I disagree that conservatives are more likely to believe that C(slavery) was better than C(now), but I agree that conservatives are more likely to process an absolute morality position (with liberals it seems more complicated--most would say they support moral relativism, but they seem to view other moral systems as fundamentally racist and thus evil, which can't be far from moral absolutism). This is more an elaboration on your point than a correction, I think.
Why? I can consider something subjectively evil, that is, I can feel a strong moral repulsion without considering that judgment to be universal.
If moral relativism is true, as I believe it is barring evidence showing the opposite, then enforcing one's subjective morality is inevitable. Banning slavery and rape, enforcing property rights, all of that is enforcing subjective morality, since there's no other.
But it's not absolutism if one recognizes that the enforcement is based on subjective opinion and not on intrinsic qualities of the actions being banned.
Essentially, it's might makes right, and I just happen to be lucky that we opponents to slavery are mightier than its advocates.
Worse, I'd guess that there is a liberal/conservative element here. Liberals are more likely to believe that C(now) > C(slavery); they are also more likely to believe that all cultures are equal.