With a perfect DAC, and perfect filters, and expensive headphones, there is no difference between 16bit/44.1kHz WAV and 24bit/192kHz WAV (until you add an EQ, then there is).
With a usual home DAC, and its filters, and at best $100 headphones, there is a major difference between 16/44.1 AAC and 24/192 AAC.
(And guess what the article attacked? The decision of Apple to sell lossy files in 24/192 for home usage. The discussion was never about lossless files, or professional usage)
Sound is linear, so yes. Any signal can be represented correctly as a sum of frequencies.
> wouldn't higher bit depth increase the fidelity in the range the audio does fill?
When you do the maths quantisation turns into the original sound + quantization noise. The bit range determines the noise (dither helps here). So it's a question of whether the noise is loud enough to hear. There are samples on the internet you can try to determine yourself at which stage you can notice the noise. It's shocking how few bits are actually required.
For a sloppy recording or repeated processing the quantisation noise goes up, so more bits are required.
> It is also worth mentioning that increasing the bit depth of the audio representation from 16 to 24 bits does not increase the perceptible resolution or 'fineness' of the audio. It only increases the dynamic range, the range between the softest possible and the loudest possible sound, by lowering the noise floor. However, a 16-bit noise floor is already below what we can hear.
But I don't understand, why is this? Is the step in volume between two values fixed regardless of the bit depth? If so, why?
You can think of it as in the sampling rate provides a mathimatical solution to the waveform - it's simply 100% accurate all the time. The bit depth adds extra "buckets" to divide the volumes into . If you have 2 bits, you then have volume levels 0, 1, 2, 3.
Say I've got an 18kHz wave and a 9kHz wave and the 9kHz wave is ever so slightly out of phase. Then imagine there are 10 different waves under 20kHz all interfering with each other in different wages.
Is it still possible to reproduce everything accurately?
And on bit-depth and dynamic range: Given that much audio doesn't use the full range available to it, wouldn't higher bit depth increase the fidelity in the range the audio does fill? The article talks about the bit depth and range only in terms of the maximum volume but what about fidelity? What's the minimum difference in volume the human ear can hear?