News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Safari is the new IE by nolok on Saturday September 09, 2017 @01:51PM (#15208207)
I do not know enough about Safari to agree or disagree with your general point, but I find this part to be really irrelevant:

> Also one could argue that if Apple did not invest so much in WebKit then chrome would have had a harder time achieving its current usage and would probably be a very different browser than what it is today.

The same can be said on an even larger scale about microsoft and IE 5 and 6; that doesn't mean in anyway that years later they were not a pain stopping the web from going forward. In other word, I don't see how that has any impact on the conversation at end (neither for or against the point made).

EDIT: Not sure why the downvotes.

Apple invested a lot into Safari (and thus webkit which lead to chrome). Doesn't change in any way if Safari is or isn't holding the web back currently, which is why I say it's irrelevant to paren't countering argument.

And in fact, we have a previous examples since we lived the same scenario with Microsoft who invested a lot into IE 5/6 (and leading into DHTML, XMLHttpRequest, ...), which then definitely hold the web back.

This is, literally, the same argument. I don't see how I can be downvoted for stating that obvious fact unless you think that IE 6 didn't hold the web back after a while.

Re:Safari is the new IE by johncolanduoni on Saturday September 09, 2017 @01:58PM (#15208257)
Chrome's renderer started as a fork of WebKit. Last time I checked nobody was able to fork any version of IE.
Re:Safari is the new IE by nolok on Saturday September 09, 2017 @02:17PM (#15208369)
That's not my point.

Thread says "Safari is holding the web back". Parents answers "Safari created the tools that lead to big parts of the modern web".

My answer is: so did IE 5/6. That doesn't mean after a while and for a long time they weren't holding the web back, it's a side fact that has no relevance.