Re:Safari is the new IE
by johncolanduoni on Saturday September 09, 2017 @01:58PM
(#15208257)
Chrome's renderer started as a fork of WebKit. Last time I checked nobody was able to fork any version of IE.
That's not my point.
Thread says "Safari is holding the web back". Parents answers "Safari created the tools that lead to big parts of the modern web".
My answer is: so did IE 5/6. That doesn't mean after a while and for a long time they weren't holding the web back, it's a side fact that has no relevance.
> Also one could argue that if Apple did not invest so much in WebKit then chrome would have had a harder time achieving its current usage and would probably be a very different browser than what it is today.
The same can be said on an even larger scale about microsoft and IE 5 and 6; that doesn't mean in anyway that years later they were not a pain stopping the web from going forward. In other word, I don't see how that has any impact on the conversation at end (neither for or against the point made).
EDIT: Not sure why the downvotes.
Apple invested a lot into Safari (and thus webkit which lead to chrome). Doesn't change in any way if Safari is or isn't holding the web back currently, which is why I say it's irrelevant to paren't countering argument.
And in fact, we have a previous examples since we lived the same scenario with Microsoft who invested a lot into IE 5/6 (and leading into DHTML, XMLHttpRequest, ...), which then definitely hold the web back.
This is, literally, the same argument. I don't see how I can be downvoted for stating that obvious fact unless you think that IE 6 didn't hold the web back after a while.