Re:The Accidental Elitist: Academia is too important to be l...
by dredmorbius on Thursday August 31, 2017 @12:34PM
(#15141488)
The humanities, or rather, the Liberal Arts from which they originate, are not about predictive power as such.
Rather, they're about information processing, and sets of useful priors.
The fundaments of the seven Liberal Arts are the trivium and the quadrivium. (Trivium => trivial, by the way.)
The three elemnts of the trivium are grammar, logic, and rhetoric. Or, to put that in an information-technology / information-theoretic frame: input, processing, and output.
The four elements of the quadrivium are arithmetic, trigonometry, music, and astronomy (or astrology). Or: quantity, quantity in space, quantity in time, and quantity in space and time. Possibly an early development of systems dynamics.
I'm not arguing that present humanities have strayed far from these roots, or that they're not exceptionally incenstuous and inward-focused. They have and they are.
But your critique that they are not of themselves predictive has been launched at the wrong target. You misunderstand the domain. (Don't feel bad, many do, and I've only recently realised the error myself.)
Rather, they're about information processing, and sets of useful priors.
The fundaments of the seven Liberal Arts are the trivium and the quadrivium. (Trivium => trivial, by the way.)
The three elemnts of the trivium are grammar, logic, and rhetoric. Or, to put that in an information-technology / information-theoretic frame: input, processing, and output.
The four elements of the quadrivium are arithmetic, trigonometry, music, and astronomy (or astrology). Or: quantity, quantity in space, quantity in time, and quantity in space and time. Possibly an early development of systems dynamics.
I'm not arguing that present humanities have strayed far from these roots, or that they're not exceptionally incenstuous and inward-focused. They have and they are.
But your critique that they are not of themselves predictive has been launched at the wrong target. You misunderstand the domain. (Don't feel bad, many do, and I've only recently realised the error myself.)
More: https://redd.it/6x7u6a