News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by asdflkj on Monday March 31, 2008 @12:14PM (#151153)
This is wrong, but being a civil argument, at least there are concrete things to refute.

One problem with direct observation is that it's hard to get a representative sample. It can be done, but you have to make it a deliberate project and put some time and thought into it, rather than just stumbling on a bunch of programmers in a café.

False dichotomy. PG's sample is neither a deliberate project, nor the people in the cafe. It's the programmers he has known and observed over his life. There's no reason to doubt representativeness of his sample.

a case where an ad hominem argument is relevant and valid.

There's never a case where ad hominem is valid. If it's valid, it's not ad hominem, by definition. A logical fallacy can't be valid. But I'm nitpicking here. His point is:

The fact that this observation confirms his preexisting belief in the worthiness of startups makes it less credible than if the same observation were made by someone who had no particular interest in startups.

Occam's Razor suggests that PG works with startups because he thinks they're better, not that he thinks they're better because he works with them. He is rich enough to work on whatever he wants.

A creature that's perpetually dissatisfied, always striving for advantage, wins out over a creature that's happy.

Then why does happiness exist? Why hasn't it been eradicated millions of years ago? Answer: because it serves a purpose. It's how evolution tells the organism, "keep doing what you're doing". Not everything that mentions nature is an appeal to nature.

Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by sofal on Monday March 31, 2008 @05:41PM (#151366)
>There's no reason to doubt representativeness of his sample.

So the sample of programmers that he has known and observed over his life is unquestionably representative?

>There's never a case where ad hominem is valid.

Are you saying that biases and potential biases of people have absolutely no relevance in any "valid" discussion, even in response to subjective observations about why people act the way they do?

>Occam's Razor suggests that PG works with startups because he thinks they're better, not that he thinks they're better because he works with them. He is rich enough to work on whatever he wants.

Are you suggesting that this makes PG completely free from bias?

>It's how evolution tells the organism, "keep doing what you're doing".

So happiness is just a reward we get from pursuing those things that will result in the propagation of our genes?

>Not everything that mentions nature is an appeal to nature.

Sure, but that's irrelevant. Gabe says PG's essay is an appeal to nature and backs it up. If you disagree, then please do the same.

Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by Hexstream on Tuesday April 01, 2008 @12:01AM (#151712)
">There's no reason to doubt representativeness of his sample.

So the sample of programmers that he has known and observed over his life is unquestionably representative?"

there's no reason to doubt != it is unquestionable that

Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by asdflkj on Tuesday April 01, 2008 @03:32AM (#151840)
The answer to all of your questions is "No, but that's irrelevant". If you had made your points in the form of statements and not questions, you'd see that they don't actually contradict what I said. As one poster has pointed out, there's no reason to doubt != it is unquestionable that. Likewise, ad hominem can never be valid != biases are never relevant; these accusations of bias are unfounded != PG is completely free from bias; happiness serves an evolutionary purpose != happiness is just a reward (whatever that means).

As for the last one, I did back it up. I refuted a central premise of the author, that happiness is evolutionarily useless.

Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by logjam on Monday March 31, 2008 @06:24PM (#151420)
> Are you saying that biases and potential biases of people have absolutely no relevance in any "valid" discussion, even in response to subjective observations about why people act the way they do?

They have absolutely NO relevance to the argument. Ad hominem is an error in logic. Bias has nothing to do with the argument. It is the argument we refute, not the person. Unfortunately, you

It is utterly amazing to me people still argue about these errors in logic. One can only assume it is defensiveness.

You might want to look up "straw man" as well. It's another logical fallacy, and you're using it.

Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by hobbs on Monday March 31, 2008 @12:41PM (#151193)
Evolution is not quite as easy as everyone assumes it is. I don't know much about it myself, but I do know enough to know that I can't appeal to it to make arguments about human nature.

Evolution, at its core, strives for only one thing: propagation of the species. Taken to this level, it's a wonder that everyone isn't spending their time either at drunken orgies, or fighting each other to get into the drunken orgies. Somehow, "civilization", "culture", and "society" have guided human development away from that model - and I don't presume to know how it happened.

Taken to the extreme, why have we even developed arms, legs, eyes, ears, and minds? Simple bacterial reproduction does just fine. In fact, there is so much bacteria in our gut and sinuses that 90% of the DNA molecules in our bodies are foreign. One begins to wonder, then, whose purpose our human bodies really serve.

Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by euccastro on Monday March 31, 2008 @07:43PM (#151514)
Evolution is not quite as easy as everyone assumes it is.

What do you mean by evolution being "easy"?

Evolution, at its core, strives for only one thing: propagation of the species.

Even if we agree to attribute intentions to evolution (rhetorically or otherwise), and to narrow the concept of evolution to adaptation through gene transmission/recombination/mutation/selection, you can just as well argue that evolution "strives for" stable ecosystems or, as you argue below, for a better habitat for our microscopic guests.

Taken to this level, it's a wonder that everyone isn't spending their time either at drunken orgies, or fighting each other to get into the drunken orgies.

Why so?

Somehow, "civilization", "culture", and "society" have guided human development away from that model - and I don't presume to know how it happened.

It doesn't surprise me that constructive competitiveness in a social setting is evolutionarily stable before shortsighted, greedy selfishness. Other less intelligent animals have developed social behaviours. The surprising thing would be that a species with more brainpower to spare wouldn't have figured that out eventually.

I don't mean to downplay culture as a factor. But I don't see a dichotomy between culture and "evolution"; I see fuzzy borders and much interplay between genetic and cultural evolution, in most of our history as a species.

The fact that culture evolves much faster than genes and is the overriding adaptation factor doesn't mean genetic influence is going away just as fast. Much on the contrary, the relative slowness of genetic evolution serves to explain why we carry such a legacy of behavioral tendencies so long after its original usefulness has faded.

Although most of us don't spend our lives in endless orgies and fights, it's easy to observe some ancestral substrate that makes many of us basically prone to promiscuity and domination (although I don't think those are the only evolutionarily stable heuristics, even in a selfish scope). The cultural rules that keep these instincts at line can't be wholly attributed to reason either; genetically driven social tendencies play an important part too.

Taken to the extreme, why have we even developed arms, legs, eyes, ears, and minds? Simple bacterial reproduction does just fine.

I don't get what you are trying to prove here. What is your explanation for the fact that we developed those things?

In fact, there is so much bacteria in our gut and sinuses that 90% of the DNA molecules in our bodies are foreign. One begins to wonder, then, whose purpose our human bodies really serve.

Again, that's a matter of interpretation. Applying the concepts of "purpose" and "serving" to these topics is like carrying our everyday physical intuitions when we are discussing relativity theory. I think it's often more a trap than a help.

With that caveat, I'd say our bodies "serve", at different levels, our own cells and mythocondria, alien microorganisms living within them, ourselves as individuals, other humans and animals for whom our net influence is positive, society as a whole, and the Earth's ecosystem.

Yes, even if we are screwing up Earth as we know it, we are "helping" it become Earth as our children will know it. I have no reason to believe Earth "prefers" either version. Whatever the outcome, it will have turned out the most evolutionarily stable one.

Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by hobbs on Tuesday April 01, 2008 @11:01AM (#152085)
Interesting points. I think your comments help elucidate my point that evolution is not so simple as to be glibly thrown around as the reason for every human behavior.

>> Taken to the extreme, why have we even developed arms, legs, eyes, ears, and minds? Simple bacterial reproduction does just fine.

> I don't get what you are trying to prove here. What is your explanation for the fact that we developed those things?

Back to my point, everyone assumes that evolution simply means "survival of the fittest" or the "propagation of the gene". If that's all there is to it, there's no obvious explanation for the emergence of higher-order organisms, since bacterial reproduction provides by far the most efficient mechanism for copying genes. All this is to say that the devil is in the details and there is actually quite a bit more to evolution than what is taught in 7th grade biology.

Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by asdflkj on Monday March 31, 2008 @12:52PM (#151203)
Evolution, at its core, strives for only one thing: propagation of the species.

No, actually. The one thing it strives for is propagation of the genes, not the species. Read The Selfish Gene, by Richard Dawkins. It will make things clearer.

Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by hobbs on Monday March 31, 2008 @12:59PM (#151207)
Sorry. I over-simplified. (or under-simplified?) I have read it and its basic idea was, in fact, the basis of my statement.
Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by neilc on Monday March 31, 2008 @08:42PM (#151580)
In fact, the basic idea of The Selfish Gene is precisely a rejection of your previous statement: according to Dawkins, evolution is not concerned with the "propagation of the species", but with the propagation of individual genes. It is merely incidental that this sometimes results in competition among "survival machines", which happen to be grouped into species.
Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by logjam on Monday March 31, 2008 @06:27PM (#151425)
> Somehow, "civilization", "culture", and "society" have guided human development away from that model.

Nonsense. If that's your "statement", it's wrong. The entire field of sociobiology (read Wilson) speaks to phenomenon like "civilization", "culture", and "society" being driven solely by nucleotide replication.

Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by hobbs on Monday March 31, 2008 @07:22PM (#151489)
> ... - and I don't presume to know how it happened.

Like I said, I only know enough to know that I can't comfortably refer to evolution to explain human nature. My point is that I doubt that most people who do reference evolution are familiar with the likes of sociobiology either.

Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by jsomers on Monday March 31, 2008 @01:53PM (#151229)
"Simple bacterial reproduction does just fine."

Sure, until one bacterium in your neighborhood starts working out---then you better hit the gym, too. Onwards and upwards.

Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by hobbs on Monday March 31, 2008 @02:15PM (#151246)
Considering that there are a billion times more copies of bacterial genes than any other, I'd say that "upwards" isn't a better way to propogate the gene: http://www.stephenjaygould.org/library/gould_bacteria.html
Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by aggieben on Monday March 31, 2008 @12:37PM (#151187)
Occam's Razor suggests that PG works with startups because he thinks they're better, not that he thinks they're better because he works with them. He is rich enough to work on whatever he wants.

Huh? I think you'd have to know pg pretty darn well before being able to apply Occam's Razor to the logic of his preferences. It seems perfectly reasonable to me to think that pg works with startups because he thinks they'd be better because he works with them.

It also seems to me that might be a distinction between work and play: you work on the things you work on to make them better, you play with the things you play with because they are better.

Lastly, if you think startups are better, and that you can make them better by working with them, then it seems like the perfect combination of work and play (read: passion), and Occam's Razor isn't needed.

Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by asdflkj on Monday March 31, 2008 @01:54PM (#151232)
It seems perfectly reasonable to me to think that pg works with startups because he thinks they'd be better because he works with them.

You know what else would be better if PG worked with it? Potholes in the street. So why doesn't PG work with potholes, or any of the infinity of other things he could be working with, and making better? The obvious answer: because he thinks startups are neat, as opposed to potholes, or big companies.

Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by aggieben on Tuesday April 01, 2008 @08:48AM (#151955)
My disagreement was directed at your use of Occam's Razor (which didn't even make sense), not on whether pg thinks startups are neat. Clearly, he does.
Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by smopburrito on Monday March 31, 2008 @12:25PM (#151174)
>Then why does happiness exist? Why hasn't it been eradicated millions of years ago? Answer: because it serves a purpose. It's how evolution tells the organism, "keep doing what you're doing".

like the purpose of leadership/management/social groups it can be taken to a detrimental level. example: addiction. "keep doing what you're doing at all costs, care about nothing else, even if it kills you or otherwise destroys your life."

>A creature that's perpetually dissatisfied, always striving for advantage, wins out over a creature that's happy.

I, too, thought this statement was conspicuously unsupported by any evidence (which is part of what i thought the author disagreed with). moreover, it is in direct contradiction to the parenthetical that it preceeds (are we to take it that monks "override... unhappiness" in order to lose out?)