https://www.edpannualreport.edp.pt/en/key-numbers
with over 70% of renewable energy generation, the equivalent of a couple small nuclear plants in wind capacity (10GW) ... they are making hundreds of millions (sometimes billions) in profit. They are one of the largest wind turbine operators in the world and know how to evaluate an energy project. The key number is $/kWh over the whole lifetime of the project (including CAPEX, OPEX, financing, decommissioning, etc). This is called LCOE or levelized cost of energy. Over the lifetime of the machine, they make a lot of money.
For your information, other companies investing heavily (and profitably) in operating wind turbines are Iberdrola, Enel GreenPower, Dong Energy, etc (all billion $ operations)
I'm not sure where you got your information from, but there are plenty of profitable wind companies. Since a lot of them are publicly listed companies, they have an obligation to invest shareholder money responsibly to generate a profit. Additionally, many diversify their risk by being 'renewable energy' companies (e.g. solar, hydro, etc.)
These companies wouldn't be building wind turbines or operating wind farms if it wasn't profitable.
Example: Meridian Energy, 866 employees, NZD$2.37 billion revenue, $NZD185 million profit. Generates ~35% of electricity in New Zealand, with operations in Australia as well (3 wind farms)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_power_in_Australia#Major_...
If you can't get a loan to build wind farms, why was new 7.7 GW of capacity added in 2016? Also, Alstom, Invenergy? I know you are trolling but come on.
You do realize renewable energy is subsidized by RECs, who wouldn't want to add capacity when the government will pay the shortfall! They aren't profitable on their own, and barely turn a profit when you look at the full life cycle of these businesses due to the maintenance/depreciation costs which are hidden when you look at pure operating profit.
Invenergy has huge natural gas generation and seems to want to sell every wind farm they build. I don't know why you think they're an example of a profitable wind farm operator, there isn't any evidence that they make money off it. Alstom makes nothing off it's wind either.
Regarding margin, coal and nuclear also barely make money. Natural gas steam barely makes money. CT peakers make high margins when operational but they are barely operational. None of this is surprising. Electricity is a commodity business (for IPPs at least), you sort of expect razor thin margins.
"Vestas Rises to 9-Year High as Quarterly Profit Quadruples" (https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-05-05/vestas-qu...)
Their profit is tied to the volume of wind farms deployed, not the profit generated per MW of wind.
Sorry, what type of analysis do you have that refutes what everybody else is saying?
Take for example Lazard's analysis from last year:
https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-...
Not sure why the maintenance or depreciation would refute the cheapness of wind.
Maintenance and depreciation are much larger costs because the asset is the business for wind farms. Who cares how much operating profit you make, if your depreciation is higher than it?
To understand depreciation, consider a guy driving Uber making $30/hr in an $80k merc. He might be making good operating profit, but when you consider he has to replace the car in 5-10 years, spending another $80k, is it really that good?
The LCoE, takes that into account. Dispatchability has no relevance to the profits/depreciation game.
Based on these comments I have to agree with another commenter that you're just trolling.
"Baseload is kind of a historical term. It’s not really relevant to how electricity is produced today…What you need is dispatchability… and [coal and nuclear] are far slower when you compare them to a lot of the technology natural gas plants have."
This makes no sense. How good a power source something is has nothing to do with how cheap it is to produce. Otherwise horses running in circles around poles would be a dirt cheap power source and oil/solar (depending if you rank by convenience or environment) would be insanely expensive.
Would you rather be powered by coal or wind?
I should also point out that power prices vary wildly depending on where and when the energy is delivered, the time of day is hugely important.
Electricity isn't stored - it must be consumed as soon as it is created. If you are delivering it at times when nobody uses it, then the only people who can pay you will give you much lower prices. Do you see how little relevance these lower prices are? It doesn't mean that coal is much more expensive, it just means coal commands a higher price because it sells when it has no competition.
With a decent quantity of storage and good interconnects to shift power from areas of high generation to other areas, it seems possible to balance out some of the issues you're referring to.
Just as there are many people that are stalwart anti nuclear, and will say anything to fight against it without regards to honest analysis, there are a ton of anti-wind energy people.
Source? I would expect inshore windmills to have very low maintenance costs.
quotes maintenance figures between 3% and 1.5% of the initial construction cost.
A lot of power dependent things are going to start being priced like AWS spot instances.
https://www.vestas.com/~/media/vestas/investor/investor%20pd...
I'm a happy Vestas shareholder :)
Also see Dong Energy. European wind companies are doing pretty well at the moment.
Wind has low operating costs but the maintenance and depreciation are huge, so looking at it from an operating cost perspective completely undermines this.
The simple litmus test we should use is that there are no profitable wind companies. It's not very hard to run one - so if this article is accurate, where the hell are they?