I know what you say is popular in certain political circles, but it's a false idea about government. Worse, it's a cynical meme that corrupts people into making government less effective, by both stopping people from trying to hold government to account, and not trying to change the rules that governments enforce.
The best way to make your idea of government true is to stand idly by and do nothing.
http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2006-05-21/features/06052...
(Though Teddy Roosevelt certainly pissed off monied interests when he felt they were acting immorally)
For example, the police, the IRS, DHS etc etc. (and hence the state) WILL be helped in their jobs by increasing surveillance, and so will always be trying to increase its scope.
Whether it's _worth_ the loss of privacy is of course a valid debate.
It certainly seems like the positive statement "government is not motivated to protect individual privacy and will not effectively do so" is well-supported by current experience.
A bit meta but I wish more up/downvoters on HN could tell the difference between normative and descriptive speech.
So, maybe theoretically we can influence, but understanding the nature of what a self-interested, pragmatic government beaurocrat values is incredibly important.
I think the parent comment and idea behind it needs to be explored further. Maybe there is a solution, but it will perhaps require an entirely new type of government. Democracies, as we know them, don't seem capable of solving this problem.
Democracy is only the problem insofar as we (here in the US) do not have one, we just pretend we do. Democracy and Republic both mean a government by the public. Voting once a year, donating money, and writing stuff on the net are utterly inadequate for that end.
Public government needs educated and involved citizenry. It means putting in quite a bit of time.
Remove the word "populist" and you've just described most politicians ;-)
Would be far more representative of the people than current way and less susceptible to populism.
People often think I'm joking when I propose this but I haven't heard a good argument against it yet.
1) By taking the average, you are risking compounding educational decreases in the populace.
Bad public education policy is enacted, chosen politicians become less educated, worse public policy is enacted, etc etc.
2) By using less experienced politians, you lessen the efficiency of the entire political process.
3) By not having the possibility of re-election, you remove any responsibility of the elected after they're elected.
2) This is the reason to only replace 25% if the parliament per year so that not all experience is lost. It gives more power to non-elected public officials which can be good or bad.
3) By removing reelection you also remove career politicians and reduce corruption. No need for campaign contributions or campaigning promises. Also, the drafted people would go back to their social circles to be judged by their peers after ended term of office where they would have to own their decisions.
2) You still have a maximum 4 year experience level. As someone who grew up in a college town, I'd estimate having to explain the basics to 1/4 of the elected body every year would require significant resources.
Additionally, handled incorrectly, you imperil the stability of the legislature. Imagine if every year were Trump election year: Mr. John and Ms. Jane Doe go to Washington intent on toppling the system as it stands because they're unhappy with the way things are.
3) Fair, but the social censure of being judged is a few orders of magnitude smaller than the power these people would wield while in office. If you think politicians are corrupt now, imagine if Exxon offered $x million in bribes to an average person off the street to approve oil drilling in wilderness refuges.
There is a lot wrong with the wealthy monopolizing political power, but at least it semi-insulates them against outright financial persuasion.
Jurors are asked to do a couple fairly common tasks that most people do frequently throughout their lives: (1) listen to different sides of a story and decide which side to believe, and (2) decide the motives for a person's acts.
A legislator is asked to judge complex policy questions often requiring extensive specialized knowledge. The arguments for and against are often long and complex. It's not a job you can expect to take some random adult off the street for and have them do it competently.
Do current law makers have to pass some kind of knowledge based test to be allowed to make the decisions?
There are more than "politician corrupted by power" stories, there are also many politician does a good thing and fades into the background, or politician leads well for a long time stories too. These are less exciting and usually receive far less press, because they are remarkable in their unremarkable outcomes.
There are government agencies whose business is to collect information. The people working for these agencies will do so _to the extent that they are allowed to_, because that is what they perceive their mission to be. Other people's job is to set limits, and they will set exactly the limits they think they have a mandate to set. They get their sense of that mandate from many possible sources, but in a republic one of the most important sources is public opinion.
Which is where you get to the real kernel of the issue: In the USA, surveys indicate that most Americans remain in favor of large scale state surveillance.
I read some of ancestors' comments and wonder why they always seem willfully blind to it. Is there a still small voice in them that says, "A little waste is to be expected" or "WE are in control of it, I am certain"? Utopian dreamers and busybodies, ugh.
Likewise, once these tools are used to compromise their privacy, they will demand better safeguards.
Supreme court (and the people) prevailed, Privacy is now a fundamental right.
Governments are likely to control food pathogens and airline risks because they need living, productive, happy voters.
But governments have also a fundamental distrust for all individuals and therefore want as much surveillance as possible. By allowing big companies to collect that, they have access as well.
Therefore I think governments are not motivated to improve privacy at all. On the contrary.