News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:100 days of postmarketOS by appleflaxen on Sunday September 03, 2017 @07:58AM (#15160993)
this is such an awesome product, but the name "postmarketos" is too descriptive and sterile.

it's probably the least of their concerns, but i think a name / branding would be helpful.

any HN brand experts? maybe you could make a contribution (in the form of expertise/suggestions)

Re:100 days of postmarketOS by lsh on Sunday September 03, 2017 @08:24AM (#15161082)
I think it's a perfect name.
Re:100 days of postmarketOS by newscracker on Sunday September 03, 2017 @03:08PM (#15163222)
I hadn't really heard about this before, and when I skimmed the HN front page, I read the name as "postmarkOS", only to realize on opening the post that it's "postmarketOS". IMO, the name is too long and isn't catchy or understandable. As an observer on the Internet, I'll stop with these opinions. I don't have any suggestions for what it could be.
Re:100 days of postmarketOS by appleflaxen on Sunday September 03, 2017 @08:34AM (#15161114)
how come?

i think it could be better because

1. it's kind of long

2. it's sterile, devoid of emotion, and hard to link emotion to via marketing or branding

3. it's too technical - the common phone OS consumer doesn't know what postmarket means, and don't know what an OS is

4. it works against itself if it becomes wildly successful, and OEMs want to put it on the phone at the time of sale... at that point it's just "MarketOS"?

None of these are a huge deal, or detract from the overall value of the project (it's awesome!); but I can't see an argument for keeping it. what makes it perfect, in your eyes?

And i'm not a brand expert; i would love to see points by someone who knows a lot more about marketing and branding.

Re:100 days of postmarketOS by khedoros1 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @04:51PM (#15163836)
I don't think it's "perfect", but I think it's named better than most projects are.

1. There's a shorthand "pmOS". "postmarketOS" is at least easy to Google (PMOS has too many meanings).

2. It's descriptive and tells me more about what it is than most names do. Maybe they could rebrand for wider appeal later.

3. The common phone consumer wouldn't pay more attention if it had a flashier name, either. They'll buy a phone based on rumor and what their friends have, and they certainly aren't going to look at replacing the OS with something new.

4. I imagine that the company might fork the repo and rename it whatever they want, in that case. "Mobilios\", then a tiny text at the bottom "powered by postmarketOS".

I'm not a branding expert either, but I know that it pisses me off when there are 3 layers of branding and marketing before I can get to what the product actually is*.

Re:100 days of postmarketOS by 482794793792894 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @01:30PM (#15162647)
I also find the name good as it is. When I first heard of it, I read up on it only because it had that weird name. If the name was yet another generic OS name, I would have just scrolled on, thinking that it's just yet another OS.

I agree that it's not that well-suited for outside of the geek community, but I doubt we're anywhere close to that. If it gets picked up by a manufacturer, they'll just as well market it to geeks. You're not getting around that, unless Android and iOS disappear from the face of the planet.

Re:100 days of postmarketOS by ollieparanoid on Sunday September 03, 2017 @09:30AM (#15161321)
Obviously we will name it postpostmarketOS then ;)
Re:100 days of postmarketOS by Fnoord on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @08:16AM (#15182995)
The name is good to attract developers, to gain traction, which is the current goal. Any users are a bonus (beta testers), and with a name like this you may gain the type of user who's OK with tinkering.

As someone who ran Maemo (and its successors in past) I am happy to see my old N900 would gain new life. However, running Linux terminal apps on a phone isn't very useful. They need to be ported to get gesture support etc as normal applications are made for hardware keyboard and hardware mouse as HIDs. Phones lack these (tho N900 does have a hardware keyboard, the other input device is resistive screen + stylus or finger).

Re:100 days of postmarketOS by dahoramanodoceu on Monday September 04, 2017 @09:28PM (#15171900)
I've done some thinking and preliminary work about brand identity and the psychology of use. Find me on the matrix channel, @AndrewMcSwain.
Re:100 days of postmarketOS by na85 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:27AM (#15161902)
What's the alternative? A vaguely exotic-sounding name that doesn't mean anything to anyone, like Haskell?

Names should be descriptive.

Re:100 days of postmarketOS by mintplant on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:46PM (#15162411)
> like Haskell

Haskell is named after the mathematician Haskell Curry. The concept of "currying" functions is essential to the language, and is named for the same person.

Re:100 days of postmarketOS by na85 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @02:38PM (#15163043)
Whoops. Bad example, I guess.
Re:100 days of postmarketOS by abrowne on Sunday September 03, 2017 @06:02PM (#15164192)
What about ReOS, as in reuse and recycle, which fits the mission (and logo)?
Re:100 days of postmarketOS by bubblethink on Sunday September 03, 2017 @07:07PM (#15164495)
Short sighted. What if it becomes big and you want to ship a new devices with this OS ? It's not reuse or recycle then. Not to mention, both of those words are uninviting to anyone looking to pick this up.
Re:100 days of postmarketOS by abrowne on Sunday September 03, 2017 @07:56PM (#15164673)
Fair enough, but just to be clear, I wasn't suggesting using the words 'reuse' or 'recycle', only to be inspired by them to use the 're-' prefix.

The current logo certainly seems inspired by common recycling icons.

At the same time your first point seems to me to apply to the current name.

Re:100 days of postmarketOS by maxerickson on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:51AM (#15161700)
How about a pithy take on postmarketOS, something like pOS or PMS?
Re:100 days of postmarketOS by mintplant on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:48PM (#15162434)
> PMS

Sure, if you want to annoy potential female contributors for no good reason.

Re:100 days of postmarketOS by yuvadam on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:03AM (#15161765)
pmOS is the semi-official shorthand