Downvotes should be about bad form, not about "I don't agree with you". HN used to be about the former, but now is much more the latter, and it is a poorer community because of it. HN isn't the first online tech-news community, and every single one of these communities that uses an up/downvote mechanism to self-regulate comment quality have gone the same way: as an increasing number of users gain voting privileges, voting replaces debate. When that happens, the community becomes a simple echo-chamber for the "established" truth of that community. This increasingly keeps away quality commenters, strengthening the effect.
When voting, especially downvoting, is a frictionless, costless action, the quality of varied discourse will sooner or later die.