News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BeOS almost made Apple a different company (2015) by CharlesW on Sunday September 03, 2017 @09:00PM (#15164900)
> Of course, if they bought Be and not NeXT […], they wouldn't have gotten Jobs back.

Yep. That's an Apple fan's Darkest Timeline, no doubt.

Having been in Apple developer relations at the time, my perspective is that the specific OS choice was irrelevant to Apple's future success.

By all accounts, BeOS would've also been a fine technology platform for Apple's future. Carbon apparently worked fine on it. And Mac OS X was far from a sure thing, for some time — if early public releases were uninspiring, early developer releases were actively demoralizing.

And yet somehow, we had to make developers believe. The only way that could work is if we believed. And Steve Jobs made us believe.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_(API)

Re:BeOS almost made Apple a different company (2015) by KernelPanic0 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @09:18PM (#15164972)
At the time I hoped that Apple would buy the Amiga company and fix AmigaOS to run Classic Mac stuff and merge both systems into PowerPC systems and then later on use Intel X86 chips.

Amiga still exists but it is very expensive, AmigaOS has evolved a lot and AROS is like an open source AmigaOS 3.X that can be ported to other platforms.

Apple can still buy out Amiga and the license to AmigaOS and make high end PowerPC workstations and servers out of them and install BSD or Linux on them. The Amiga One was better running Linux than AmigaOS, so just make an Amiga API WINE like software that runs AmigaOS apps in Linux. Then make Intel based versions to save money.

Just think Apple could use HaikuOS, MacOS, AmigaOS, AROS, Linux, etc on their Mac line using Intel chips, and contribute to their development to take on Microsoft and Windows.

Yet Apple could make a deal with Valve to port SteamOS to their older Intel Macs to make use of them for playing games on them, etc. Give them PowerMac specs as well to make a PowerPC version of SteamOS.

Re:BeOS almost made Apple a different company (2015) by eropple on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:48PM (#15165584)
> Yet Apple could make a deal with Valve to port SteamOS to their older Intel Macs to make use of them for playing games on them, etc. Give them PowerMac specs as well to make a PowerPC version of SteamOS.

I am unclear why anyone but a fragmentary, fingernail-thin minority would want this.

Re:BeOS almost made Apple a different company (2015) by jstewartmobile on Monday September 04, 2017 @12:43AM (#15165779)
I'll second that.

When I first heard about OS X, the idea of a widely-available Unix on PowerPC was very exciting. The reality of the first release was, from a performance and feature perspective, pretty underwhelming.

I'd guess the whole iTunes/iPod business put more wind in their sails in the early days.

Re:BeOS almost made Apple a different company (2015) by JKCalhoun on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:14PM (#15165456)
> By all accounts, BeOS would've also been a fine technology platform for Apple's future.

I have heard the opposite. I liked the slick look of BeOS, but have been told since that there was very little there there. I don't know either way.

Re:BeOS almost made Apple a different company (2015) by memsom on Monday September 04, 2017 @05:14AM (#15166829)
The BeOS was all smoke and mirrors. It worked really well to the end user, yes. But it was extremely lean under the hood. I think getting it to do what the baseline of Mac OS 9 did would have taken significant engineering. The issue was stuff we take for granted these days, like networking (netserver, shudder!), printing (severely lacking drivers), USB (barely worked in R5.03, slightly better if you installed the leaked BETA USB stacks)... stuff like that. It all "sort of" worked. But it still wasn't completely ready when Be Inc closed their doors. And this was even after they completely re-wrote the network stack (aka BONE.)
Re:BeOS almost made Apple a different company (2015) by badsectoracula on Monday September 04, 2017 @05:22AM (#15166858)
Isn't all that stuff about drivers? If Apple got BeOS they would only need to implement drivers for their own hardware and ignore anything else.

EDIT: See? This is why comment voting is a bad idea, it was bad on Reddit, is bad on every Reddit clone being made and of course is bad on Hacker News. What is the point? You get people downvoting comments without reason, leaving the original commenter wonder why someone would... disagree? Consider it non-constructive? Agree but dislike the tone? What? Text explains much better than a number the intent of someone and me, right now looking at a -1 number near my post, have no idea what exactly is the issue. Not to mention the fadeout that happens in downvoted comments in HN, which is extra bad (gives the impression that this comment is not important before even someone bothers to read it - thus creating a bias against it regardless of the contents).

No really, why was this comment downvoted? There are so many reasons it could have been, from misunderstandings to actual issues, that i cannot pinpoint without someone saying it.

I mean, imagine being in the same room, having a discussion about OSes, someone saying the above about BeOS and me asking the question above... if you disagreed with something i said, wouldn't you try to explain what you disagreed with? Why aren't you doing the same here?

Note that whenever i say something like that (mainly on Reddit, but a couple of times also here) people upvote the comment after the fact, i suppose to "right the wrong". But i am not interested in the comment votes as much as knowing the reasoning. After all i asked a question, my impression from what memsom said was that this was a driver issue that Apple could mostly avoid - downvoting/upvoting isn't a response, doesn't answer the question nor affect the thinking that went on making it.

Re:BeOS almost made Apple a different company (2015) by memsom on Monday September 04, 2017 @07:36AM (#15167455)
Not really. The underpinnings of the OS were fairly basic.

I was a heavy BeOS user. I owned a BeBox. I developed for the OS. There was a *lot" of stuff under the hood that made the OS very immature. I just didn't sit here listing them. Highlights:

Messaging was flaky prior to R5.1. The BMessage got copied a lot, and the Ports used for messaging could get clogged and then messages got dropped. Quite fatal.

The API was multi threaded - it was a concept that at the time a lot of developers struggled with. It could be extremely complicated to port apps.

A lot of the code was rough and some of it badly documented. So, the guy who worked on it knew it worked, but I doubt many other people did outside of their team. They cut a lot of corners. For example, OpenGL was a disaster. I was told the original dev left and no one was able to support what he left. It never really got back up to the level he had it up to prior o the focus shift.

Media Kit ended up getting a rewrite.

There was quite a bit of 3rd party code in the OS. Some was licensed. Some was GPL. Some of the GPL was a little questionably used, given the license. This is quite probably one of the reasons the OS was never open sourced.

Re:BeOS almost made Apple a different company (2015) by badsectoracula on Monday September 04, 2017 @02:38PM (#15170043)
I see, thanks :-). You say that some parts (Media Kit) got rewritten, were the issues BeOS fixed later? Some (BMessage copying, multithreaded API) sound like design issues, do you think that they could affect Haiku despite being a from scratch rewrite?
Re:BeOS almost made Apple a different company (2015) by memsom on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @04:37AM (#15173426)
The messaging system got a massive overhaul between R5.03 (R5 was code-named "Maui") and the leaked R5.1 (aka "Dano".) They did a lot of stuff to improve it. Dianne Hackbourne wrote a massive post about it on OS News[0] around the time the OS was leaked.

[0] http://www.osnews.com/comments/7057#236889

Re:BeOS almost made Apple a different company (2015) by troydavis on Monday September 04, 2017 @09:03AM (#15167935)
I suspect it was downvoted because "Isn't all that stuff about drivers?" is phrased aggressively. After the detail memsom posted, posting what amounts to a 1-sentence argument is dismissive, even if that wasn't your intent.

If your comment actually said your summary of it ("my impression was that this was a driver issue that Apple could mostly avoid") then asked "As an ex-user, what do you think?" I doubt it would have been downvoted.

OTOH, if you were actually arguing that the problems were all driver issues (rather than proposing the possibility and asking), then your theory needed a lot more substantiation.

Re:BeOS almost made Apple a different company (2015) by badsectoracula on Monday September 04, 2017 @02:40PM (#15170060)
It was indeed mainly a question, followed by my assumption (which i meant to be used as a "pivot point"/anchor for a followup, not as a declaration for what happened). I didn't meant it to sound aggressive, it was more of an informal tone - basically what i'd say to someone in front of me.
Re:BeOS almost made Apple a different company (2015) by rjsw on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @08:44AM (#15174549)
The downvotes could have been because people hear things like "Isn't all that stuff about drivers?" from PHBs every day.

The standard response isn't to start teaching Operating Systems 101.

Re:BeOS almost made Apple a different company (2015) by fanf2 on Monday September 04, 2017 @08:36AM (#15167791)
AIUI one of the main limitations was its design as a single-user OS, so it lacked memory protection - it was an essentially 1980s design, so it was not a step forward like OS/2 or WNT or OS X.
Re:BeOS almost made Apple a different company (2015) by memsom on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @07:59AM (#15174298)
BeOS was single user. I don't think it lacked memory protection any more than any other OS that was active at the time (i.e. Mac OS 9 and Windows 95/98.) Also, though it lacked file permissions and multi user security, the hooks were there to add in that type of security, they just never did.
Re:BeOS almost made Apple a different company (2015) by shawn-butler on Monday September 04, 2017 @05:20PM (#15170926)
Whomever has told you this, you should downgrade their input on technical matters in the future.
Re:BeOS almost made Apple a different company (2015) by tambourine_man on Monday September 04, 2017 @12:35AM (#15165748)
Carbon apparently worked fine on it

Really? I never knew that. Care to elaborate?

Re:BeOS almost made Apple a different company (2015) by memsom on Monday September 04, 2017 @05:08AM (#15166796)
I don't know about Carbon, but Sheepshaver started on the BeOS and one could run a full version of the MacOS up to about 8.1 along side BeOS with no real performance hit. For example, I used to run R5.03 on my PM9500/200MP and I could start up MacOS 8.1 and in a window or full screen. I used to use it to get a decent browser (NetPositive sucked badly by that point.) The MacOS was running as a process, and if it hung or crashed, you could kill it and restart it.

This was all very similar to the way Classic worked in Mac OS X, save the way the apps ran in the same desktop as the main OS.

Re:BeOS almost made Apple a different company (2015) by peatmoss on Monday September 04, 2017 @10:48AM (#15168552)
That's not quite right. Sheepshaver was approximately analogous to the classic mode where OS X booted a full version of Classic Mac OS in the background. I.e. a virtual machine like Sheepshaver

Carbon was the old Mac OS Classic APIs ported to OSX. Classic support allowed you to run old binaries. Carbon APIs allowed you to port your classic apps easily-ishly.