That's the difference.
Huge difference /s
Double_a_92 is pointing out a distinction -- USD is pure legal tender, that is mandated by the US government to be accepted for payments of debts. Bitcoin is not.
exactly.
I think that the same argument could be held for digital currencies, they were created for a similar purpose and then would also have fundamental value. The value that digital currencies has is far more tenuous than fiat currencies or gold.
But don't get me started on the value of gold. Gold has the same issues as fiat, it's just more likely to be stable after the complete breakdown of society.
The fundamental value of cryptocurrencies is a shared agreement of value amongst investors.
I imagine some snotty 14-year old would argue that there is no fundamental distinction between the two but that's not being economically serious.
If people stopped believing in America, the dollar would go. How little would have to fail for Bitcoin to have the same problem. I've heard that if the person who owns the large stake in Bitcoin were to transact even one of their coins, all hell would break loose. That doesn't spell stability to me. Neither does "forking" the currency.
Interesting, considering that the purchasing power of the dollar has been long in decline. It holds its place against other currencies, but with dollars you can't buy as much stuff/assets today as you could yesterday.
It's quite clear to me which one is a more moral system.
Again, based on your own definitions.
The fundamental value of a national currency is not violence. It is civil society.
It's quite clear to me which one is a more moral system.
It's not really clear to me how this word salad you've thrown out is supposed to be an actual argument.
And then Bitcoin is accepted in tens (maybe hundreds) of thousands of online stores.
Also only something like 10% of gold is used industrially, the rest is regular hoarding.
And Bitcoin has other uses as well.
But even if you ignore all that, you still can't answer what the fundamental value of 1kg of gold is - it's value is determined by the supply/demand, and has a lower limit, which is it's mining cost, which also changes all the time due to depletion, fuel costs, technological advanvements, land costs, etc.
You can settle $1 of government debt with $1.
If someone owes you $1, you can offer to take other amounts of other goods or currency, but you are required to take cash dollars.
I can wipe my butt with a dollar bill. I can use that dollar bill to snort a line of cocaine. I can make a paper football out of it. I can use it to help roll a joint. I can fold it into a small coin purse to hold change and keep it from rattling in my pocket.
The dollar bill, being a physical object, has some utility, and thus some value.
Can you do any of those things mentioned above with a Bitcoin?
That argument never made any sense to me. What's the fundamental value of $1?
People assign value to all things based on how desirable they are (the demand). There are rare exceptions, like when a government ties their national currency to something like the dollar, but that immediately creates a black market, where it trades for its real value, and because of that, the government exchange only works one way (to buy or to sell). See Bolivar as a current example.