That's why I wrote "limited version of". Rust's "associated constants" are a subset of C++'s class variables feature. Namely you can only have variables qualified "const" i.e. constants.
>Rust also doesn't have classes in any recognizable sense
What? If you have instantiatable abstract data types with associated methods you have a "class". Calling them "structs" does not change that. There are classes defined with "struct" in C++ and D too.
Oh and calling an interface a "trait" does not change its fundamental nature either.
Rust clearly is an OOP language.
In any case, this point is been argued at length for every language, including Rust.
That is, I think the essence of "OOP", OOP-as-used, not any theoretical OOP, is function name resolution depending on type. That and syntax. So first, you write x.tree_foo() instead of tree_foo(x) which is purely syntactic. And then you shorten x.tree_foo() to x.foo(), because x is a tree, which is a great semantic help.
According to this definition, Haskell and C are not "OOP", which matches common understanding.
[obj doStuff: foo withBar: bar]
gets desugared into objc_msgSend(obj, NSSelectorFromString(@“doStuff:withBar:”), foo, bar)So if I just take C's structs and add the ability to associate structs with functions using a "struct.function" notation, I now have classes? If so, a class isn't a very powerful concept, is it?
Here's an easy way to see the difference between traits and interfaces, and simultaneously see why some people find OOP completely inadequate for their purposes.
Imagine you're implementing several different types that all need to be able to be added. You've got integers, floats, mathematical vectors, and possibly other types. All of them should support an `add` method. But you should only be able add objects of the same type: an integer to an integer, a float to a float, and a vector to a vector. This incredibly simple idea, to my mind almost the simplest thing a person might want to do with a type system, cannot be expressed in most OOP languages using an interface with an `add` method.
But it can easily be expressed using traits (or using Haskell's type classes).
And this is why I never understood why anyone bothers with OOP.
What you're talking about has nothing to do with neither.
Any language that has generics can have self types or whatever you want to call them. It's a matter of whether the language has a strong static typesystem and most FP-style languages have these and a minority of OOP-style languages has them too.
The reason why I use C++ has nothing to do with a preference for OOP. It's because all the widely used alternatives have terrible performance.
I hate dealing with C++ projects. I hate dealing with memory leaks and segfaults. But that doesn't stop me from creating more of them and working on existing ones.
All of that because the resulting memory footprint and performance are worth it.
Traits just provide a single level of indirection and if you want to do anything more complex you'll need to use composition to achieve it.
let a = Foo; Foo::bar(&a); // if bar takes &self
Plus, there is no concept of inheritance. I don't see how that meets any definition of OOP unless you make the definition so weak as to be meaningless.
Traits are a form of ad hoc polymorphism and behave closer to Haskell's typeclasses than they do to interfaces and subtype polymorphism.
Part of the difficulty here is nailing down what "class" even means, exactly. Rust doesn't fit into either of the three major schools of OOP, which I personally nickname the "smalltalk school", the "java school", or the "javascript school".
All kidding aside, I think for any regular working day programmer Rust is obviously OOP. The debates are really just which parts of which favorite school of OOP you think Rust is inspired by.
But what really matters is that Rust gives you:
* Encapsulation
* Polymorphism.
* And Code Reuse.
Which are the only three things anyone who reaches for OOP is really looking for anyway. As fun as the PL theory discussions are. (Kind of a Hobby for me at least) I think those are the bits that actually matter to the people who truly need an answer to the question "Is Rust OOP or not?"
I doubt I'm the only one whose high school and college exposure to OOP was to model "Dog is-a Mammal, Cow is-a Mammal, Mammal is-a Animal", and if a newcomer to Rust tries to do the same as their "hello world" then they're going to be greatly frustrated. Again, this isn't to say that the phrase "Rust is OOP" is necessarily incorrect, only that it's going to backfire if we going around shouting it, due to misaligned expectations.
I also think that the concept of "class" suffers from a great amount of un-orthogonality. A class packages together a memory representation, an encapsulation boundary, an interface that defines functionality and a unit of type parametrisation. I find the way how Rust separates modules as the unit of encapsulation, traits as the unit of functionality and structs as the units of memory representation, very elegant.
Now if one could type-parametrise modules...
The Simula, Smalltalk, Lisp, SELF or BETA model?
Yes, OOP is broad, just like FP also is.
Ha! But yeah, if you're going to claim Rust is OOP, I would argue that makes the most sense.
> what really matters is that Rust gives you:
Right, this is the "Java School" definition. However, when people talk about OOP this way, when they say "polymorphism", they mean "subtype polymorphism" not "parametric polymorphism." Take https://docs.oracle.com/javase/tutorial/java/IandI/polymorph... as an example. Rust's only sub-typing is for lifetimes.
> As fun as the PL theory discussions are.
I definitely agree that in some senses, this is academic. But at the same time, practitioners can be mis-led by using terms in a different way than they're used to. This is sort of the argument I'm making above; since many practitioners see "polymorphism" as being equal to "subtype polymorphism", calling other types of polymorphism "polymorphism" is a more academic, less user-focused distinction.
I think the working programmer doesn't know or care though. They care about whether you can reuse code in some way. And whether you can substitute multiple implementations of an object act as one particular type.
The specifics of how you reach either of those goals is all they want to know and the pedantry that us language geeks love to engage in just blows right past them.
Anyway, thanks for a good discussion!
I have to come to HN for that instead.
These are three incredibly vague terms that pretty much every programming language can be said to provide. I can't understand how you think OOP is defined by this.
Do you think Haskell programmers are unable to reuse code? That they don't have any form of polymorphism? That they can't hide implementation details of functions, data structures and modules?
This is the kind of argument that convinces me that OOP is completely bunk. Its adherents can't even explain what it is!
I do not want to defend OOP, but I would like to add that object-orientated languages are often to be expected to support these 3 things (encapsulation, inheritance and polymorphism) - at least many sources list these properties as must-have to be considered object-orientated.
> This is the kind of argument that convinces me that OOP is completely bunk.
Agreed. E.g. functional programming has a sound foundation (λ-calculus), but in object-oriented land if often sounds a little bit hand-wavy.
But most working programmers don't care about the debate at all in my experience. When they say they are looking for an object oriented language what they are really saying is:
I am looking for a language that has a syntax where you
can declare an object and call methods on that object
usually with a dot but sometimes with an ->.
They don't actually care about much more than that most of the time.But why? That's such a weird thing to look for. Clearly there's a reason they think they want "objects", but what is it? And why the focus on what syntax these objects have?
In Haskell you have to deal with the possibility of record types sharing the same field names.
Those are 3 characteristics of modularity, not object or class-specific in any meaningful sense. Rust isn't really a classic object-oriented language, but it is a modular language with object-like abstractions.
JavaScript code bases use a lot of classes, but while JavaScript supports inheritance, it's use isn't particularly idiomatic. What is idiomatic is duck typing (checking for the presence of method or property on an object). This is basically the same as using traits, except without compile time correctness guarantee. You even have things like `Symbol.iterator`[0], which allow an arbitrary object to work with a `for..of` loop, exactly like `impl Iterator` in Rust.
https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/JavaScript/Refe...
let mut window: PistonWindow = WindowSettings::new(
"piston: hello_world",
[200, 200]
)
.exit_on_esc(true)
.opengl(OpenGL::V2_1)
.build()
.unwrap();
If you wrote that in C++ or Java or Python or.. it would /could look fundamentally the same. You create a window object and then call a bunch of its methods (mutating its state). That's OOP.I think the Rust people just desperately try to disassociate themselves from the OOP label because OOP is not hip anymore. "So 90s" and all that.
I think that's childish. If you use a broad definition of OOP according to which C++, Smalltalk, Java, and Python are all OOP languages said definition certainly covers Rust too.
To be fair, even the C++ crowd doesn't like to use the term OOP anymore and instead say things like "generic programming".. but at the end of the day they too are instantiating classes.
Yeah, the usage does, but the definition does not, the implementation does not, and the features are very different.
For example, "new" is just a convention here, not an actual constructor, as Rust does not have constructors.
> You create a window object and then call a bunch of its methods (mutating its state). That's OOP.
It depends on what you mean by "object". If structs are objects, then OOP boils down to only "you can use x.y() instead of y(x)", which I don't think is a good way to think about programming languages or their features. YMMV, of course.
> I think the Rust people just desperately
I can assure you, that's not the case for me at least; I love OOP languages enough to have both Ruby and Perl logos tattoo'd onto my body.
I don't like saying Rust is OOP because of said definitions elsewhere in the thread, as well as people struggling to map their OOP patterns over. If they hear "Rust is OOP", they expect to be able to do OOP-like things, and when they can't, that's a big frustration. Enough so that we had to add that book chapter.
It's uncontroversial to state that Rust has methods, which are usually associated with OOP. It's also uncontroversial to state that Rust is utterly incapable of defining inheritance hierarchies, which are also usually associated with OOP. If we're going to argue about it, we might as well try to agree on terms that will let us say things that are meaningful.
Declaring class inheritance to be the defining feature of OOP just because it was fundamental to 1990s Java courses makes about as much sense as to say extreme late-binding is a fundamental aspect of OOP, like Alan Kay does, and thus neither Java nor C++ are OOP languages. Yippee! Suddenly they are no longer boring, old OOP anymore either! Thanks Alan!
You mention FP being a broad category. Indeed it is. Haskell is all about expressive static types, meanwhile Erlang couldn't care less about types. Yet I dare to argue that this broad definition is not "useless" because both Erlang and Haskell default to immutable data and pure functions, and that defines FP more than anything.
Practically meaning that Erlang and Haskell tend to be massively closer to each other than they are to imperative languages.
The same is the case here. Rust is massively closer to C++ than to Haskell. Mutable ADTs+methods+interfaces, as opposed to free functions and (immutable) "raw" data defines the code style way more than questions like subtype vs. parametic polymorphism
If you think that the fact that your dog does not "inherit" from mammal but instead has the mammal "trait", means you are doing a fundamentally different kind of programming, you are wrong. Such differences are of lesser importance in practice.
No argument there. :)
> Yet I dare to argue that this broad definition is not "useless" because both Erlang and Haskell default to immutable data and pure functions, and that defines FP more than anything.
I think this illustrates what I'm trying to get at: if one's task is to further the tenets of functional programming, then going around espousing "functional programming" as a general concept is less direct than just cutting to the chase and evangelizing for immutability and/or purity directly, especially when one considers that e.g. Common Lisp is neither immutable nor pure, but will be what plenty of people's minds jump to when they think of FP.
No, it's mostly driven by the differing semantics despite happening to have similar syntax. Syntax is a surface polish that people focus on a lot, but doesn't drive the core language behaviour.
Personally I like Rust's better. It feels more like a "better C with generics" than C++ is.
At an introductory level, like this announcement, we teach this system by analogy to OO, but its not OO in its core and snide comments like this only reveal the limits of your knowledge.
That's correct, though they have been added to the C++20 draft: http://www.open-std.org/jtc1/sc22/wg21/docs/papers/2017/p073...
Also, to be a little snide:
"Modules" = modules
"Concepts" = traits
C++ keeps approaching Rust's feature set!
It's normal and even expected that languages in a similar space will either draw inspiration from each other or converge on similar solutions.
Guess I didn't go far enough :)
If there's one thing we C++ programmers can agree on, it's that having tons of features makes C++ a pleasure to work with... ?
Then I got a full time job working with a large C++ codebase. Since then I've been dealing with:
- uninitialized variables / members
- NULL checks
- buffer overflows, especially with C-strings
- (mutable) global variables
- exception safety
All these things don't exist in (safe) Rust. I'm sold.
Foot note: the only thing I'm really missing in Rust right now is specialization in generics, which is being worked on here: https://github.com/rust-lang/rust/issues/31844.
So C++ is a wonderful language - in a world that only exists in the creators' heads, or on committee tables, or on brand-new, post C++03 codebases. Basically - nowhere.
- Object Pascal (in the TP days)
- Modula-3
- Oberon, Oberon-2, Active Oberon, Oberon-07
- Component Pascal
You need to resort to plain functions/procedures instead.
Rust makes it really difficult to share mutable data. But once you do that, such as by smuggling a pointer _through_ an unsafe block, all bets are off, even for code outside an unsafe block.
Also, as with Java there will always be bugs in the compiler and runtime. Rust programs were susceptible to StackClash just as much as C applications.
No matter what language you use, if you minimize shared mutable data you'll minimize thread-safety issues.
That proof might be parameterised by a proof that some external FFI function was safe, which you might not be able to actually prove and have to assume, but then you would have your assumptions well-documented.
As it is, you have to justify the safety of your unsafe blocks to other programmers using comments, which kind of sucks.
Still better than every other fast language in this area though so I can't complain much.
"Associated constants" = limited version of class variables
Rust keeps approaching C++'s feature set..
I am amazed that the above wasn't in Rust to begin with, though. Can't think of any other languages which has classes but no class methods/variables.