Oh shit! The government knows I bought something from custom-fishing-lures.com! Ruuuuun!
Seriously, what you just listed is a reason not to use the government's Oauth for every website and ban all other implementations. What OP seemed to say, and what I disputed, is the idea that this service should not ever be used by any private website even as one of several options.
The US does not have legally-mandated job-protected leave for pre-trial detention, people have been terminated (for cause, and so not eligible for unemployment, either) for missing one day of work due to an arrest for which no charges were ever filed.
BTW in case anyone thinks it was a ridiculously contrived example, I was just trying to illustrate that what one person thinks is totally innocuous can appear damning to someone else.
The state exists as the means for ensuring positive societal outcomes, such as providing services that the private competitive market cannot or will not supply (tragedy of the commons, game theory, etc). One such possible service is an identity service - and we already have that through a hodge-podge of things like SSN, driving licenses, passports, etc. A consolidation of these services means greater efficiency, less waste, and therefore lower taxes.
I'd respect the libertarian position more if it were framed as "greater utility of government" instead of the dogmatic "less government".
This is the moral basis for outcomes like, snuffing out a person for selling loose cigarettes. In the end, the privileged get away with infractions that hurt people en masse, and the disposessed get punished for offending the sensibilities of those who get to define "positivity" on behalf of society.
I'd respect the state position more if there were well defined metrics for "greater utility" and a stronger non self regulating mechanism for accountability, instead of the dogmatic principle that voting constitutes consent.
That's a far greater threat than that they might shut off any given person's access.
Step 1) regulate all speech by vaguely defined hate speech laws, which change based on who has power
Step 2) Start arbitrarily destroying sites based on who is in power, utilizing login.gov + speech controls, to deem a given site in violation of speech codes
Or, more plausibly, selectively refuses to authenticate you to certain classes of sites, whether “all non-government sites” or something more targeted.
The government does shady stuff all the time. It's unwise to give them such an easy kill-switch that cuts off any particular citizen's access at any time.
The government is made up of people, and given enough people, at least one is bound to do something stupid for reasons most won't understand. If someone can do something, no matter how ridiculous, at some point, someone will.
Sites will use such a service to invade your privacy even further, and the government has a record of every site you've logged into and when.
That's not how OAuth works. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OAuth
> the government has a record of every site you've logged into
Only the ones where you chose to use their service. Or are we imaginging a future where this service has been made mandatory, and logins and passwords have been abolished?
Honestly, the amount of FUD in this thread is absurd. The government already has an enormous amount of information about your online activity! If they want more, their strategy will probably not be writing open source software and hoping you opt in to it!
> Only the ones where you chose to use their service.
There are hundreds of websites that require you to use Facebook to log in. With government-sanctioned ID, it will be worse.
> Or are we imaginging a future where this service has been made mandatory, and logins and passwords have been abolished?
This already exists in several countries, including Korea. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resident_registration_number
Hopefully this serves as an indicator that your skepticism on this topic is wildly miscalibrated. There's no "imagination" involved, this is how it is right now in places where this exists.
> their strategy will probably not be writing open source software and hoping you opt in to it!
That is the exact strategy I would use if my goal was to help the government gain more control over the internet. Letting people give their freedom away in exchange for a bit of convenience is one of the oldest tricks in the book.
The reason I'm not worried about the government finding out which websites I visit is because they already know, from traffic inspection at the ISP level. Don't think I'm the one miscalibrated here.
Beyond that, the problem with this "but they might do something bad!" argument is not that it's false, it's that it's always true in every case. Literally every government policy could be the precursor to something terrible. Sure, they could introduce an optional OAuth to try to stop identity theft and then later use it to censor the internet, but they could also just censor the internet straightaway.
Yes, this is true. If all websites start requiring their visitors to do something their visitors overwhelmingly don't want, the result would be something their visitors don't want. Kind of suggests that they won't do that, yes?
We will probably have to agree to disagree here; you're imagining a world where oauth.fed.gov slowly becomes more and more widespread until it's ubiquitous and we have no other options, and that just doesn't sound realistic to me. (I think it would struggle for adoption even if it were implemented perfectly and had the best privacy controls possible, due to exactly the fears you're enumerating in this discussion) But we are talking about something hypothetical, so either of us could be right.
At any rate thanks for arguing forcefully but staying respectful and on topic!
Again, please look at what's happening in South Korea. I think you're vastly underestimating how likely businesses are to adopt such a thing and how likely the government is to gradually incentivize (and eventually force) businesses into using it.
Wha-huh? Why? What specifically is wrong with login.gov (or any government agency) running an oauth server and private websites allowing users to authenticate with it? How does that result in "a major new point of U.S. government control over the Internet"?