Re:Geneticists pan paper that claims to predict a person's f...
by Ygg2 on Saturday September 09, 2017 @07:39PM
(#15209681)
Yeah, but they also grew in same uterine environment.
Re:Geneticists pan paper that claims to predict a person's f...
by mbreese on Saturday September 09, 2017 @08:32PM
(#15209852)
They also probably grow up together, have similar diets, speak the same language... there are lots of correlated environmental factors with twins aside from their DNA.
A better comparison would be separated twins (widely separated). But I'm not sure if anyone has looked at the relative differences between twins raised together vs apart.
Re:Geneticists pan paper that claims to predict a person's f...
by Mayzie on Monday September 11, 2017 @04:44AM
(#15217004)
> A better comparison would be separated twins (widely separated).
The two people in The Parent Trap are twins and were widely separated, yet they still looked identical, so much so that their parents could not even tell them apart.
Re:Geneticists pan paper that claims to predict a person's f...
by findyoucef on Saturday September 09, 2017 @09:46PM
(#15210076)
There is a documentary I think on Netflix of twins who find each other randomly on the internet. I think the were Korean and we're adopted by two families. One in California and another in France.
Re:Geneticists pan paper that claims to predict a person's f...
by bmsran on Saturday September 09, 2017 @09:55PM
(#15210113)
It is common to compare traits in monozygotic vs dizygotic twins to help control for shared environments.
Re:Geneticists pan paper that claims to predict a person's f...
by carbocation on Saturday September 09, 2017 @07:58PM
(#15209741)
True! But this seems to set some limits the timeline of significant environmental influence.
Re:Geneticists pan paper that claims to predict a person's f...
by mchahn on Saturday September 09, 2017 @09:40PM
(#15210051)
> The fact that identical twins look similar suggests that most of the variation in facial identity is going to be driven by a heritable element.
I don't see how you get to that conclusion. If a set of twins inherited nothing from their parents they could still be identical. The DNA could be generated randomly and then duplicated.
This is just a logic argument as clearly everyone inherits many things from parents.
Re:Geneticists pan paper that claims to predict a person's f...
by aptwebapps on Sunday September 10, 2017 @12:54AM
(#15210717)
You can argue about the effects of different genes but you can't reasonably argue that children do not get their genes from their parents.
However, that depends on correctly mapping the program to its output. I'm skeptical that we're at the point where we can model this correctly. I think this is why you see that all of the predicted faces in the Venter paper look like a generic/averaged face.