I mentioned to an academic computer scientist that I worked with blockchains. He immediately asked "So these blockchains, how do they do consensus? Isn't it some kind of majority vote?" I said "Well, kind of, in combination with economic incentives to follow the longest chain." He just said "Well, come on! That's the whole problem! That's not a solution!" or something like that. Not impressed at all!
Bitcoin does not meet the requirements identified by the academic community for a usable digital currency. On the other hand, it works (while nothing that came out of academia in this area ever has). Infer from that what you will.
It would be nice if science had a term for its equivalent of "outsider art."
The repeated claim that Bitcoin came up with a totally new and unknown way of solving the problem always irks me.
Everyone keeping a complete history of all actions is, like, consensus 101.
Research is based around not having to do that.
That wasn't the key insight -- it was the idea that you could get a working solution under the assumption that 50%+1 of the hashing power is from honest nodes as long as those nodes agreed to coordinate on the ledger with the most proven work invested in it.
Also, Bitcoin is kind of a "dirty" solution to the consensus problem; if all the academics were looking for an elegant solution it's not surprising that they didn't discover it.