News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rod Vagg's statement on the request to be removed from th... by bhouston on Friday August 25, 2017 @06:05PM (#15102606)
Too much drama and polemics. My god he spent a lot of time on that response -- like hours.

If you are writing long emails dealing with responses to drama, you need to move on. Not because you are at fault but the whole situation is screwed up and not worth your time. This is not a win-win situation, but an everyone lose situation.

It means you and others are in the muck. Once you get a bunch of these accusations and long polemical post flying around it is nearly impossible to figure out who is right and who is wrong. The way people try to win here is ultra long polemical posts, secret discussions, accusations, character assassinations, etc. Non of which is at all productive.

Being in the muck is a huge waste of time and energy for everyone. Find something that doesn't involve so much drama, life is short.

I think one rule in software development is that once you are engaging in polemics, especially many hours of it per day, and not technical matters, something is sick about the situation -- get out of it.

Re:Rod Vagg's statement on the request to be removed from th... by eric_b on Friday August 25, 2017 @06:27PM (#15102757)
Was "Polemic" in your word of the day email or something?

Anyways, Rod's character is being assassinated on the internet. Prospective employers could Google his name and all they'll see is one side of things, unless he attempts to defend himself.

Additionally - the people wielding the pitchforks want him to just give up. At some point it's important for people to take a stand if they believe in their principles - or maybe I'm just old fashioned.

Re:Rod Vagg's statement on the request to be removed from th... by bhouston on Friday August 25, 2017 @06:43PM (#15102857)
This is a polemic: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polemic

It is not a means of trying to fix the issue, but rather a strong worded, accusatory, defensive blast at his critics by someone who believes they were wronged and others are at fault.

This is not a "how to get to yes" type response, but rather a response that just inflames a situation, and causes everyone to dig in.

There is going to be no winner going down this path, just losers all around and a lot of wasted energy and time.

Yuk.

Re:Rod Vagg's statement on the request to be removed from th... by eric_b on Friday August 25, 2017 @06:50PM (#15102890)
Sounds like you'd already made up your mind about Rod, and weren't keen to hear the other side.

I, on the other hand, was curious to read his version of things so I'm glad he took the time to offer a detailed reply. After reading his "polemic" I felt he was rational, composed, and defended his actions and character rather well. I came to the conclusion that the pitchfork wielding folks were slinging a lot of unsubstantiated accusations that look a lot like moral authoritarianism.

My read was that he diffused a lot of possible indignation and inflammation with his word choice and tone. He was more conciliatory than I would have been in his position.

Re:Rod Vagg's statement on the request to be removed from th... by bhouston on Friday August 25, 2017 @07:01PM (#15102943)
> Sounds like you'd already made up your mind about Rod, and weren't keen to hear the other side.

I actually only read his side, although I stopped after a couple screen fulls as I recognized from experience that what I was reading was not a productive response to the situation at hand, but a defensive one.

Re:Rod Vagg's statement on the request to be removed from th... by dmpk2k on Friday August 25, 2017 @08:08PM (#15103271)
Of course it's a defensive one. He's the person being accused! ಠ_ಠ

God forbid someone defend themselves after being publicly and on-record dragged through the mud. This isn't going away for him even if he stepped down and disappeared from the scene entirely.

Re:Rod Vagg's statement on the request to be removed from th... by kuyan on Friday August 25, 2017 @07:38PM (#15103125)
> I recognized from experience that what I was reading was not a productive response to the situation at hand, but a defensive one.

What would a productive response be? I agree that getting unnecessarily mired in drama is counterproductive, but I don't think that these accusations could have been reasonably ignored, nor do I know what Rod could (or should) have done differently.

Re:Rod Vagg's statement on the request to be removed from th... by bhouston on Friday August 25, 2017 @08:21PM (#15103340)
In real-life, outside of 10,000 word github issues, one should call those you are having problems with and talk about it. That is how you resolve these issues. You show empathy, you show understanding, you take more responsibility that you deserve because you have a strong ego, you focus on the future and how best to achieve joint success, you show some flexibility, you get a mutually beneficial resolution or an agreed plan of action that should lead to a better outcome. This is best done on a one-by-one basis. And people come to your side or at least understand you.

You need to not be accusatory, nor defensive.

This is the age old way of dealing with issues in a productive fashion. Read getting to "Getting to yes" or try getting married.

What I read in this github issue is just immature, very ineffective problem solving from I guess someone who doesn't know better.

Re:Rod Vagg's statement on the request to be removed from th... by echaozh on Friday August 25, 2017 @10:36PM (#15103756)
When people defame you in the public, to talk to people in the private don't solve all the problems. The public need to hear from both sides.

You don't like to hear the defense, all right. Just don't try to stop other people from hearing it.

Re:Rod Vagg's statement on the request to be removed from th... by bhouston on Saturday August 26, 2017 @06:19AM (#15104866)
> When people defame you in the public, to talk to people in the private don't solve all the problems. The public need to hear from both sides.

Only if you want to run a negative sum game for all involved. This is a horrible strategy to engage in. You only end up also wrecking your own reputation and others and wasting a ton of time.

The socially mature thing to do is resolve this behind closed doors and be flexible as I suggested.

He may get some success by playing the martyr, but it will be success that occurs by his aggression, stubbornness and by expending more efforts in polemics than others. In the end he might still be standing but everyone around him will be wounded metaphorically because of this (mostly via huge wastes of time because of difficult conversations and departures of people from the project.)

Anyone who wants to run a company focused on results and to avoid unnecessary drama should avoid this type of character like the plague.

This behavior he is currently engaging in is a huge red flag if you recognize it for what it is.

Again, he is engaging in a strategy that forces everyone into a negative sum game, which is itself a form of aggression -- and it is easy to recognize from this github issue as I've seen this before close up. It is not a smart thing to do and should have been avoided by doing things differently long ago.

He can still pull up by basically retracting all of this and re-engaging in a mature and flexible manner that shows some contrition/empathy -- but that requires a strong ego, social maturity, and flexibility which may not be something that is possible on his part at this time. Everyone he is dealing with would love that I am sure, even at this stage, because it will stop the negative sum game.

Re:Rod Vagg's statement on the request to be removed from th... by phiskk on Saturday August 26, 2017 @10:43AM (#15105646)
This isn't unnecessary drama on Rod's part. He is standing in the line of fire to shield the rest of his community from a McCarthyesque witchhunt conducted by SJWs, who are the real source of the drama.
Re:Rod Vagg's statement on the request to be removed from th... by CrystalLangUser on Monday August 28, 2017 @10:25AM (#15116708)
Once someone drags your name through the mud in public, it's well past the point of having a private chat. His behavior isn't a huge red flag in the slightest; he's responding to what's essentially a public attack of his character. Responding to something like that publicly when it's already a public situation isn't a form of aggression.

You are projecting WAY too much of your own bias and opinion into what was simply a response. It's telling that you're suggesting he needs to have social maturity when the allegations levied against him are pretty unsubstantiated- see the "evidence" of him retweeting an article discussing free speech concerns on college campuses.

Are you genuinely so obtuse as to scorn a man who's attempting to merely respond to being accused of something?

Re:Rod Vagg's statement on the request to be removed from th... by bhouston on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:16PM (#15120142)
If the allegations were unsubstantiated it would not have gotten this far, especially if he dealt with this in a mature fashion by engaging and showing he is just a reasonable person. If they were totally unsubstantiated the only way it would get to this point is because he dealt with it in the worst ways possiblle.

People wouldn't have quit to make what is essentially a useless fork if it were truly unsubstantiated. Those people are truly angry about what happened. This means there was something to resolve but it wasn't resolved, we just get grandstanding and massive effort into polemical defenses.

He tactically argues like a really smart guy, but his overall strategy is the wrong one.

Re:Rod Vagg's statement on the request to be removed from th... by freeone3000 on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @02:34PM (#15126537)
This reads akin to the logic behind a witch hunt - a bunch of people are very upset at a person, therefore the person must be a witch. I disagree with the premise.

The people are indisputibly angry. They may have reason to be angry. I don't see it, but they may have it. But the entire line that "he's accused, therefore he must be guilty" is flawed.

Re:Rod Vagg's statement on the request to be removed from th... by CrystalLangUser on Monday August 28, 2017 @10:38PM (#15121725)
If it was substantiated there would be evidence. I see nothing beyond inane things that aren't worth this fuss.

It seems like another example of CoCs being used maliciously to hunt someone out of bias.

Re:Rod Vagg's statement on the request to be removed from th... by palimpsests on Saturday August 26, 2017 @01:43PM (#15106478)
bhouston's statements are far more nuanced than saying that they don't want to hear the defense or attempting to prevent others from hearing it.
Re:Rod Vagg's statement on the request to be removed from th... by phiskk on Saturday August 26, 2017 @09:44AM (#15105394)
Perhaps you should be telling this to those who launched a witchhunt against Rod because he undermined their oppression tool. They certainly didn't try to "call those you are having problems with and talk about it."
Re:Rod Vagg's statement on the request to be removed from th... by phiskk on Friday August 25, 2017 @07:31PM (#15103074)
When people have already mounted an attack, a polite defense seems a very reasonable response.
Re:Rod Vagg's statement on the request to be removed from th... by hoorayimhelping on Friday August 25, 2017 @07:53PM (#15103199)
>I actually only read his side, although I stopped after a couple screen fulls as I recognized from experience...

So what you're saying is you made up your mind (based on past experience) and weren't really keen to read the full text because of that?