News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why American Workers Pay Twice as Much in Taxes as Wealth... by gnicholas on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @11:00AM (#15227810)
> You owe the IRS about $38,500 more, assuming each of us pays the maximum with no special deductions.

This also assumes the investor has no interest income, which would be unlikely. For a younger person with a big nest egg, this wouldn't be a huge chunk of their assets. But as you age you'd want to shift into less-risky assets, like interest-bearing ones.

Also, investors would probably be diversified into real estate (which generates rental income, which is taxed as ordinary income). There are tricks that can be played in real estate, of course, but there's also lots of ordinary income tax paid.

> I get to skip about $24,000 in payroll taxes that you and your employer must fork over each year.

"Payroll taxes" includes social security, which the worker will collect until he/she dies. It is also payable to the worker's spouse in certain circumstances. But you only get to collect social security to the extent you paid into the system. So if there's an economic downturn, the worker will have social security to fall back on in old age, where the investor will not.

The general point remains, but this is a highly stylized example designed to emphasize (hyperbolize) the author's point.

Re:Why American Workers Pay Twice as Much in Taxes as Wealth... by rgbrenner on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @12:24PM (#15228632)
But you only get to collect social security to the extent you paid into the system

Medicare and social security payout more in benefits than you paid in: http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/article/2013/feb/01/...

Re:Why American Workers Pay Twice as Much in Taxes as Wealth... by gnicholas on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @01:02PM (#15229039)
I was trying to avoid saying "you only get benefits if you paid in", which oversimplifies the situation. If someone paid in for decades, they'll get more SS than if they paid in for 2 years. Basically, I meant "to the extent" to mean that it scales with participation. Thanks for the link — interesting details.
Re:Why American Workers Pay Twice as Much in Taxes as Wealth... by antisthenes on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @01:22PM (#15229242)
*If you live long enough, which isn't looking to be the case for the bottom quartile, considering the retirement age will be raised to 67 before our cohort will start retiring.
Re:Why American Workers Pay Twice as Much in Taxes as Wealth... by haikuginger on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @12:07PM (#15228445)
> But you only get to collect social security to the extent you paid into the system.

To clarify: Social Security benefits are calculated based on the 35 highest-earning years you report to the IRS, up to a maximum cap. You will _not_ "run out" of benefits at any point, but if you report under 35 years of earned income to the IRS, those zeros will play into the overall calculation of your benefit rate.

Re:Why American Workers Pay Twice as Much in Taxes as Wealth... by HockeyPlayer on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @01:35PM (#15229368)
> But as you age you'd want to shift into less-risky assets

Not if you are wealthy. If your money might not last you have to shift to conservative assets. But if you have 10x what you need for the rest of your life you can keep investing aggressively.

Re:Why American Workers Pay Twice as Much in Taxes as Wealth... by mgkimsal on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @12:52PM (#15228954)
> "Payroll taxes" includes social security, which the worker will collect until he/she dies

The example is citing someone who's pulling in $300k from dividends and capital gains each year from investments.

If there's enough of a downturn which would long-term imperil someone pulling in $300k off dividends, it may be big enough to impact social security itself, no?

Re:Why American Workers Pay Twice as Much in Taxes as Wealth... by pas on Wednesday September 13, 2017 @10:20AM (#15238501)
Well, no.

Big money from some investment now doesn't mean big money forever from that investment.

You can diversify and hedge, but then you're bound to get average market rate, that's basically the rate of Treasury bonds.

But if you get 300K from that per year, good for you.

Re:Why American Workers Pay Twice as Much in Taxes as Wealth... by aylmao on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @11:27AM (#15228057)
Yes. I would assume the article's point IS to emphasize the author's point.
Re:Why American Workers Pay Twice as Much in Taxes as Wealth... by gnicholas on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @11:42AM (#15228203)
Sure! It'd be more credible if it acknowledged the unrealistic assumptions that it's making. Reminds me of the Engineering dept t-shirt I saw in college: "assuming a spherical cow..."
Re:Why American Workers Pay Twice as Much in Taxes as Wealth... by aylmao on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @11:54AM (#15228319)
I mean, sure. But the point is to make the problem accessible to the reader, not to obscure it through the ton of variables present in real life.

Which actually goes back to the t-shirt example. If we had to consider a real cow every time, nobody would want to study engineering ¯\_(ツ)_/¯