News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Have you partnered with thieves and robbers? by Ygor on Saturday July 17, 2010 @04:26AM (#1523494)
"if Virgin Music and EMI etc., would have bought Napster (instead of suing it and closing it down) and then converted the site into their official mp3 website, iTunes would have been a me-too and not the gorilla it is today"

This part is interesting. Not so because of the concrete actors mentioned, but overall. It raises the question about the way the whole film/game/music industry battles piracy. Do You think they too could have found a better way, making it all to their benefit (and profit). Or have they done that already?

Re:Have you partnered with thieves and robbers? by ZachPruckowski on Saturday July 17, 2010 @12:34PM (#1524082)
The "music industry" got screwed on like 4 fronts at once. Actual piracy hurt, but the move from $20 CDs to $1 singles killed the "2-4 singles and 6-10 fillers" album model (now you're getting $2 for something you could have gotten $20 for, and sales didn't quintuple), falling production costs made Label Loan Sharking less attractive, and a rise of new distribution venues (MySpace and YouTube, where recorded music is a loss-leader for merch and concert sales) weakened their distribution monopoly.

They could probably survive or solve any one of those problems, but there's no way to survive all four.

The film industry has to wrangle with piracy, but there's still a large entry barrier to make something that looks like it has high production values. Similarly, there are fewer new distribution options, because there's no real "films as a loss leader" business model. They are picking up the pace of innovation with stuff like HD and 3D and 2K/4K precisely so that they can move the goal-posts on production/distribution upstarts. You can throw together a simple romantic comedy with few locations and no special effects for a few hundred thousand, but a HighDef 3-D adventure with city-bending CGI and special effects is gonna set you back piles of money.

Re:Have you partnered with thieves and robbers? by fragmede on Sunday July 18, 2010 @01:03PM (#1526131)
The film industry's high entry barrier is getting much, much lower. An Avid editing workstation now costs < $10k, they used to be more like $50k. At this years NAB, DaVinci (high-end color correcting software), went from being a $200k Linux system, to a $1k software package to be run on a Mac Pro you already own.

2K DPX is now doable on a (high end) NAS system where previously you needed a high end SAN with Fibre Channel, and Nvidia's Cuda makes a system that can do do "city-bending CGI and special effects" positively affordable.

Re:Have you partnered with thieves and robbers? by mseebach on Saturday July 17, 2010 @07:10AM (#1523611)
If you could go back to 1995 and show even the most open-minded EMI exec the state of business today, I'm not sure that his conclusion wouldn't be they they'd lost - completely.

The music industry has all but completely lost the power over distribution and discovery, and these were the areas that allowed them to pick up a kid off the street and make him a superstar and make people listen to him. When you make somebody a star, it's a bit harder for them to negotiate their salaries, than if you find someone already talented, with a following etc.

The head of the graph is roughly the same height, but it drops off much quicker and the tail is much fatter. Yes, they've more-or-less successfully transitioned to the new reality, but it's a much, much less lucrative reality.