 4 drops more calls than the 3GS. But how many more calls per hundred does it drop?...The iPhone 4 drops less than ONE call per hundred than the 3GS.” To me this reads clearly that were one to make 100 calls on each device, the iPhone 4 would drop between 0 and 1 more calls than the 3gs which is consistent with Geee's interpretation.
Re:RIM on Apple's claims of Blackberry Bold signal loss
by zacharye on Saturday July 17, 2010 @10:51AM
(#1523862)
You lost me. AT&T's data, according to Jobs, suggests the iPhone 4 drops one additional call per hundred when compared to the 3GS.
"It means that if the 3GS drops 1% of calls, the iPhone 4 drops 1.01% of calls."
"If the 3GS drops 1% of calls", it drops one call per hundred.
That means the iPhone 4 drops two calls per hundred, or 2% of one hundred calls. Not 1.01%.
Re:RIM on Apple's claims of Blackberry Bold signal loss
by jsz0 on Saturday July 17, 2010 @10:43AM
(#1523851)
It looks like lots of people just read live blogs and second hand accounts. It's shocking to see how easily and quickly the facts get mutated these days.
Just to show I'm somewhat unbiased on the issue -- if we want to question Apple's data why did they show AT&T store returns and not Apple Store returns?