Aren't they opposites?
> For a long time, I complained that the US couldn't afford such a thing, but we've been running a huge deficit for decades, and no one seems to care,
One mistake that people make is believing that no deficit is a good thing. Running a deficit is like borrowing to fund college.
Another is that money is worth something. If as a generation all the wealth was owned by rich retired unproductive people, but the only way that food is generated is from poor working people, the elderly are screwed. Savings are not value, they are a hope that the future generations as a whole will be kind enough to work for old people based only on how much old people did when they were productive.
If future generations decide they will not pay any attention to old people's money, what happens then? What do I care that in 1960 you worked 60 hour weeks saving $500,000 in assets. Why shouldn't my generation decide "lets reduce the value of the dollar to 10% of it's current value, and lets put a massive tax on assets to redistribute to working people (say swapping income tax for an asset tax). That way I only owe rich people 1 year's salary in debt, not 10, my wage would simply have a zero added to the end (as would prices). The tax relief would mean a real wage increase too.
You just rediscovered something that Marxists had concluded long ago: class wealth is a product of political control, not the other way around. If a class of people takes control of government, they can rewrite laws and the economic system to favor them, instead of the previous ruling class. That's the whole basis of the so-called "dictatorship of the proletariat".
> Aren't they opposites?
Not OP, but not necessarily. Basically, Libertarians strongly support civil liberties in many forms. That can mean supporting drug legalization (liberal) and also gun rights (conservative). It can also mean supporting an individual's right to discriminate in private business transactions (men's or all-white golf clubs, hetero-only bakeries) which would likely be viewed as a really conservative social stance.
Many Libertarians also strongly support States' Rights, which tend to lean conservative.
>Aren't they opposites?
It's sad that everything about American politics casts every issue in black and white, either/or, polar-opposites mentality, and must be labelled. I was just trying to "get on paper" for context with my post.
> Running a deficit is like borrowing to fund college.
That may have been the most unfortunate example you could have used, since so many people are not seeing the value of their education in the marketplace pay off that investment in a reasonable period. Regardless, I understand what you're saying, but if you're trying to tell me that the deficit that the US federal government consistently runs is a planned, strategic effort, I'm not buying it. ;-)
Having said that, government debt is a little different from personal or business debt for a couple of major reasons:
1. Government's don't die. If they do, debt is the least of your worries.
2. Governments can control inflation and print money.
Having said that, I'm not agreeing our amount of debt is good or even ok, it's just there are different things to consider and it isn't really analogous to personal or business debt.
Reducing th3 dollar's value will me1n that your imports will be ten times more expensive.. And for the tax, it will mean that all the people who can invest abroad instead of in the US will do it before the tax is applied..
I'd argue outsourcing and austerity are to blame.
Take a look at your infrastructure once in a while. It's crumbling and it's not robots who are rebuilding it, it's nobody.
And that company that builds that iPhone of yours? Uses a LOT of very fleshy robots.
And Tesla, which just built a single factory designed to produce 500,000 vehicles a year with ONLY robots? People are watching. If this succeeds (and I suspect it will), there's going to be a LOT more attempts at such a thing.
Tesla uses far more workers than NUMMI employed to build far fewer cars. In 1985, its first full year of production, NUMMI had 2,470 employees and produced 64,764 vehicles — about 26 vehicles per worker per year. By 1997, it had 4,844 workers and produced 357,809 vehicles — about 74 vehicles per worker per year.
Tesla, on the other hand, had between 6,000 and 10,000 workers in 2016 and manufactured 83,922 vehicles. That puts its vehicle-per-worker number between 8 and 14, about one-seventh the efficiency of NUMMI at its peak.
http://www.autonews.com/article/20170611/OEM01/170619951/tes...
I like Tesla, but Elon often talks about the future like it exists today. One day they'll be able to completely automate that factory, but first they need to become as efficient as the other auto manufacturers that already exist today.
Automation of production is something that all of auto manufacturers have pushed... and Tesla is far behind on that metric. I would not assume they get to full automation before Ford, GM, Toyota, etc.
It's funny, because I lean liberal and I don't. I think there will be plenty of jobs for a long time. I don't want to put words in your mouth, but is it possible what you're saying reflects some sort of bias you have about the inherent value of people who are less _____ than you? Can you say a little bit about what these supposedly useless/unmarketable people are like, what they have spent their time doing and why their skills have no value?
My hypothesis is different than yours: The pendulum in the employer class has swung towards authoritarian control over the last 50 years. Employers have tried to organize both their business and society so that employees either have fewer choices, or believe they have fewer choices.
Employers have organized things such that people are afraid to leave their jobs, through norms like employer-provided health insurance. They have pushed important work like customer service into an "hourly" category, which is considered unskilled, where wages can remain stagnant.
These norms benefit all employers, and can't easily be "shorted" by a single organization paying their employees their true value. To extract the true value from those workers you'd need to have a continually expanding management apparatus to provide space for those employees to grow into, and you run into scaling issues. Therefore the mispriced labor can only be "shorted" by a federated system of many businesses making the play together.
But the pendulum is swinging back. People are waking up to the idea that if they can contract themselves out to multiple clients, they can have leverage to extract their actual market rate from employers.
And software will eventually provide the market for the federated play I describe.
The people who are living this lifestyle ("gig"-only, or multiple part time jobs) seem to dislike it. Their income is unpredictable and highly variable, while their expenses are consistent and difficult to meet.
Please note that I'm not talking about software development consultants - I'm talking about Uber drivers and service industry hourly workers.
I'm puzzled by the question. Aren't we already seeing it? When it takes a 4-year degree to do an office clerk's job, doesn't this already indicate that people who can't get a degree are being phased out of the job market? If the employers with menial positions have enough selectivity in the job pool to weed out people without a degree -- for jobs that do NOT require them -- doesn't that, in itself, show that we're running out of jobs for people? I'm being simplistic for the sake of brevity, but it seems to me that there's a whole class of people (non-college-grads) that are being weeded out of the job market as we speak.
I think the old systems of employment have mostly run their course and are on the decline, but new systems based on loosely federated networks of independent contractors will replace them. Right now the tools are weak, but will get better. So we're in a kind of gap right now, where the old system has optimized on a local maximum that is leading to unemployment, but the new system hasn't quite formed to take over those employees. Increased unemployment will increase the pressure for the tools to stand up.
How many people has Google Apps for Business already put out of work? I've "gigged" setting up this sort of thing for small companies with Linux, and continue to do it for my medium-sized church. However, this market has changed DRAMATICALLY within the past 5 years. My church payed the money to switch. Even the Fortune 150 I work for has now outsourced its email and messaging, from in-house Notes, to hosted Office365. That represents HUNDREDS of internal admins that are simply no longer needed in one of the largest manufacturers in the country. Even someone with experience and specialized knowledge in basic networking and services (email/file & print/DNS/DHCP) will have a hard time finding "gigs" going forward with Google Apps and Office365 in the market. It's just too easy! A kid who grew up with a smartphone is all you need to set it up.
We, as a society, are already leveraging the efforts of a relative tiny few to alleviate the work of thousands, even hundreds of thousands, just in IT services, and this grows exponentially by the year. Twenty years ago, the trade mags were raging on "cloud" everything. It took 10 years to figure out that it just meant "someone else's computer." Now it means a web portal to configure everything you need and take your money.
I'm also good at hardware (microcontroller-based machines) and business domain programming. Sure, I figure I'll have work until I'm dead, but I see what's happening with Arduinos and Raspberry Pis, and the "internet of things." I know it's crap, but when Joe Blow can buy the junk from Amazon, throw it in his home and office, and it does essentially what it's supposed to do, what's the difference to him? That trend is also going to continue to scale out so that more and more things that would have taken custom hardware and software will be recognized as a market need, and product-ized.
At each step, more and more people just aren't needed to make what everyone wants or needs, because of market dynamics like the parent alludes to: all home appliances being made by less than a handful of companies. All entertainment being copyrighted by 4 companies. All IT being controlled by about 6. All cell services in the hands of (essentially) 2. All broadband in 4. On and on it goes. All endeavors trend towards monopoly in a capitalistic system, and I don't see any way for the US government to reign that in at this point, with regulatory capture being operative phrase of the day.
I'm glad someone's hopeful about how my grandchildren are going to find their place in society. I'm holding my breath.
You suggested that the commenter might be biased against those people and feel above them. Those who oppose a living wage for everyone are the ones who tend to have this attitude because they believe that poverty is the individual's fault.
That's not an economy that looks like it has permanently automated away net 4% jobs.
That's an economy that looks like it automated away some jobs, created more new jobs, but companies can't find workers to fill them.
For a long time, I complained that the US couldn't afford such a thing, but we've been running a huge deficit for decades, and no one seems to care, so why should we let a budget hold us back from things like a living wage and free higher education and a single-payer insurance system and any other entitlement you want to tack on?