You don't even have to take issue with the modeling or any other part of the methodology to debunk this study; it's the interpretation that is plainly ridiculous. As you said, these are pictures from a dating site; awfully likely that people choose to present themselves differently based on who they want to attract. Also no appropriate statistical test applied to differences in faces picked up by the model. See this for more: http://callingbullshit.org/case_studies/case_study_ml_sexual...
Sexuality is not a boolean value, it's not a yes or no, it's not a this or that, even for people who are attracted to females they are not attracted to every female, and people who are attracted to males are not attracted to every male. It's such a silly thing to try and hone in on, because it removes the primary deciding component of human sexuality from the study: personal, intimate, real human preference. It's like attempting to discover one's favorite flavor of bagel shmear based on high school portraits.
You may find some surprising results, realize neural nets are trainable phenomena, and then run around giving everyone plastic surgery because more pronounced cheek bones tend to prefer Strawberry Shmear, and if peoples' cheek bones were adjusted their flavor preference would change.
Why couldn't physical features change?
I believe hormone changes can affect appearances, so it doesn't seem beyond the realm of possibility.
> Sexuality is not a boolean value, it's not a yes or no, it's not a this or that
Did it occur to you that possibly the correlation with facial characteristics could be a matter of degree?
Consider the correlation between facial characteristics and racial background. I'm half European, half Asian. There's going to be a stronger correlation between people with near 100% European ancestry and "European facial characteristics" than people with 50% European ancestry, than people with 25% European ancestry, etc
No, it doesn't. It means sexual orientation and hormonal/chemical composition might be related, and hormonal/chemical composition might affect facial composition.
Everything you wrote afterwards is just an emotional outburst to an uncomfortable results from a study you obviously didn't bother reading.
Yes, I am emotionally bothered by this whole enterprise, because sexual orientation is not something you can understand through portraits, and this study makes the claim that 7/10 times a computer can do it. That's not the case.
Let's say there's a 50% chance that hormonal/chemical composition and sexual orientation are related, and let's say there's a 50% chance that hormonal composition affects facial features. That means that for the both of them to work out we have a 25% chance they are correlated. That's a pretty generous estimate, given that there is no data supporting the second half of that equation where "hormonal composition affects facial composition" as far as I'm aware.
The best we are doing with this dataset is inferring hormonal composition from what someone put down as their sexual preference. Or am I missing a large piece of the puzzle?
What's the big deal? We've already got people thinking their toddlers are transgendered because they picked up a doll one time...