News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pandas and Lobsters: Why Google Cannot Build Social Appli... by wallflower on Monday July 12, 2010 @11:00PM (#1510222)
One of the more colorful, stream-of-consciousness opinions to appear on News.YC. Some interesting observations in the prognostications.

> Google FAILED in acquiring and integrating other social products. Blogger, Picasa, JotSpot, Dodgeball, Jaiku. None are their category leaders now. Some are dead. Why?

Metaphorically, foursquare rose from the ashes of Dodgeball.

> Google cannot hire a Head of Social because no individual can change Google's DNA of building applications for pandas, not lobsters.

I wonder what Marissa Mayer thinks about Google's role in Social. I'm sure they have something in the labs... but you can't grow a social network in a petri dish.

Now I can see why Facebook probably won't ever merge with Google. It would be like an arranged marriage.

Android is the wildcard wildebeast. Mobile phones are inherently social.

Re:Pandas and Lobsters: Why Google Cannot Build Social Appli... by benologist on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @12:28AM (#1510368)
Someone will probably build a huge and successful social whatever on Android, and maybe even the one that dethrones Facebook.

But it won't be Google.

Re:Pandas and Lobsters: Why Google Cannot Build Social Appli... by byoung2 on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @10:48AM (#1511514)
But it won't be Google.

Then Google will buy them

Re:Pandas and Lobsters: Why Google Cannot Build Social Appli... by waterlesscloud on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @12:28AM (#1510365)
Mobile phones, maybe, but pocket computers? I'm not so sure they're inherently social. Not completely so, anyway. They have a lot of utility beyond communication, and that may dilute their socialness to the point that it's no longer central.
Re:Pandas and Lobsters: Why Google Cannot Build Social Appli... by roc on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @12:13PM (#1511795)
> "Mobile phones, maybe, but pocket computers?"

If it has a data connection, then yes. If it does not, then no.

A PC has all sorts of utility; none of which dilutes its "social-ness" once it has a data connection.

Re:Pandas and Lobsters: Why Google Cannot Build Social Appli... by gcb on Thursday July 15, 2010 @01:53PM (#1518530)
true. no matter how advanced is your device, it must be connected.

google realized that a while ago. Anyone remember all the fuss with free wifi and darknet?

my bet is that it's now trying a more subtle approach. Andoid thetering via open wifi hotstop by default, anyone?

Btw, as my personal "fuck you" to AT&T i make my android became a open hotspot over 3G every time it's charging.

Re:Pandas and Lobsters: Why Google Cannot Build Social Appli... by mikeryan on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @12:36PM (#1511884)
"Metaphorically, foursquare rose from the ashes of Dodgeball."

I'm not reading your point, do you consider foursquare a success for Google?