News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What the Rich Won't Tell You by cjlars on Friday September 08, 2017 @06:13PM (#15204325)
I don't think there's a threshhold. Take Bill Gates for example. He's done a lot of good in his life. He built a huge company that transformed personal computing, employed an army of people and then put billions of dollars into poverty mediation programs that the world's governments didn't seem to be able to handle. Along the way, he also payed billions in taxes. Without old Bill, the world is many billions of dollars poorer.

I think there's a lot of value in letting people that are 10,000x better than the average person at creating wealth do so. Maybe there should be something to limit the excesses of luxurious consumption (I for one, favor a progressive VAT), but I think trying to impose punitively high tax rates on very successful people makes society worse off in most cases.

Re:What the Rich Won't Tell You by crimsonalucard on Friday September 08, 2017 @06:32PM (#15204424)
Bill did not build a company alone. He built it off the backs of employees. His earnings are so substantial that it is fundamentally impossible for him to earn it off of his own two hands and intelligence alone. No one man has enough intelligence or physical ability to generate a billion dollars. Can one man create the windows operating system? Can one man construct a boeing 747? If no one man can construct a boeing 747 than how can their exist people who have wealth greater than the worth of a passenger airliner? There is only one explanation. This wealth was earned unfairly.

What Bill and all other billionaires do is utilize the labor of other people. Microsoft, Amazon, Facebook, and Apple are all group efforts where humanity pools their collective power together to construct something greater than one man can produce. The issue here is that, the leaders of these groups get rewards that are disproportionate. There is no way one human can contribute labor worth 50 billion dollars to the world. It it physically impossible. The taxes that Bill paid is wealth generated by the employees, not Bill.

Re:What the Rich Won't Tell You by slededit on Friday September 08, 2017 @06:53PM (#15204534)
Bill was able to organize the labor of people into something more productive than the sum of its parts. That is a relatively rare skill. Luck comes into it, and we can debate how much of a factor time, place, family networks, etc played into it. But regardless there were incumbents that were much more likely to succeed than him at the start.

IBM had the biggest advantage here. Snatching defeat from the jaws of certain victory is one of the largest blunders in modern business.

Gary Kildall failed to land a suitable deal with IBM, and would have been the next in line to be Bill Gates. Even if he did make the deal his personality made it unlikely he'd structure the deal as BillG did which enabled the clone market.

Or Seattle Computer Products that owned the actual DOS BillG used.

Ultimately it was BillG that executed the vision and did so relentlessly for multiple decades. Not many other executives were sleeping under their desks at the time. This was particularly what impressed IBM enough to take a chance on them. Their work ethic as a company was well noted in the industry. BillG set that example from the top.

Re:What the Rich Won't Tell You by gertef on Friday September 08, 2017 @07:13PM (#15204632)
Bill G used a mixture of cuthroat and illegal activities to crush competition and create a monopoly. In his absence, we may well hve had a thriving ecosystem of compatible adn far more secure technology. Or some other cutthrouat like Steve Jobs would have won. Just because the game is winner-take-all doesn't mean the winner did nearly all the valuable work.
Re:What the Rich Won't Tell You by slededit on Friday September 08, 2017 @09:06PM (#15205041)
That was true in the 90s with netscape. Less so during the 80s when his position was being cemented. He even sent IBM over to Gary Kildall initially. It was only after that meeting failed that he went out and bought QDOS.

The point is that Microsoft wasn't always a monopoly. It took skill to get there, and there were opponents that started with much better hands.

Re:What the Rich Won't Tell You by coldtea on Saturday September 09, 2017 @11:57PM (#15210500)
>Bill was able to organize the labor of people into something more productive than the sum of its parts. That is a relatively rare skill.

Citation needed. Why it's a rare skill? How about it's a rare opportunity offered to too few people?

I think that a market only can support/bear a number of successful companies (and thus CEOs etc) which is smaller than the number of otherwise competent potential CEOs.

Instead of seeing someone like Gate as an ubermench with natural CEO-talent, I believe that tons of people are never offered the chance -- through lack of luck, lack of educational opportunities, bad background, etc to be able to start a company.

Re:What the Rich Won't Tell You by slededit on Sunday September 10, 2017 @12:54AM (#15210714)
Yes it's true there can be only so many. However the skill of BillG is that he made his company the one to dominate. As I said earlier he was not anywhere close to having the strongest hand at the start.

It's skill in the same way someone with a mediocre poker hand bluffs their way to victory.

Re:What the Rich Won't Tell You by cjlars on Friday September 08, 2017 @08:43PM (#15204979)
And everyone was paid. Where is the unfairness in voluntary transactions?

If you're trying to argue that, "it would have just happened anyway", all you're asserting is that the profits would have gone to someone else, but at a lag of several months to several years. Why is slowing down technological advancement an improvement?

Re:What the Rich Won't Tell You by crimsonalucard on Saturday September 09, 2017 @03:07AM (#15205908)
In third world countries people voluntarily get paid 10 cents an hour. Where is the unfairness there?

A contract between an employer and an employee can establish a salary that is only agreed upon. Both parties can agree to either a salary that is fair, or is unfair. It is totally possible in this reality to voluntarily agree to unfair policies.

>If you're trying to argue that, "it would have just happened anyway", all you're asserting is that the profits would have gone to someone else, but at a lag of several months to several years. Why is slowing down technological advancement an improvement?

When did I say slowing down technological advancement an improvement? You're making a lot of random stuff up here. I've never claimed to have stated nor do I understand any of your statements here.

Re:What the Rich Won't Tell You by crimsonalucard on Friday September 08, 2017 @07:23PM (#15204696)
Is organizing labor a skill as rare as building a boeing 747 with your bare hands and raw intelligence? I would say that the aforementioned skill is so rare, no human being on the face of the earth has the ability to build an airliner by themselves. Yet here we have man named Bill Gates who possesses more wealth then several airliners.

Bill Gates probably deserves to be a millionaire, but no man deservers to be billionaire... it's just obscene to say such a thing.

Re:What the Rich Won't Tell You by slededit on Friday September 08, 2017 @09:08PM (#15205046)
There are many engineers. Very few of them are building new organizations that make things like 747s possible. How much this "skill" is worth can be debated. But if you go by scarcity its certainly more scarce than engineering talent.
Re:What the Rich Won't Tell You by crimsonalucard on Saturday September 09, 2017 @03:00AM (#15205888)
How much skill required to build new organizations is also debatable. Sure there are few people who actually build organizations, but is it because the skill is scarce or is it because the positions accommodating this skill are few and far in-between? If a pauper can replace a prince then it must mean anyone including a pauper can do the job of the prince.

Trust me. Gathering people and telling them what to do is 100 times easier than actually doing it.

Re:What the Rich Won't Tell You by AnimalMuppet on Friday September 08, 2017 @06:49PM (#15204516)
> There is only one explanation. This wealth was earned unfairly.

Define "unfairly".

If by "unfairly", you mean "earned by owning a company that paid its employees well, gave them stock options that made millionaires out of many of them, and still made the owner insanely rich", well, that's kind of an odd definition of "unfairly".

Re:What the Rich Won't Tell You by crimsonalucard on Friday September 08, 2017 @07:16PM (#15204649)
This is hard to define and is subjective. I use a hard metric for my own definition that makes sense.

Find a physical product that is fundamentally impossible to be built by one man. Say a boeing 747. Find a man who has more wealth then the cost of a boeing 747. By common sense: if it is impossible for a man to build a 747 with his bare hands then it is impossible for a man to own more wealth then the cost of a 747 without going through trades and transactions that are unfair. If such a man exists then he attained his wealth through unfair transactions.

This is my definition of unfair. You may have another definition and I respect that. IMO in the ideal world Bill Gates probably deserves to be a millionaire and billionaires would represent a perversion of wealth that is insanely obscene.

Re:What the Rich Won't Tell You by AnimalMuppet on Friday September 08, 2017 @09:10PM (#15205059)
> By common sense: if it is impossible for a man to build a 747 with his bare hands then it is impossible for a man to own more wealth then the cost of a 747 without going through trades and transactions that are unfair.

I don't consider that to be common sense at all. If nothing else, all the humans in the world put together couldn't make a 747 with their bare hands. And yet all the people in the world together have far more wealth than the cost of a 747. So I think there's something faulty in your logic.

More to the point: Who was Gates unfair to? His own workers? He paid them well, in fact above market rates. His customers? They wanted his products more than they wanted their own money.

It sounds like you're just looking at his wealth and saying "that's unfair" without having any idea of what he actually did that's unfair. That's... rather weak.

Re:What the Rich Won't Tell You by crimsonalucard on Saturday September 09, 2017 @02:52AM (#15205870)
>all the humans in the world put together couldn't make a 747 with their bare hands.

How does this make sense. How do 747s exist if they are not created by our hands? Maybe it's my mistake, I am not precluding hands from using tools, as long as the tools are eventually made by hands somewhere along the supply chain. Lets not complicate the matter with deliberate nitpicking. This is not faulty logic, the fault is with you.

>More to the point: Who was Gates unfair to? His own workers? He paid them well, in fact above market rates. His customers? They wanted his products more than they wanted their own money.

I'm talking about his own workers. Market rate in India is 5 cents an hour. Market rate is rarely fair. If you think market rate is fair then you are highly highly mistaken.

>It sounds like you're just looking at his wealth and saying "that's unfair" without having any idea of what he actually did that's unfair. That's... rather weak.

Sounds like you made a claim about something I'm doing when I already told you my reasoning. Sounds like you didn't read what I wrote. I'll repeat the logic. He is being unfair because his wealth is to obscenely high for one man to own. What does that mean? It means what he "did" is underpay people working for him.

Do I really need to spell out the logic? I am describing a dead body and I am calling the man with a bloody knife standing next the dead body the murderer and you are asking me to point out what he actually "did"

Re:What the Rich Won't Tell You by jimmies on Monday September 11, 2017 @02:43PM (#15221008)
Or maybe you could read "I, pencil"...
Re:What the Rich Won't Tell You by cjlars on Friday September 08, 2017 @08:38PM (#15204960)
>if it is impossible for a man to build a 747 with his bare hands

&

>without going through trades and transactions that are unfair

It's fundamentally impossible for one man to build even the microwave that preheats the meals inside a 747, but that's no reasonable threshold. The entirety of modern life is built on transacting goods and services that are fundamentally impossible to create alone -- are you trying to say that all transactions are unfair? Or just Bill Gates'? Or just transactions that are too skillfully done?

Re:What the Rich Won't Tell You by crimsonalucard on Friday September 08, 2017 @09:26PM (#15205110)
This is not true at all. A microwave can be built by the knowledge and skills of a single man.

Additionally you are not thinking holistically. Take your computer: a device that needs the manpower of thousands to create. Such a device is only as cheap as it is because of mass production on an automated factory line. The true value thus cannot be measured by an individual computer but by the intrinsic value of the technology as a whole. This is hard to measure. I chose a 747 because 747s are not produced on a robotic factory line. They are built by machinists, so each plane is a more accurate measure of a products' true value.

I am saying that in a capitalist economy. The majority of transactions are unfair. The lower class gets screwed perpetually. This is a fact of life.

Re:What the Rich Won't Tell You by Retra on Friday September 08, 2017 @07:06PM (#15204596)
Are you aware of the concept of loaded language?