Re:EasyDNS refuses to host The DailyStormer domain
by mrguyorama on Friday September 08, 2017 @12:16PM
(#15201488)
The fear that most Free Speech absolutists have is that tomorrow it will be: "I mean, not being a socialist|capitalist|religious individual is an option..."
From an Ideals perspective, its a valid and valiant fear, but I don't understand the absolutist position. Legitimate verbal threats are still allowed under absolute free speech, but they obviously produce harm. Should we really allow anyone to threaten the life or livelihood of another human being without repercussion?
Absolutism in the other direction is just as dystopian as well. Follow the exact line of populist opinion or else.
So "Free speech on principal" people, where does it end? What ISN'T "Free Speech" to you?
Re:EasyDNS refuses to host The DailyStormer domain
by submersiveblue on Friday September 08, 2017 @12:37PM
(#15201697)
Anything that doesn't directly call for violence. If you're presenting a position that others are free to evaluate on the merits, then free speech covers it. The point of allowing free speech is to be open to the truth. That doesn't mean that the truth is never ugly or in disharmony with fashionable opinion.
Re:EasyDNS refuses to host The DailyStormer domain
by problems on Friday September 08, 2017 @12:27PM
(#15201600)
I think this has been answered many times over, even the most extreme free speech absolutists tend to agree that direct, specific threats are unacceptable. General, non-specific threats and expressing joy about violent acts however... opinions vary.
Re:EasyDNS refuses to host The DailyStormer domain
by krapp on Friday September 08, 2017 @12:53PM
(#15201837)
Cultural rejection of white supremacist and neo-nazi ideology isn't necessarily part of a slippery slope that will inevitably encompass all non-mainstream speech, rather it's a manifestation of free speech. Those beliefs had their trial in the marketplace of ideas and have been found to be culturally toxic, and intellectually and scientifically void. One can believe in free speech while also accepting that speech can have consequences, and that not all ideas have equal value, or necessarily deserve equal consideration.
I mean, not being a neo-Nazi is an option...