News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Google Interview by csomar on Friday July 16, 2010 @02:44AM (#1520490)
I don't know Cletus, I just noticed his profile somehow in StackOverFlow. However, as a brilliant StackOverFlow member with over 100K of points and 3K answers, I really wonder if he is not above the average developer.

Only experienced developers can contribute and answer question in Stackoverflow. Questions are generally hard and random.

So if Google hires only from the top 10% (say in Australia); isn't this a critical fail in the hiring process? (considering cletus with ranking 4 in sof, I can safely say he's among the top 1% or 0.5%)

Re:My Google Interview by jackowayed on Friday July 16, 2010 @03:13AM (#1520531)
I don't think you can "safely say" that he's among the top 1% of developers based purely on his StackOverflow profile, regardless of how impressive it is.

The only way you can really "safely say" that someone is within the top 1% (That's a pretty elite group. That's like saying "I can safely say he'll get into Harvard.") is if you've seen a significant amount of their actual code (working with them, OSS, etc) and been consistently amazed.

Re:My Google Interview by cletus on Friday July 16, 2010 @03:36AM (#1520565)
The "top 1%" is such a great phenomenon. I remember in the 2000 election the top 1% of earners were daemonized by then VP Gore. In a survey some 20% of people thought they were in the top 1% and another 19% aspired to be.

And that's with something easily quantifiable. How exactly do you quantify the percentile of a programmer?

FWIW I make no such claim about being the top 1% nor do I claim SO ranking translates to the nebulous concept of a programmer's ranking. If anything, SO reputation is a function of time more than anything else. It's also an indicator of persistence but only a positive indicator (meaning lack of a SO ranking obviously doesn't mean a lack of persistence).

Re:My Google Interview by waqf on Sunday July 18, 2010 @07:05PM (#1527006)
> the top 1% of earners were daemonized by then VP Gore

He set them to run in the background and wake up periodically?

Re:My Google Interview by barrkel on Friday July 16, 2010 @04:13AM (#1520619)
By the same token, however, don't overestimate the competence of the vast majority of working stiffs who have titles describing them as programmers. Many (I would estimate well over 50%) just turn simple business requirements into business rules by copying and pasting earlier implementations, and getting things done by sheer persistence mixed with some googling, forum questions, etc.
Re:My Google Interview by aaronbrethorst on Friday July 16, 2010 @04:24AM (#1520643)
He wants to go to the Sorbonne. Harvard is his safety.

(Apologies to Wes Anderson)

Re:My Google Interview by nostrademons on Friday July 16, 2010 @03:24AM (#1520545)
There's also the issue of company fit. Google turns away a lot of very good developers because they're not good in a way that will translate to success within Google's culture.
Re:My Google Interview by tkahn6 on Friday July 16, 2010 @03:31AM (#1520555)
Most of the questions asked on SO generally fall upon a spectrum of either "super domain specific" or "fundamental misunderstanding about a language". And then you have questions orthogonal to those classifications such as "what's the best IDE" or "do you think programmers MUST have two monitors?".

There are comparatively few questions that would fall under the category of computer science. I would be hesitant to say that having a lot of points on SO would automatically mean you are a genius programmer or problem solver.

Go look at Jon Skeet's top grossing answers. Only one of them is related to computer science.

Re:My Google Interview by barrkel on Friday July 16, 2010 @04:15AM (#1520623)
Top questions and top answers are almost by definition bikeshedding trivia, because those are the only kind which can draw a large enough population to get really high votes.
Re:My Google Interview by tkahn6 on Friday July 16, 2010 @09:44AM (#1521098)
Definitely true. The point I should have emphasized is that the StackOverflow questions and answers usually are about a user's experience with a framework/language or lack thereof. Few questions require answers that are creative or profoundly intellectual.