News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Comments now cost 99 cents and your name. by timmaah on Thursday July 15, 2010 @07:48PM (#1519688)
That is no different from the comments on most local papers now.

I'm amazed that a company that wants to be taken as a professional source for journalism allows those kinds of comments on their site. It just looks terrible to their image and adds nothing to the story.

Re:Comments now cost 99 cents and your name. by vog on Friday July 16, 2010 @04:45AM (#1520671)
> It just looks terrible to their image

Comments are from "ordinary people", so why would anyone measure the quality of an article by the quality of the comments? Does an article become less true or less readable just because it is followed by some bad comments?

In contrast, not publishing comments would lead to the impression of being unable to take criticism.

By publishing even the dumbest comments, they show that they are able to handle criticism, and that they don't suppress anyone's opinion.

> and adds nothing to the story

Comments serve a completely different purpose. While the article reflects the facts, the comments reflect the sentiment of the people. That's what they add to the story.

In some rare cases comments even add some interesting facts.

Re:Comments now cost 99 cents and your name. by hugh3 on Friday July 16, 2010 @09:24AM (#1521036)
Comments serve a completely different purpose. While the article reflects the facts, the comments reflect the sentiment of the people. That's what they add to the story

Except they don't reflect the sentiment of "the people", only the small subset with the time and inclination to comment. This usually winds up being folks with some kind of extreme opinion or other kind of bonnet-dwelling bee.

Re:Comments now cost 99 cents and your name. by lhnz on Friday July 16, 2010 @10:13AM (#1521188)
> Does an article become less true or less readable just because it is followed by some bad comments?

I see what you're saying, but remember than many people judge a news organisation by the calibre of its viewers and readers.