News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by 21 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @02:42PM (#15163061)
Funny, looking at the associated picture tells me a different story. Look at how uncrowded the chicks are and how much free space to move they have, and compare with US where they are so packed together that they can't even turn in place.

http://www.nationalgeographic.com/content/dam/magazine/right...

Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by Fnoord on Sunday September 03, 2017 @05:23PM (#15164003)
There are two types of chickens: the ones grown for their meat, and the ones grown for their eggs (I'm not aware of the English terminology on either).

There have been campaigns for both types of chicken to improve their quality of life. Here in NL they were conducted by an NGO called Wakker Dier. There's the campaign against the 'plofkip' (huge chicks who are unable to move, and are force fed) so that grocery stores quit selling these. Then for the sale of eggs (itself harmless for chickens, if unfertilized eggs, and if chickens are treated without abuse) there's a star system ranging from 1 ('kooi') [1], 2 ('scharrelei') till 3 ('vrije uitloop'). Note that this system says nothing about their diet. Now, if you'd translate 2 and 3, you'd both end up with 'free range'. This Wikipedia article on free range [2] explains the EU has strict rules on that term, while the US does not. Its worth noting that due to campaigns of Wakker Dier eggs of type 1 are almost never sold anymore directly, but they are still being widely used within products! If not, they will mention the name of type 2 and 3 ('scharrel-ei' usually or more uncommon in the case of products 'vrije uitloop ei' otherwise).

Regarding the picture you linked if that is from NL, that might very well either be accurate due to fipronil scandal [3] (millions of chickens were killed due to that hence near empty cages), or otherwise a propaganda picture.

Its very important to be critical of farmers. They're treating thousands upon thousands of animals with various degrees of treatment (from loving/caring to downright abuse), as well as affecting our soil (as in, "the inhabitants of Earth's" which also makes sense since our soil is deeply connected with the rest of Earth's ecosystem as well as literally your neighbors's soil).

[1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/a5/Eisen_ko...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free-range_eggs

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_Fipronil_eggs_contaminati...

Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by hycaria on Monday September 04, 2017 @04:02AM (#15166519)
>Its very important to be critical of farmers.

I've always felt that it's a bit ironic for people consuming animal products to be critical of breeders. Kinda passing responsibilities on them so tadaaa ! No more consumer guilt.

If you really want to reduce animal exploitation and world GHG emission, cut down your consumption instead of putting even more pressure on producers without accepting to get more money out of your pocket for products. Because generally speaking, people don't want to spend more money on food, as there is so much other essential trash to buy. To each his priorities...

Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by Fnoord on Monday September 04, 2017 @05:56AM (#15167002)
> I've always felt that it's a bit ironic for people consuming animal products to be critical of breeders. Kinda passing responsibilities on them so tadaaa ! No more consumer guilt.

Its relative, not absolute, and history teaches us we need to be critical of farmers. The recent fipronil scandal only underlines that. Our government failed as well, don't get me wrong.

If you want to reduce harm done to sentient beings (or animals with a CNS) there are many ways to achieve that. Yes, the best way would be going vegan overnight, but that is tough for an individual and quite unrealistic to achieve society-wise. Right now, we are better off reducing meat consumption (ie. via 'meatless monday' initiative) since we don't need to consume that much meat to begin with. If you eat less meat, you can use that money to eat quality meat. Eventually we can irregularly eat lab meat. So, yes, we should be critical to ourselves as well. But that's a different, and very complex discussion (I'm on a Facebook group where this is the main subject, finding the grey between the two extremes and supporting each other).

(Also as a side note there are some non-animal products which are rather bad for GHG emission, btw.)

Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by hycaria on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @04:49AM (#15173482)
All I'm saying is that it's not important to be critical of farmers but of consumers. Were there not so much demand for cheap animal products, all these problems would not be there. Almost every breeder I've met enjoys caring for its animals, but the harsh truth is that a farm is a business and most decisions are money-based, and also that time is crucially limited (can't spend 2 hours everyday for weeks caring for one single animal).

The recent fipronil scandal I'm not especially hostile to. It's like the horse meat thing, no risk for the consumer, it's simple fraud from the antiparasitics producer afaik and not latent farmer malignancy. You're way more exposed if you use antiflea products on your pets... And fipronil is really low risk for mammals overall. Oh, and of course this was in the cheap industry side of laying hens, so your wallet could vote on this beforehand.

Yet people still don't want to spend more on food. Most already shop first price, its just not a priority when you need to get a new phone and other stupid stuff. And this is the exact kind of consumer who can leisurely insist that we need to be critical of farmers. Oh, the irony. Sweep before your own door, you know.

But good on you, I hope your taking part in this Facebook group (probably known for it's high scientific and intellectual qualities, as everything that is on facebook) is comforting enough that you don't have to drastically change your consuming and behavior (and chronically, as "scandals" break out, underlines that farmers have a HUGE responsability in this), because what a shame that would be.

Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by edwinjm on Monday September 04, 2017 @03:11AM (#15166328)
Ah, so farmers never can do good. And when they do good, it's an "propaganda picture".
Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by Fnoord on Monday September 04, 2017 @05:45AM (#15166959)
I gave two plausible options each explaining the picture. I find both of those explanations more plausible than tons of empty cages. YMMV.

I never said farmers are 'evil' people. Farmers can do good (and if you read my post well you'd have seen my examples), but we live in a capitalist world where profit is an important factor, if not the most important factor. So we need others to force the farmers to keep checks and balances: consumers, NGOs, and the government. Case in point: the fipronil scandal, where ChickFriend was a cheap solution to a problem, and where the government (NVWA) failed to look into an anonymous tip in november 2016. If they did, we'd have a lot less economic damage as well as less potential health damage. Another example is as I explained how Wakker Dier's campaign stimulated the sales of free range eggs of type 2 and 3 (although first and foremost in fresh eggs; not products containing eggs), and how they managed to reduce the amount of 'plofkip' in grocery store.

Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by spiderfarmer on Monday September 04, 2017 @07:14AM (#15167337)
There was no potential health damage. The biggest scandal is how such a small issue was made this big by everyone involved. Read up on it. You can swallow 10.000.000 times as much fipronil as maximally allowed and still walk home from the hospital.

Putting the blame on the farmers is wrong too. How on earth could they have known that what the cleaning company used was illegal?

Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by mverwijs on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @02:22PM (#15185904)
Just because one solution is slightly less ghastly does not make it friendly.
Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by enraged_camel on Sunday September 03, 2017 @03:40PM (#15163405)
It seems strange to point out how well you are treating an animal when you are slaughtering it for consumption in the end. In fact that is the animal's only purpose of existence.
Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by 21 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @04:29PM (#15163708)
I think you look for purpose where there is little. What's the purpose of an animal living in the wild? Ecologists would say eat or be eaten, thrive, multiply.

From an evolutionary point of view you could say that cows, chickens, pigs (and cats, dogs, horses) are one of the most successful animals, exactly because we eat (or pet) them.

Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by spiderfarmer on Sunday September 03, 2017 @03:46PM (#15163440)
Maybe I, like all my predecessors, am not yet 'evolved' enough to give up on eating meat. In the meantime I like the fact that the animals are growing up disease free in relatively humane conditions.
Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by enraged_camel on Sunday September 03, 2017 @03:55PM (#15163485)
It's not about being evolved enough, whatever that means. Eating meat is a conscious choice. Humans can do without meat. We are omnivores, not carnivores.

I mean yes, in the grand scheme of things, treating animals well before slaughtering them is better than treating them poorly, but it misses the forest for the trees.

Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by 21 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @04:33PM (#15163736)
I would be highly surprised if in 100 years we'll still do this.

It's only a matter of time until lab-grown meat is as good and cheap as the original, and then society will turn. Eating real animals will be something like hunting is now, a tiny thing and with huge image costs.

Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by YSFEJ4SWJUVU6 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @06:08PM (#15164218)
Hunting has huge image costs where you live? Are you sure it's not just inside your specific bubble?
Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by riffraff on Monday September 04, 2017 @02:53AM (#15166253)
I'm fairly sure hunting is declining in all of the western world.

As anecdata, consider the outlawing of fox hunting in UK, declining hunting love in France[0], and a similar decline in the US[1].

The more hunting becomes unusual, the higher the number of people who will consider it in negative light compared to those who view it favourably.

[0] http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-37865215 [1] http://deerfarmer.com/wiki/hunting-decline

Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by YSFEJ4SWJUVU6 on Monday September 04, 2017 @08:12AM (#15167645)
You should've spent more time sourcing that last claim, considering it was by and large the most bold one.

Furthermore, whilst it may not be obvious in activist circles, seeing the topic was about eating animal produce, the obvious counterpart in hunting would be game animals, and not a sport (which fox hunting is, more or less). My (unsourced) guess would be that most non-vegetarians do not condemn hunting, and it would also be a somewhat hypocritical stance. Furthermore, meat consumption isn't exactly on declining in the world, but you can make your own conclusions about that.

(I'm a city dweller, and haven't hunted anything in my life. I'm not saying that to validate my opinion, but regardless I know quite a bit about the realities of hunting that probably apply to most places, and the reason it is in decline may well not be because of a shift in the moral landscape. It is a consuming hobby, but that doesn't in itself imply that all non-hunters would automatically start to disapprove it more and more.)

Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by riffraff on Monday September 04, 2017 @09:48AM (#15168184)
sorry, I should have phrased it better, I don't mean that hunting is declining because of moral reasons, I mean that as it declines and people grow more detached from it it will be considered more morally reprehensible.

It is obviously an opinion not a fact, but as an example, you can consider the attitude of people to eating animals that they ate in the past and not now (porcupine, turtle, cat, dog).

Not only it's considered disgusting, but it's often considered worse than eating other animals.

Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by spiderfarmer on Sunday September 03, 2017 @04:16PM (#15163620)
If you, by choice, never killed an animal, I absolutely respect that, but society is not ready to draw the line at the same height as you.
Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by an27 on Monday September 04, 2017 @02:58AM (#15166273)
I'm hoping to some day keep my own animals, to find out how the sausage gets made. I want to face the reality behind the sterile, bloodless chicken fillet I eat, and my apathy to animals.

Perhaps that will convince me to stop eating meat. Meanwhile I have bigger worries.

Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by bostik on Sunday September 03, 2017 @03:53PM (#15163475)
Flesh of an unstressed animal tastes better.

I can dig the exact page from On Food and Cooking for reference if needed.

Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by spiderfarmer on Sunday September 03, 2017 @04:28PM (#15163699)
Although I always believed that was true, I started having doubts when I saw "Topchef" candidates having trouble distinguishing cow and pig meat when blindfolded.

Stress should be avoided, don't get me wrong, but I don't think our tastebuds are this advanced.

Re:The Netherlands has become an agricultural giant by Paradigma11 on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @08:13AM (#15174375)
"In fact that is the animal's only purpose of existence."

From the farmers point of view.