* Detaining this individual indefinitely without charge.
* Charge based on limited anecdotal evidence.
* Release without charge.
Can you think of other suggestions? Which of the available options do you think is best? Best being a balance between the rights of the individual and the laws of the state.
What should happen in this case IMO is that they should charge him with whatever they have right this moment, and if it fails, release him. Infinite detaining of individuals should be impossible, no matter what. This is dangerous.
If all it takes to be a criminal that can't be charged for their online behaviour is to encrypt a hard drive, what ramifications does that have for our legal system?
Encryption, once you lose the key, effectively destroys data. If you wanna charge someone with destruction of evidence, then charge that.
Refusing to comply is not a valid reason to lock someone up forever. You can charge him with contempt to court if you need to.