The point is that Microsoft wasn't always a monopoly. It took skill to get there, and there were opponents that started with much better hands.
Citation needed. Why it's a rare skill? How about it's a rare opportunity offered to too few people?
I think that a market only can support/bear a number of successful companies (and thus CEOs etc) which is smaller than the number of otherwise competent potential CEOs.
Instead of seeing someone like Gate as an ubermench with natural CEO-talent, I believe that tons of people are never offered the chance -- through lack of luck, lack of educational opportunities, bad background, etc to be able to start a company.
It's skill in the same way someone with a mediocre poker hand bluffs their way to victory.
If you're trying to argue that, "it would have just happened anyway", all you're asserting is that the profits would have gone to someone else, but at a lag of several months to several years. Why is slowing down technological advancement an improvement?
A contract between an employer and an employee can establish a salary that is only agreed upon. Both parties can agree to either a salary that is fair, or is unfair. It is totally possible in this reality to voluntarily agree to unfair policies.
>If you're trying to argue that, "it would have just happened anyway", all you're asserting is that the profits would have gone to someone else, but at a lag of several months to several years. Why is slowing down technological advancement an improvement?
When did I say slowing down technological advancement an improvement? You're making a lot of random stuff up here. I've never claimed to have stated nor do I understand any of your statements here.
Bill Gates probably deserves to be a millionaire, but no man deservers to be billionaire... it's just obscene to say such a thing.
Trust me. Gathering people and telling them what to do is 100 times easier than actually doing it.
IBM had the biggest advantage here. Snatching defeat from the jaws of certain victory is one of the largest blunders in modern business.
Gary Kildall failed to land a suitable deal with IBM, and would have been the next in line to be Bill Gates. Even if he did make the deal his personality made it unlikely he'd structure the deal as BillG did which enabled the clone market.
Or Seattle Computer Products that owned the actual DOS BillG used.
Ultimately it was BillG that executed the vision and did so relentlessly for multiple decades. Not many other executives were sleeping under their desks at the time. This was particularly what impressed IBM enough to take a chance on them. Their work ethic as a company was well noted in the industry. BillG set that example from the top.