Re:24/192 Music Downloads Are Very Silly Indeed (2012)
by agency on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @07:01PM
(#15128327)
With regards to the first part of your question - as long as the signal is bandlimited the Nyquist-Shannon theorem applies. If all of the waves are under 20kHz, regardless of how they're interfering with each other, the signal can be reconstructed perfectly with a 40kHz sample rate.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:24/192 Music Downloads Are Very Silly Indeed (2012)
by umaxumax on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @09:54AM
(#15132136)
Incorrect. Nyquist-Shannon theorem does not guarantee phase! It only guarantees frequency reproduction. This paper illustrates the issue succinctly: http://www.wescottdesign.com/articles/Sampling/sampling.pdf
Re:24/192 Music Downloads Are Very Silly Indeed (2012)
by kuschku on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @04:06AM
(#15130476)
Assuming that you have a perfect DAC (which you don’t), with perfect analog brickwall filters (which you don’t), with no compressed audio (which isn’t the case).
With a perfect DAC, and perfect filters, and expensive headphones, there is no difference between 16bit/44.1kHz WAV and 24bit/192kHz WAV (until you add an EQ, then there is).
With a usual home DAC, and its filters, and at best $100 headphones, there is a major difference between 16/44.1 AAC and 24/192 AAC.
(And guess what the article attacked? The decision of Apple to sell lossy files in 24/192 for home usage. The discussion was never about lossless files, or professional usage)