Downvotes should be about bad form, not about "I don't agree with you". HN used to be about the former, but now is much more the latter, and it is a poorer community because of it. HN isn't the first online tech-news community, and every single one of these communities that uses an up/downvote mechanism to self-regulate comment quality have gone the same way: as an increasing number of users gain voting privileges, voting replaces debate. When that happens, the community becomes a simple echo-chamber for the "established" truth of that community. This increasingly keeps away quality commenters, strengthening the effect.
When voting, especially downvoting, is a frictionless, costless action, the quality of varied discourse will sooner or later die.
Sounds like a typical software development effort. we always used to say that if we built bridges the way we write software, there wouldn't be many bridges. Well, now we build cars the way we build software, and guess what is happening...
I firmly believe that this is all safety critical code, and we should look to NASA to ask how its done:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Power_of_10:_Rules_for_Dev...
and
https://www.fastcompany.com/28121/they-write-right-stuff
But hey, all that boring "safety" stuff is expensive, and takes too much time to complete....
EDIT: As has now become usual for HN, I am being downvoted instead of debated. This used to be a site for good debate. Too bad that's no longer the case.