News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google to Comply with EU Search Demands to Avoid More Fines by ars on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @05:18PM (#15127680)
It's headline news when the law is not only ridiculous, but protectionist, and inconsistently followed.

It's pretty obvious that the EU is only doing this because Google is a US company.

I am quite sure that google considered simply pulling entirely out of Europe. It wouldn't affect them as much as you think - it's the internet, you can run a website from anywhere.

And it's not like the EU would prevent their citizens from buying ads from Google, so their revenues would not be affected all that much. Their EU sales force could be through a third party (so that Google would not have any assets in the EU).

All that Google would lose is EU employees.

The bare fact this this plan I am outlining is even worth considering rather than bow to the EU demands tells you a lot.

Re:Google to Comply with EU Search Demands to Avoid More Fines by ionised on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @05:38AM (#15130823)
> It's pretty obvious that the EU is only doing this because Google is a US company.

It's pretty obvious that Americans are complaining because Google is a US company and they want it to succeed even at the cost of unethical or illegal behaviour as determined by foreign jurisdictions, and that they deem their own laws to be exceptional and superior to those of all other nations.

See? I can make totally unsubstantiated claims too.

The point being all your comment does is serve to distract from the actual issues in question by turning the issue into a tribal us-versus-them conflict. It's tedious and unproductive.

I'd wager if the US's own regulatory agencies were doing their jobs then each of the 'big four/five' tech companies would have faced penalties in the past on various issues.

They haven't because of that thing you mentioned, protectionism.

Re:Google to Comply with EU Search Demands to Avoid More Fines by cisanti on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @06:56PM (#15128301)
What are you on? EU is the biggest market when it comes to prosperity / population.

Some people need to drink less the libertarian kool-aid, Google is still recovering from missing out China and will do anything do anything eventually to satisfy EU

Your comment lacks anything with relationship with real life.

Re:Google to Comply with EU Search Demands to Avoid More Fines by lagadu on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @03:13AM (#15130231)
If it was deemed illegal, they could prevent any payments to Google from European banks, effectively barring Google from the most affluent single market in the world and we're ignoring how companies making business with other markets aren't automatically exempt from things like VAT, which they are under the current system. Google shareholders would tear down everyone even marginally involved with that decision.
Re:Google to Comply with EU Search Demands to Avoid More Fines by Oletros on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @05:35PM (#15127785)
> It's pretty obvious that the EU is only doing this because Google is a US company.

If it is obvious, it will be easy to explain the reasons for it

> I am quite sure that google considered simply pulling entirely out of Europe. It wouldn't affect them as much as you think - it's the internet, you can run a website from anywhere.

I'm quite sure that Google is glad to not have people like you as CEO.

> And it's not like the EU would prevent their citizens from buying ads from Google

Tell me how a company like Google, or Apple or Microsoft can do business with the EU without being there. And please, no't give nonsensical reasons like internet is everywhere, that just shows that you don't know much about economy.

Re:Google to Comply with EU Search Demands to Avoid More Fines by thejynxed on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @10:21AM (#15132325)
They did it quite easily prior to when certain EU nations decided to give them massive tax breaks (up to and including zero tax) if they located offices and production facilities in their nations, so your last point is moot. Until then, they didn't have offices in the EU because there was no point in sinking that kind of money into countries that would just tax you to death for little in return.
Re:Google to Comply with EU Search Demands to Avoid More Fines by Oletros on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @03:45PM (#15135314)
Please, can you give any information of any of those companies working for EU customers without having any presence in the EU?